News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Employers Banned From Asking For Social Media Passwords I... by w00kie on Thursday September 27, 2012 @09:27PM (#4583867)
Next time I interview someone for a position at my company, I'm going to ask them for their Facebook password. If they give it to me, they will be automatically disqualified from the hiring process for lack of common sense.
Re:Employers Banned From Asking For Social Media Passwords I... by prophetjohn on Thursday September 27, 2012 @10:36PM (#4584046)
I don't think this is much better. I wouldn't work for someone who asked me this question, even if this were the rationale. Who knows why someone would divulge their password. I bet there are reasons other than being completely devoid of common sense.

Regardless, I bet that any predictive relationship between willingness to divulge a Facebook password in an interview and the ability to perform adequately as a software engineer is weak at best. To me, an employer who doesn't understand that shows poor capacity for unbiased reasoning.

Re:Employers Banned From Asking For Social Media Passwords I... by kenko on Friday September 28, 2012 @01:08AM (#4584396)
"Who knows why someone would divulge their password. I bet there are reasons other than being completely devoid of common sense."

You need a job and are given to believe that you won't get the one you're interviewing for if you don't hand over your password.

People regularly do all kinds of demeaning things because employers ask/demand them to.

Re:Employers Banned From Asking For Social Media Passwords I... by TheAmazingIdiot on Friday September 28, 2012 @01:13AM (#4584402)
Last time I checked, people need a place to sleep and food to eat.

You need a job to pay for those things.

Re:Employers Banned From Asking For Social Media Passwords I... by mortenjorck on Thursday September 27, 2012 @11:23PM (#4584156)
If I were interviewing a candidate and had decided to ask this question, my response following their reaction would be "Just kidding. We don't do that here" followed by taking note of how concerned they initially appeared at the question.
Re:Employers Banned From Asking For Social Media Passwords I... by prophetjohn on Thursday September 27, 2012 @11:36PM (#4584191)
The "just kidding" would probably need to be before I answered. If I start to get up and walk out and then they say "no, I was just yankin' ya!" I'm going to be really suspicious.
Re:Employers Banned From Asking For Social Media Passwords I... by eli on Friday September 28, 2012 @08:16AM (#4585114)
What exactly do you think their level of visible concern would tell you about them? An employer conducting jokey personality tests would be a huge red flag for me.
Re:Employers Banned From Asking For Social Media Passwords I... by sliverstorm on Friday September 28, 2012 @12:18AM (#4584288)
I bet there are reasons other than being completely devoid of common sense.

Easy examples off the top of my head:

- You cultivate a profile almost like a garden, knowing that one day an employer is going to demand to see it

- You started one, but don't use it

Re:Employers Banned From Asking For Social Media Passwords I... by davyjones on Thursday September 27, 2012 @10:46PM (#4584073)
This might backfire on you because if the person you want to hire has a similar line of thought, he/she wouldn't want to work at your company.
Re:Employers Banned From Asking For Social Media Passwords I... by w00kie on Thursday September 27, 2012 @10:57PM (#4584097)
Well, for one, this was kind of a sarcastic comment. Second, if I really did this, once the interviewee refuses to give out the password I would congratulate them, saying they passed my test of modern technological common sense: "never EVER give out your password to anyone for any reason".
Re:Employers Banned From Asking For Social Media Passwords I... by oinksoft on Thursday September 27, 2012 @11:24PM (#4584162)
That would be both immature and manipulative, of course.
Re:Employers Banned From Asking For Social Media Passwords I... by dizzystar on Thursday September 27, 2012 @11:59PM (#4584245)
Oddly, I don't find this idea too offensive, especially since so many companies have large security holes via social engineering. If the applicants are this lackadaisical in keeping their own data private, why would I trust them with the company's or my customer's sensitive information?

With that said, I definitely understand why an applicant would be offended by the question. In fact, I would hope they are! I guess the second test is seeing if they understand the logic of such a question then convincing him or her that I don't conduct myself this way.

In the right hands, this is a great tool, but in the wrong hands, it is a disaster.

Re:Employers Banned From Asking For Social Media Passwords I... by okamiueru on Friday September 28, 2012 @06:02AM (#4584869)
In my case it would still backfire. I wouldn't know what the response would be if I _had_ given them the password. It would make me think the person hiring me was being manipulative and dishonest. And that is a best-case scenario.

Secondly, it would be setting the bar way too low. I don't appreciate being congratulated for not being an idiot. Someone congratulating me and actually being impressed of that fact makes me think less of that person.

A pretty bad start to a supposedly long relationship, if you ask me.

Re:Employers Banned From Asking For Social Media Passwords I... by ataggart on Thursday September 27, 2012 @10:14PM (#4583991)
In a similar vein, it's not clear to me why I should be deprived of the knowledge that a potential future employer is a privacy-invading jerk. The censor not only infringes on the rights of the speaker, but also the rights of the would-be listeners.
Re:Employers Banned From Asking For Social Media Passwords I... by tomrod on Thursday September 27, 2012 @10:42PM (#4584062)
"Aw shocks, I seem to have forgotten my password since I haven't logged in since 2007. Can I use your account instead?"
Re:Employers Banned From Asking For Social Media Passwords I... by Zenst on Friday September 28, 2012 @07:33AM (#4585029)
How does your logic apply if the don't have a Facebook account?

What if your prospective employee asked you to sign a NDA with regards to any personal information he may or may not reveal, before the interview started. How would you view them then?

Reason I ask is there be companies that will find away around law's and will ask you to sign a NDA during the interview stages and this is accepted in general. Does focus the aspect of what happens at work stays at work and what happens at home stays at home, somewhat.

Re:Employers Banned From Asking For Social Media Passwords I... by mkup on Friday September 28, 2012 @07:43AM (#4585047)
Can NDA overrule the law? For example, can burglar who broke into your house force you to sign NDA so you don't report this case to the police? IANAL, but probably law doesn't work that way; burglary is still a crime regardless of NDAs, and asking for Facebook password at the interview is a violation of law too, no matter what any kind of contract says.
Re:Employers Banned From Asking For Social Media Passwords I... by arethuza on Friday September 28, 2012 @07:58AM (#4585073)
IANAL But an NDA sounds like a contract to me and contracts signed under duress usually aren't enforceable.
Re:Employers Banned From Asking For Social Media Passwords I... by davidwen on Thursday September 27, 2012 @10:38PM (#4584050)
And if they don't? They'll probably disqualify you as a potential employer for asking such a question. Just doesn't seem like anyone wins from this.
Re:Employers Banned From Asking For Social Media Passwords I... by krichman on Thursday September 27, 2012 @10:14PM (#4583990)
I think (hope) some people are just so desperate for work they'll suffer indignities like that in order to have it.