Re:FBI tries to unmask owner of archive.is
by coldtea on Thursday November 06, 2025 @02:47PM
(#45839466)
No, but it can make it unworthy of concern, same how an egg gone bad on the kitchen counter is not very important when the house is on fire
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:FBI tries to unmask owner of archive.is
by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday November 06, 2025 @04:34PM
(#45840730)
If one is naive to the fire in the house, the egg on the counter, as something worthy of concern, might get them to look around and see that their house is not actually suitable for use as shelter. People who are trying to put out the fire (or who are simply concerned about it while watching from a distance) might decide to point to the spoiled egg to spread awareness of the fire to the people inside.
Re:FBI tries to unmask owner of archive.is
by ToValueFunfetti on Thursday November 06, 2025 @07:44PM
(#45842391)
I think you have to change or abandon the metaphor to make your point. These are not true statements of spoiled eggs and house fires, and so much so as to make a reasonable claim about institutions and malfeasance look absurd.
Re:FBI tries to unmask owner of archive.is
by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday November 06, 2025 @08:08PM
(#45842541)
> These are not true statements of spoiled eggs and house fires, and so much so as to make a reasonable claim about institutions and malfeasance look absurd.
True, but I disagree with the conclusion. When I try to map it back to reality and it doesn't make sense, it is indeed an indictment of the analogy. But the fact I have to abuse the analogy to make that mapping coherent is not my problem; it's not my analogy.
However, within the context of the analogy, and if one can imagine that absolutely insane scenario, the logic holds.
Re:FBI tries to unmask owner of archive.is
by cestith on Thursday November 06, 2025 @04:40PM
(#45840782)
An egg gone bad and a house fire are not the same sort of concern. A government agency doing two types of evil thing is more akin to ranking whether the small fire in the living room is more important than the slightly larger fire in the media room. Itβs all fire in your house.