BrowserID (Persona) took me minutes to implement. On a non-trivial project, it may take a couple hours. The beauty of this is the fact that it still works without built-in browser support. It's designed to be a forwards-compatible API that only becomes more usable with time.
Additionally, email is an excellent way to establish a user's identity, and the fact that it's designed around email makes it easy for a regular person to understand its authentication flow.
The problem with SSL is that it is an all-or-nothing technology. There's a chicken and egg problem: people won't make good UI for it until it's widely used, but people won't use it until it has a good UI. Persona provides an implementation of BrowserID that has a decent UI, and the user experience will only get better with time as more people use it. The chicken/egg problem is solved there, but two-way SSL right now is practically unusable for anyone who isn't very familiar with it (most people). Using an email address is very familiar, though.
I couldn't be happier with a signin solution. It even complements my legacy solution very well, you can see a demo at http://www.yourpane.com (click "Persona", never mind the email field.)
How will my mom log in to an SSL-certificate-requesting site from another computer?
That said, I'd love they succeed and we have finally something that works well and it's not under company-X's control.
With OpenID, the result of the site redirecting you to the IdP (and then the IdP redirecting you back to the site) is that the IdP can get a trail of every website you're trying to log into. That's pretty fundamental to the way OpenID is designed.
In Persona you will just click a button (because your browser knows your IDP) and then optionally sign in to your IDP. A huge difference.
If we're going to have browser support anyway, I'd rather just use standard two-way SSL and put the work into developing better UI and private key distribution systems for it. It's even more secure and has a great user experience once you've set up the key in the browser and authorized it to the site.