Re:Incorporate your startup only when you’re forced to
by georgemcbay on Saturday September 29, 2012 @03:11PM
(#4590540)
"Read that whole thread carefully before you decide whether or not you're willing to spend ~$150, the equivalent of a month's Starbucks habit, to do business as an LLC with contract liability protection."
YMMV on the $150. In California that covers the upfront costs for setting up an LLC, but be aware that one year later (and each year after that until you dissolve the LLC) you will receive a tax bill from the state of $800, regardless of whether or not your LLC made a penny.
Re:Incorporate your startup only when you’re forced to
by tisme on Saturday September 29, 2012 @03:27PM
(#4590579)
$150 or $1000 might be enough to swing the decision about where to incorporate for some instances but for most that is a rounding error. And anyway, all expenses that you are going to have should be part of your businessplan when you're at the go/no go stage. If $800 scares you then you're not doing business.
Re:Incorporate your startup only when you’re forced to
by georgemcbay on Saturday September 29, 2012 @10:43PM
(#4591781)
I don't disagree that the difference between $150 and $1000 isn't a huge deal for any serious venture, but the topic of this conversation covers a wide range of possible levels of seriousness and some people suggest always incorporating even for goofing-around projects but those people never go into the fact that incorporating in some states will cost you some serious dough in minimum yearly taxes.
Read that whole thread carefully before you decide whether or not you're willing to spend ~$150, the equivalent of a month's Starbucks habit, to do business as an LLC with contract liability protection. That thread is a perfectly ordinary situation that business founders routinely find themselves in.
If you're not going to be entering into contracts and you're not going to be conducting business transactions as a vendor to other businesses and you're not going to be employing people, I don't have a strong opinion about whether you incorporate. On the other hand, those are pretty important things for a business to do.
To that, I will only add that the meme that incorporation harms your chances of being funded is, in a word, horseshit. If your corp structure is simple, as with a Delaware or home state LLC, and your ownership structure is simple, then the cost of converting it to a C Corp is a small constant factor added to the cost of incorporating as a C Corp to begin with. If your structure isn't simple, you clearly didn't have a choice between incorporating or not. There are corporate structures that make it very annoying to get back to the "clean slate" investors want you to be at, and my gut is that this is the concern animating things like "don't incorporate if you don't have to". If your company is amazing, people will invest even if some crazy guy in the woods claims to own 90% of it; if it's not amazing, an LLC isn't going to push you off the bubble.
Corollary: if you don't know the difference between a C Corp and an LLC, then your default position should be "get an LLC ASAP", because you don't know enough to be making this decision based on some dude's blog post.
Late edit: I went and looked for LLC->C conversion costs and found a Quora post from a startup lawyer suggesting ~$1000, and, as I expected, that the costs mostly involve working around the need for unanimous consent from all the members of the LLC, which in small new LLCs where all the members are still active, unanimous consent isn't a big deal.