News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My mum was a 17-year-old free spirit so she was locked up... by nekusar on Sunday November 16, 2025 @02:58PM (#45947923)
So we're supposed to simultaneously discuss the article (General Franco's extremist Catholic task forces), but not identify the religious tropes behind this?

I read the article, and discussing the article. And as hackers, im curious as how to fix the problems.

Re:My mum was a 17-year-old free spirit so she was locked up... by dang on Sunday November 16, 2025 @03:30PM (#45948138)
You can discuss things like that without denouncing entire groups of people and without inflammatory rhetoric.

It's not hard to understand where the line is if you've reviewed https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and genuinely want to use HN as intended.

Re:My mum was a 17-year-old free spirit so she was locked up... by LexiMax on Sunday November 16, 2025 @07:38PM (#45949865)
Dang. Sweetie. Pumpkin.

Nobody is intimidated by threats of banishment from HN. It is far too easy to register a new account and continue posting. Within a few weeks, someone can get their flagging privilages back. Within a few months, they can have downvotes.

Most threads of any controversy are rotten with bad faith throwaways. Do they get banned? Maybe... But they can just register a new account and continue doing the same things that got them banned.

If you care about HN as a community, you need to reconsider some fundamental aspects of how this site works.

Re:My mum was a 17-year-old free spirit so she was locked up... by DontForgetMe on Monday November 17, 2025 @02:59PM (#45957564)
I mean, of all the many, many talking points from the article 'This particular religious / cultural group is a global problem and must be eradicated, and (all of? Seems like it meant all of) its many billions of members are enthusiastic supporters or perpetrators of child abuse' is not one that leapt out to most people.

And even if it did, they didn't say it here. This is not the place for religious ideology. I passionately hate my neighbours who listen to music really loudly in their garden all the time, but I don't call for their eradication on public fora unless there's a really, really specific relevance (like here, for example) and I also don't campaign against them on GitHub, my local supermarket, local government meetings, or other places where people are trying to do other things.

There are places for me to rant about my neighbours. There are entire discussions about noisy neighbours, my vicinity, local customs and manners etc. If I wanted to rant about them, those would be the place to do it. But I don't, because I wouldn't actually gain anything from it. I'm not going to single handedly change the law on nuisance, and all a hate campaign could achieve would be, well, more hate. I want solutions, or quiet, and I won't achieve either of those by telling random strangers how terrible my neighbours are.

I'm sure you can think of the easiest solution to the hypothetical neighbour problem. It's not ideological and doesn't involve changing the hearts and minds of hundreds of people, none of whom are currently concerned about my neighbours.

It might look like I'm trivialising your point, but I promise, I'm not. Noisy neighbours, or an itchy foot, or even a literal broken fingernail, are a more immediate problem than 'we must rid the world of Christians', unless they are currently holding you hostage.

And the reason I'm bothering to write such a long-ass reply at all is because there is currently far too much intolerance and ethno-religious hatred being propogated and spread around the world. We know where this leads. It always leads the same way, there is no possibility of a happy ending. We have tried 'that religion is the problem, let's persecute them' repeatedly and we end up in the sort of fascist dystopia we were reminded of literal moments ago in the article.

It's not ok to do it to Jews or Muslims, which means it's not ok to do it to Christians. And it's not ok to let people spread those messages in bad faith, which means I've got to call out those spreading the same message in presumed good faith.

My neighbours are just annoying me, I can deal with that. Christians are just kinda weird but whatever, we've all got our foibles. Racists, dogmatics and puritans can believe whatever they want, I just won't listen to it.

And I invite you to step away from the brewing culture war too. It's more fun discussing tech and stuff.