News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Drilling Down on Uncle Sam's Proposed TP-Link Ban by eru on Sunday November 09, 2025 @11:18PM (#45872380)
The question is whether you want to interfere in the freedom of contract for this.

Almost all software everywhere comes with a 'no liability' clause. And arguable, open source couldn't exist without it.

The exceptions where liability is wanted negotiate that specifically.

Re:Drilling Down on Uncle Sam's Proposed TP-Link Ban by otterley on Sunday November 09, 2025 @11:27PM (#45872432)
There is precedent, for example, lemon laws related to automobiles. Unfortunately, governments have ceased to care for consumers like they once did.
Re:Drilling Down on Uncle Sam's Proposed TP-Link Ban by eru on Monday November 10, 2025 @01:06AM (#45872933)
Consumers can care for themselves, if we let them.
Re:Drilling Down on Uncle Sam's Proposed TP-Link Ban by otterley on Monday November 10, 2025 @12:17PM (#45878167)
Respectfully, I think you have too much faith in the ability and general desire of individuals to protect themselves. Consider how successful scams and security breaches are. Consider, too, the unequal bargaining power between vendors and individual consumers (have you ever tried to negotiate a form contract with a megacorporation?).

We protect people because they have failed. These regulations tend to follow actual injuries; they are rarely promulgated in anticipation of them.

Re:Drilling Down on Uncle Sam's Proposed TP-Link Ban by eru on Monday November 10, 2025 @07:54PM (#45882859)
> Consider, too, the unequal bargaining power between vendors and individual consumers (have you ever tried to negotiate a form contract with a megacorporation?).

You don't negotiate the contents of your burger with McDonald's. If you don't like it, you go to Burger King or have a Döner Kebab.

There's plenty of tacit negotiations here.

> We protect people because they have failed. These regulations tend to follow actual injuries; they are rarely promulgated in anticipation of them.

Homeopathic medicine tend to follow actual health problems, too. That doesn't mean they are a good idea.

Re:Drilling Down on Uncle Sam's Proposed TP-Link Ban by otterley on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @01:48AM (#45884750)
> You don't negotiate the contents of your burger with McDonald's. If you don't like it, you go to Burger King or have a Döner Kebab.

Not every industry is a competitive one with practically unlimited choices. Natural monopolies or industries with high barriers to entry tend to have the most leverage over their customers. Most people have only a single electricity provider, and there are only two major mobile OS vendors worth speaking of.

> Homeopathic medicine tend to follow actual health problems, too. That doesn't mean they are a good idea.

Some work; some don’t. The key is figuring out which solutions are effective and which aren’t. Nobody is proposing keeping fixes around whose costs aren’t worth the benefits to society.

Re:Drilling Down on Uncle Sam's Proposed TP-Link Ban by SkiFire13 on Monday November 10, 2025 @01:36AM (#45873067)
> And arguable, open source couldn't exist without it.

Couldn't you just include selling a product or a licence for it as a requirement?

Re:Drilling Down on Uncle Sam's Proposed TP-Link Ban by eru on Monday November 10, 2025 @02:21AM (#45873316)
The GPL is a license.
Re:Drilling Down on Uncle Sam's Proposed TP-Link Ban by NekkoDroid on Monday November 10, 2025 @07:30AM (#45875306)
selling a product or license

Generally most GPL'd software isn't sold (terms and conditions may apply).

Re:Drilling Down on Uncle Sam's Proposed TP-Link Ban by eru on Monday November 10, 2025 @07:50PM (#45882832)
IBM used to sell you the computer, and the software was free. The industry could resurrect that practice as a loophole.
Re:Drilling Down on Uncle Sam's Proposed TP-Link Ban by NekkoDroid on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @05:27AM (#45885852)
If you sell the computer with the software preinstalled it would still fall under the selling a product part. So if you'd want to actually have a loophole you'd at best be selling the product without any software, and we both know how well that would go with the masses.
Re:Drilling Down on Uncle Sam's Proposed TP-Link Ban by eru on Thursday November 13, 2025 @07:50AM (#45914300)
> [...] and we both know how well that would go with the masses.

Pretty well, actually, as long as you can download the software for free.