News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Search Referrers Disappear In iOS 6 by pilif on Thursday September 27, 2012 @10:26AM (#4580829)
I would assume this is caused by the search bar now using the SSL version of Google.

The "fix" is "easy": If you want referrer data, offer your site over SSL or use the Google Webmaster tools (I don't know whether there is an API to get to that data).

Browsers don't send a referrer header if the referring site is SSL and the target site is not. This has always been the case even on the desktop.

Re:Google Search Referrers Disappear In iOS 6 by olalonde on Thursday September 27, 2012 @10:38AM (#4580897)
Yep, that's what the RFC says. http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc2616#section-15.1.3

"Clients SHOULD NOT include a Referer header field in a (non-secure) HTTP request if the referring page was transferred with a secure protocol."

Re:Google Search Referrers Disappear In iOS 6 by jimktrains2 on Thursday September 27, 2012 @10:44AM (#4580914)
Doesn't it also say not to send refer data to different domains? I'm trying to find docs for that.

EDIT: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=141641 Maybe I'm wrong but that seems to be what some browsers do/did.

Re:Google Search Referrers Disappear In iOS 6 by olalonde on Thursday September 27, 2012 @10:49AM (#4580934)
Sending referer data to different domains is always allowed for non-secure URLs (otherwise, web analytics would be pretty boring). For secure URLs however, the browser should only send referer data if the destination page is also secure, regardless of domain.
Re:Google Search Referrers Disappear In iOS 6 by dmayle on Thursday September 27, 2012 @12:29PM (#4581441)
That makes no sense, and defeats some of the protection of SSL. If you're on a secure site, there should be no referrer sent cross-domain, or cross-protocol.
Re:Google Search Referrers Disappear In iOS 6 by entropy_ on Thursday September 27, 2012 @04:52PM (#4582827)
I makes some sense. If you're using SSL and someone is trying to snoop on your connection. If you visit a non-SSL site from an SSL site and the referrer gets sent then the snooper knows the URL of the page you were on last. Whereas if the target site is SSL then no information is leaked to listeners.

The point of SSL is to protect from snooping, not as a general privacy-protection mechanism that should have everything privacy-related shoehorned into it.

Re:Google Search Referrers Disappear In iOS 6 by sullivandanny on Thursday September 27, 2012 @11:43AM (#4581167)
There is no fix for this. In the article, see the related stories at the bottom, in particular "Google Puts A Price On Privacy."

Google deliberately prevents referrer data from passing regardless of the state of SSL. It only allows it to pass if someone's clicking on an ad.

Re:Google Search Referrers Disappear In iOS 6 by peteretep on Thursday September 27, 2012 @10:39AM (#4580901)
Yes, this is the case. A quick search shows I'm being taken to Google via https, hence no referrer string. You'd hope the author would have worked that out :-/
Re:Google Search Referrers Disappear In iOS 6 by IanDrake on Thursday September 27, 2012 @11:09AM (#4581021)
On my desktop (with chrome) searching google via HTTPS I get search results that first redirect to a HTTP page on Google then does a client redirect to the search result. This produces referer information to the search result.

It seems this step is not being taken on iOS, it could be google who singling out iOS6 and not doing the redirect to the HTTP page.

Re:Google Search Referrers Disappear In iOS 6 by mikeryan on Thursday September 27, 2012 @12:36PM (#4581470)
Tried this on my Nexus 7 and didn't get the redirect so it may be something they're doing for mobile user agents. Its definitely not specific to iOS6
Re:Google Search Referrers Disappear In iOS 6 by lallysingh on Thursday September 27, 2012 @01:08PM (#4581650)
Probably to reduce latency. Another hop is expensive on mobile networks.
Re:Google Search Referrers Disappear In iOS 6 by peteretep on Thursday September 27, 2012 @11:41AM (#4581158)
That's interesting. But as a counter point, my blog gets a bunch of hits from Google marked as "[Secure Search]", so I guess they don't always do it.
Re:Google Search Referrers Disappear In iOS 6 by ry0ohki on Thursday September 27, 2012 @11:47AM (#4581189)
Unfortunately no. Welcome to the future of web analytics, where all inbound keywords are (not provided) :(. Google claims this is a privacy thing, however AdWords keywords are still conveniently passed on!
Re:Google Search Referrers Disappear In iOS 6 by Bill_Dimm on Thursday September 27, 2012 @11:59AM (#4581264)
If you want referrer data, offer your site over SSL...Browsers don't send a referrer header if the referring site is SSL and the target site is not.

