News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SSL Configuration Generator by ranger_danger on Friday November 14, 2025 @09:55PM (#45934668)
Lots of people, I certainly don't trust free providers, and I think it's a lot less likely that malware will use a non-free cert, so some people trust those more. Plus there are email, code-signing and other cert types that aren't provided for free.
Re:SSL Configuration Generator by ekr____ on Friday November 14, 2025 @10:48PM (#45934902)
What does it mean not to trust Let's Encrypt in this case? What is it you are concerned they will do?
Re:SSL Configuration Generator by ranger_danger on Friday November 14, 2025 @10:58PM (#45934943)
I worry that the CA is somehow compromised (state actor holding private keys, etc).
Re:SSL Configuration Generator by nixosbestos on Friday November 14, 2025 @11:48PM (#45935121)
I would have that concern, at minimum 100x more with random shitty unreliable SSL providers, than those being run by literal huge nerds and non-profits. Your analysis here is thin and lazy and that's being generous to your analysis.
Re:SSL Configuration Generator by alwillis on Saturday November 15, 2025 @02:33AM (#45935710)
> I worry that the CA is somehow compromised (state actor holding private keys, etc).

"Somehow" is doing a lot work in that sentence.

Operationally, there's no difference between the security procedures and requirements that a for-profit or a non-profit CA must adhere to.

Re:SSL Configuration Generator by alwillis on Saturday November 15, 2025 @02:40AM (#45935739)
BTW, all the recent certificate shenanigans have invovled for-profit CAs [1].

[1]: https://sslmate.com/resources/certificate_authority_failures

Re:SSL Configuration Generator by ranger_danger on Saturday November 15, 2025 @07:56AM (#45937127)
I still believe in "if it's free, you are the product."
Re:SSL Configuration Generator by alwillis on Saturday November 15, 2025 @11:55AM (#45938735)
In what way is a non-profit such as Lets Encrypt attempting to monetize their customer relationships? They've issued more 700 million certificates at no cost.

While I don't get the cynicism in this case, you would agree supporting a secure web is in the public interest, right?

Re:SSL Configuration Generator by ranger_danger on Saturday November 15, 2025 @12:05PM (#45938826)
I wasn't referring to monetization, but government surveillance.
Re:SSL Configuration Generator by edoceo on Saturday November 15, 2025 @03:08PM (#45940203)
How would they surveil? And also, have you disabled the certs you don't trust from these providers on your systems?
Re:SSL Configuration Generator by nixosbestos on Saturday November 15, 2025 @06:08PM (#45941321)
Lol!! I'll donate $100k to charity if they disabled the LE root. But of course they didn't. Because they're ignorantly babbling about a topic they have no idea about.
Re:SSL Configuration Generator by IgorPartola on Saturday November 15, 2025 @11:58AM (#45938763)
To each their own, but you do realize that you are using a free website running on free software secured by free TLS libraries transmitted via routers that often run free software and firmware? Also how much did you pay for the browser you used to make these comments?

There is a sea of difference between something like Google/Facebook/TikTok and Let’s Encrypt/the Linux Foundation/FSF/etc. I can only assume you can’t see that difference if you have spent no time reading about these things, but I would encourage you to. This stuff is important especially if you get to make security decisions for any kind of product.

Re:SSL Configuration Generator by ekr____ on Saturday November 15, 2025 @02:06PM (#45939770)
Thanks for explaining.

I think this concern is reflects a misunderstanding of how the security of the WebPKI works. Specifically, any CA can issue certificates for your domain whether you are their customer or not. What that means is that if CA #1 is compromised but you choose CA #2, CA #1 can still be used to attack connections to your domain.

The situation is slightly worse if the CA you actually use is compromised because the main defense we have against misissuance is Certificate Transparency, and it's easier to detect that a certificate was issued by a CA you don't use than that too many certificates were issued by a CA you do use, but it's just slightly easier.

The bottom line here is that if you are worried about some group of CAs being compromised, then using a different CA doesn't help you much.

Re:SSL Configuration Generator by ranger_danger on Saturday November 15, 2025 @02:13PM (#45939819)
Yes I understand all of that, but I still choose to trust free services less.

Of course the (more secure?) alternative would be to generate self-signed certs, but for customer-facing sites that's a big UX problem.

Re:SSL Configuration Generator by ekr____ on Saturday November 15, 2025 @02:29PM (#45939934)
> Yes I understand all of that, but I still choose to trust free services less.

Well, you can choose to do whatever you want, but given that you're posting to a public forum, it would be helpful if you actually explained your reasoning.

> Of course the (more secure?) alternative would be to generate self-signed certs, but for customer-facing sites that's a big UX problem.

It's not just a big UX problem, it's a big security problem, because the customers have no way of knowing if your certificate is actually valid.

Re:SSL Configuration Generator by nixosbestos on Saturday November 15, 2025 @06:00PM (#45941257)
> it would be helpful if you actually explained your reasoning.

It's exceedingly clear that's not going to happen, and I think we all know why. Good reminder to anyone that anyone can just post here. Including people that logic-lessly think that paying a shitty third party that probably has a bad track record is somehow better than using LE. Like, this isn't a serious conversation?

Re:SSL Configuration Generator by nixosbestos on Friday November 14, 2025 @10:52PM (#45934921)
> Lots of people,

I started holding my breath

> I certainly don't trust free providers

And not for long - there it is. SMH, also fucking LOL.

EDIT: Just going to throw this out here for those that need to hear it, if you have to include "many people are saying it [wide hand gesture], bigly!", you know, consider other people are going to roll their eyes immediately and that maybe your opinion is not as widely shared as you arrogantly presume and assert?

---

> think it's a lot less likely that malware will use a non-free cert, so some people trust those more

Wait, WTAF are you talking about? Yes, the exactly zero people on their earth that check the green padlock for a root CA... to... vibe check the issuer. What an intensely silly comment.

---

> Plus there are email, code-signing and other cert types that aren't provided for free.

just.... just lol.

Re:SSL Configuration Generator by oarsinsync on Saturday November 15, 2025 @03:38AM (#45935954)
> I certainly don't trust free providers

What does this mean in practice? Do you remove the free providers from your OS & browser trust stores? Does this mean you get warnings every time you visit a site that uses LetsEncrypt (and other free providers)?