News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenAI may not use lyrics without license, German court r... by sidewndr46 on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @11:56AM (#45889682)
You're using the phrase "actually legal" when the ruling in fact meant it wasn't piracy after the change. Training on the shredded books was not piracy. Training on the books they downloaded was piracy. That is where the damages come from.

Nothing in the ruling says it is legal to start outputting and selling content based off the results of that training process.

Re:OpenAI may not use lyrics without license, German court r... by rpdillon on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @12:10PM (#45889935)
I think your first paragraph is entirely congruent with my first two paragraphs.

Your second paragraph is not what I'm discussing right now, and was not ruled on in the case you're referring to. I fully expect that, generally speaking, infringement will be on the users of the AI, rather than the models themselves, when it all gets sorted out.

Re:OpenAI may not use lyrics without license, German court r... by sidewndr46 on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @12:30PM (#45890238)
I'm in agreement that it will be targeted at the users of AI as well. Once that prevails legally someone will try litigating against the users and the AI corporations as a common group.
Re:OpenAI may not use lyrics without license, German court r... by gruez on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @12:00PM (#45889772)
>Nothing in the ruling says it is legal to start outputting and selling content based off the results of that training process.

Nothing says it's illegal, either. If anything the courts are leaning towards it being legal, assuming it's not trained on pirated materials.

>A federal judge dealt the case a mixed ruling in June, finding that training AI chatbots on copyrighted books wasn't illegal but that Anthropic wrongfully acquired millions of books through pirate websites.

https://www.npr.org/2025/09/05/g-s1-87367/anthropic-authors-...