I haven't tested any browsers or looked at any standards on this, but if that works it doesn't make any sense to me. I would think that the rule would be "Browsers don't send a referrer header [to a different domain] if the referring site is SSL" period (no "and the target site is not" part). If a URL on site X contains secret information, why would it be OK to transmit that secret information to some other website simply because the secret information is encrypted while in transit? At the very least, I would expect the user to be prompted to confirm such action before doing it (which would probably be more annoying to the user than just dropping the referrer info).

Re:Google Search Referrers Disappear In iOS 6 by pandog on Thursday September 27, 2012 @11:54AM (#4581235)
This is exactly what's happening - though the author seems to think differently.

This isn't a huge deal as you can still get details of Google Queries using Google Webmaster Tools: http://www.google.com/webmasters/

Re:Google Search Referrers Disappear In iOS 6 by sullivandanny on Thursday September 27, 2012 @12:08PM (#4581319)
It is a huge deal and has been since Google stopped passing referrers for signed-in users last October. That's because...

1) If it's a privacy thing, then Google is happy having a leak by giving these terms to advertisers

2) The data is not provided in a way that can be used by third party ad retargeting terms, giving Google a competitive advantage

3) Publishers can't use the data to better target with landing pages

4) Google Webmaster Central data only goes back for a short period of time, and if you haven't constantly been downloading your data, all your historic traffic information related to a term has gone poof.

Re:Google Search Referrers Disappear In iOS 6 by mun2mun on Thursday September 27, 2012 @12:27PM (#4581424)
Does it create a monopoly situation?
Re:Google Search Referrers Disappear In iOS 6 by scottkrager on Thursday September 27, 2012 @03:22PM (#4582329)
This is a massively huge deal for attribution of organic search.

The queries you can download from webmaster tools are just 1 column of data....nothing to tie queries to conversions or any meaningful metric.

If it was everyone who was losing this data...I could understand the change but if you buy adwords ads, you still get the referral data even in https Google.

Re:Google Search Referrers Disappear In iOS 6 by nchlswu on Thursday September 27, 2012 @10:45AM (#4580918)
I'm not familiar with the implications of not sending the referer data.

Can be interpreted that not sending the referer, and thus the decision to use the SSL version is in anyway malicious in intent (almost like what the author is implying in the headline)?

Re:Google Search Referrers Disappear In iOS 6 by pilif on Thursday September 27, 2012 @11:00AM (#4580969)
You can't have it all. The HTTP RFC is very clear that referrer data from HTTPS sites should not be sent to HTTP sites (in order to protect the content of the HTTPS site - remember: Even the URL is transmitted in an encrypted way, so it might contain sensitive data).

So by doing the Google searches over HTTPS, you make the life of pages and analytics vendors harder, but you are doing a huge favor to the end users because now their searches are private between them and Google. Nobody else on the way can sniff them. No government and no neighbor/coworker.

Of course, once the user clicked and found your site, the URL the user initially used isn't that confidential any more, so in theory, passing the referrer wouldn't be a problem in this case, but that's not what the standard says and it's not what browsers are doing.

If you want to see this changed, talk to the IETF or the W3C to have the standard changed such that, for example, google could add some rel= attribute to tell the browser that sending a referrer is OK.

Or just serve your page over SSL, further helping the end-user - and it's all about them in the first place - isn't it?