Re:FAA restricts commercial rocket launches indefinitely due...
by rogerrogerr on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:12AM
(#45857694)
Opposing Bases a few weeks ago had feedback from someone who had a button on their transponder that didn’t work and needed a code without any 5’s in it. Good luck getting _that_ through to auto-ATC.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:FAA restricts commercial rocket launches indefinitely due...
by terminalshort on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:42AM
(#45858002)
Can emit all bytes except for 00000101 isn't really the type of problem you see in a digital system. And even if it were, it's pretty simple.
plane 1 > assign code 4563
plane 2 > reject
plane 1 > assign code 0827
plane 2 > accept
Also assigning short codes like that isn't something likely to be necessary in an automated protocol like this. Why not just have every message sent between 2 planes include a sender_id: UUID header?
Re:FAA restricts commercial rocket launches indefinitely due...
by rogerrogerr on Saturday November 08, 2025 @12:08PM
(#45858200)
Because now we’re talking about putting deeply integrated equipment in every plane. It’s a certification and cost nightmare.
This is not a system where you get to do clean slate greenfield development. Whatever you do must work for the lowest common denominator. ATC is a fairly cheap societal expense compared to developing, certifying, installing, and maintaining systems with the level of integration you want in hundreds of thousands of diverse planes.
Re:FAA restricts commercial rocket launches indefinitely due...
by terminalshort on Saturday November 08, 2025 @12:49PM
(#45858488)
There are only 35,000 commercial planes on Earth. Even if installing costs $1 million per plane, that's only $35 billion.
Re:FAA restricts commercial rocket launches indefinitely due...
by rogerrogerr on Saturday November 08, 2025 @05:06PM
(#45860482)
The US has about 200,000 general aviation planes. You can’t ignore them, and you can’t just ban GA because that’s your pipeline for getting commercial pilots.