News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by echelon on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @01:50PM (#45814553)
> "Non-political community" is an oxymoron

No it's not.

I'm an LGBT person with a trans partner and I find many codes of conduct to be chastising and purposefully finger pointing to conservative people.

A lot of them are basically, "your religious teachings or cultural upbringing aren't welcome here"

I don't agree with religious texts, but that's what you're wagging in their face with some of the CoCs.

Leave it at "don't be an asshole". It's that simple.

The current political climate, I feel, is a direct reaction to this.

A politically neutral space wouldn't permit religious people to harass trans or LGBT people, but it also wouldn't give anyone latitude to throw stones the other way either.

CoCs are "you're not welcome here at all".

Another thing: you always see language and project logos modified to bear the rainbow, trans, and BLM colors. You never see anything supporting Asians, white people, men, or Christians. If you did this, you would be called out as a racist. Which is so ironic.

Let's just get along and work together. Maybe we'll find more agreements amongst ourselves that way instead of trying to divide everyone into camps.

Some progressives are going to get very pissed off at this comment, but I grew up and live in the South. You can (and often must) work with people you don't agree with. It's not impossible to be friends either. You might wind up changing their mind, and they might wind up making you more tolerant as well.

Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by shayway on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @04:12PM (#45815943)
Just want to say I appreciate you publicly taking this stance (on what appears to be a non-throwaway account, no less). As a fellow LGBT person I feel so alienated from other progressive-leaning people and communities because of my belief in how those who don't share my beliefs should be treated.

When saying these things out loud can be social suicide, well, it means a lot to see someone else say it first. So thanks. I hope tolerance can come back into fashion.

Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by quamserena on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @05:01PM (#45816359)
This is all fun and games until a “politically neutral” decision is made by a programming language foundation to refer to all trans people using they/them. How would that make you feel?
Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by eeeesh on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @06:22PM (#45817058)
The most politically neutral decision in this case would be to let people refer to others with whichever pronouns accord to the speaker's beliefs, without reprimand.
Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by quamserena on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @08:33PM (#45818007)
That is absolutely not politically neutral.
Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by eeeesh on Wednesday November 05, 2025 @02:34AM (#45820367)
How not? This policy permits expression aligned with personal convictions without privileging one political position over another.
Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by ModernMech on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @10:06PM (#45818510)
Yeah that's the fastest way to breed animosity in these communities. Insisting on calling someone by a name they don't use for themselves is extremely antagonistic.

r/programminglanguages has the right idea: put a pride flag in the logo and a lot of these problems just sort themselves out.

  the flag logo has proven surprisingly effective at weeding out bigots. Not just in this thread or the previous one, but also in the moderator mail: we've had at least several instances of mouth breathers writing rants along the lines of "How dare you use colors in your logo!" (that's a very nice "translation" of what's actually written in those cases). Similarly, several comments in this thread have been removed and their authors banned, due to comments that boil down to "I'm not a bigot, I just hate LGBTQ+ people". This will not change, based on the simple premise that such people aren't worth having around in any community, and these people don't contribute anything of value anyway.
https://www.reddit.com/r/ProgrammingLanguages/comments/17gcv...

And it does work out well, the discussions stay on topic, LGBTQ issues aren't really a community topic despite the flag. Here's how that works out in practice, from today:

https://www.reddit.com/r/ProgrammingLanguages/comments/1onr6...

Someone says "he", they're corrected with "she", and that's the end of it. In more toxic communities where people are encouraged to use whatever pronouns they want, that simple interaction because a whole thing, where eventually one person calls the other delusional, the other calls them a bigot, and then no one is talking about programming languages. It's an eternal struggle, and for many people who build and maintain programming languages, they prefer to kick out the bigot rather than be called delusional, so everyone can get back to talking about programming languages. Still, there are plenty of online spaces, especially language spaces, where LGBTQ people are made to feel excluded. People upset with the flag or pronouns can join one of those communities, and everyone is happy.

(If anyone is wondering what kind of comments, they're usually veiled or not so veiled threats along the lines of this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45727677. If the mere presence of the flag keeps people like this out, that's fine by me.)

Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by eeeesh on Wednesday November 05, 2025 @04:02AM (#45820913)
> Here's how that works out in practice, from today:

> Someone says "he", they're corrected with "she", and that's the end of it.

This is a good example of conversational flow in an environment where people are not reprimanded for referring to others with pronouns that accord to the speaker's personal worldview. One person says "he", another person says "she", and everyone tolerates this difference of expression whether they agree with it or not.

Essentially it's the most politically neutral stance on pronouns, as implemented in an everyday conversation.

Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by vacuity on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @11:28PM (#45819079)
Morality partially stems from autonomy (in the sense that "I should be able to act as I please"). According to autonomy, a person should be able to act freely, and two people should be able to interact similarly. One person's policy will be judged by any other, who is free to act by a distinct policy. But autonomy alone doesn't make for a good person, or a good society. The other factor in morality is non-hypocrisy (in the sense that "I should act how I say I should act").

I've laid out a neutral response. Of course I have my personal beliefs, as one does, but I speak here without pretense. Believe what you will.

Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by shayway on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @05:43PM (#45816739)
You would consider that decision politically neutral?
Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by roommin on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @07:11PM (#45817457)
So you can see why they put it in scare quotes. Just above your reply another says it's politically neutral to adopt whatever pronouns the speaker feels is valid, and not punish them for it. This is "neutral" in that it sides with the speaker regardless of who they are, but is clearly designed to allow bigots to misgender freely. That is the point, "neutral" is not so trivially defined, and often falls on the side of more conservative societal trends.
Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by quamserena on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @08:36PM (#45818036)
Thank you, this is exactly what I was getting at.
Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by shayway on Wednesday November 05, 2025 @04:04PM (#45828000)
What would you consider politically neutral, then? Because it seems we're in agreement that a decision to "refer to all trans people using they/them" would not fit the bill.

(for the record I do realize the phrase is vague and unclear, and often used as a conservative dogwhistle, hence why I avoid using it)

An example of the sort of Code of Conduct I personally feel is the most inclusive, accepting, and conducive to cooperation and open discussion across a wide variety of backgrounds would be the Hacker News guidelines[0]. I think the moderation in general here does a good job of staying politically neutral in a non-scare-quotes-dogwhistle way.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by vacuity on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @02:50PM (#45815188)
I agree with you, although of course "don't be an asshole" is only simple to enforce in practice. In the current climate, I expect that people considered "conservative" will still be highly hostile to good faith (let alone not) enforcements.

No matter the person, it's really disappointing that we're still entrenched in the mentalities of tribalism, anti-intellectualism, "if you're not with us, you're against us", "an eye for an eye", "someone hurt me, so I'm going to hurt someone", and so on. And by "person", that includes me.

The Earth politics patch really can't come soon enough. How much do we pay the devs, again?

Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by JoshTriplett on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @02:07PM (#45814723)
> You can (and often must) work with people you don't agree with.

Life's for too short to force people to do this, and ideally we should make it as feasible as possible for as many people as possible to never have to do this.

Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by pessimizer on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @02:20PM (#45814865)
This is a crazy notion. If I have to like everybody to work with them, we can't have a civilization because I don't like most people.

I like some people. Everybody else I work with if they're willing to work with me. Saying that we all have to agree with each other is basically giving up on the political project entirely, and going back to strongman rulers who organize by demanding conformity. Very relevant in these times.

> we should make it as feasible as possible for as many people as possible to never have to do this.

No, we should make it impossible to avoid so people can't sneak into adulthood without being properly socialized.

Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by abenga on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @02:31PM (#45814986)
There is a wide gulf between "I don't like this person" and "this person's whole existence should be a crime".
Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by vacuity on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @11:58PM (#45819332)
I think that many people leaning toward the latter are "merely" misguided, though I certainly don't think that to correct them would be easy. However, I genuinely think some people are taken to be hateful when they aren't. Discussion of such cases should not be taken with the presumption that the accusations of hate are true, because then truth gives way to opinion. A good cause is a good cause, but realization invites bias.
Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by JoshTriplett on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @02:38PM (#45815069)
Nope. I won't work with people who think my friends shouldn't exist. And I won't work with people who think doing that is somehow childish.
Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by Oper_52 on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @02:58PM (#45815252)
> people who think my friends shouldn't exist

What does this mean? Are you talking about people who openly support actual murder? Almost everyone is opposed to that, of course.

Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by tczMUFlmoNk on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @06:35PM (#45817169)
College athlete Lia Smith died by suicide last week after years of targeted harassment and attacks from the people we're talking about. At some point, when the institutions of power do everything they can to demonize your existence, strip you of your accomplishments, and vilify you publicly—across millions of people nationwide—it doesn't matter whether you call it murder or not. The deaths rack up all the same.
Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by Oper_52 on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @06:58PM (#45817357)
Perhaps it would be best not to spread unverified speculation about possible reasons for someone choosing to die by suicide.
[dead]
Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by vacuity on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @11:34PM (#45819124)
In fact, by my reading, that post is saying that the actual cause is immaterial in the face of campaigning that essentially tried to be the cause.
Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by echelon on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @02:55PM (#45815232)
Imagine the flip side. We could easily wind up in that world too.

The best defense against polarization is a strong and cohesive middle ground.

If you pull to far in the other way, all the bonds break. And it's a race for each interest group to seize power, rather than having some intermediating force that serves as a buffer.

Again: look at the political climate. It's a reaction. The pendulum is swinging harder and harder because we've given up on the middle ground.

Most of the people you hate (and you do seem to dislike them at least a little bit) have honestly never had an LGBT friend. Imagine if they did how that might change them.

Instead they hear voices from the LGBT community that want to outlaw them and their way of life. That's pretty hostile. And definitely is going to be met with the same attitude you're giving them.

I'm LGBT and I have many conservative friends. They're more apt to come around to it than you believe. You're shutting down any conversation before it can even happen.

Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by vacuity on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @03:12PM (#45815375)
> Instead they hear voices from the LGBT community

Oftentimes, the voices are outside.

I think you're somewhat optimistic, and "the middle ground" is not a magical place. It's easy to fall into a false sense of security that comes from making (likely valid) criticisms of caricatured groups. Middle ground should not be sought for its own sake, or else it becomes useless (akin to Goodhart's law; roughly "when a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure"). People should embrace a diversity of values, but the burden is to stay true to a set of values and push for the truth.

Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by vacuity on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @11:45PM (#45819212)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45819079 (read my comment here first)

Not quite your fault, but the framing of "people you don't agree with" juxtaposed with the implicit statement of "people who promote hate" (or similar) doesn't make for a clear discussion. To be clear, those two types are well separated. If someone is of the latter type, really truly they are, then they can be removed without further ado (and I think GP would agree). I think the situations that are less clear cut will make people in good faith fight.

Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by clipsy on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @03:04PM (#45815289)
> A lot of them are basically, "your religious teachings or cultural upbringing aren't welcome here"

Could you point out a code of conduct -- preferably from a large, well known project -- that reads this way in your opinion?

Re:The Rust Foundation Maintainers Fund by munificent on Wednesday November 05, 2025 @01:28PM (#45826138)
> that's what you're wagging in their face with some of the CoCs.

I never mentioned codes of conduct in my comment.

Those are orthogonal to the observation that communities are fundamentally political.

> Leave it at "don't be an asshole". It's that simple.

Sure, and "don't be an asshole" is a political statement. The subjects and objects of that sentence are people and the intent is to affect how they interact.

If you feel that that's the kind of thing that community members should write down and say to each other, then you're implicitly agreeing with my claim that politics is what communities do.

I suspect you think you and I would disagree with what politics a community should espouse, but that's not my point at all. All I'm saying is that every community, every group of people coordinating together, is a political beast. It's true of an anarcho-syndalistic art collective from Portland who only communicate through crypto-signed commits on their self-hosted fork of Fossil, it's true of a gang of skinhead bikers meeting regularly at a dive bar, and it's true of the Rust community.

When people regularly interact with each other and communicate about how they should interact... they are politicking. "Politics" has become a bad word for some people, but it's the less bad word we have available to describe what it is people are doing when they are establishing the norms and practices of their regular repeated interactions.