News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Get the Fainting Chair by tptacek on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @02:27PM (#4577171)
I find it a little baffling the amount of animus Apple's mapping has generated on HN. The alternative to Apple doing their own mapping was to continue relying on Google. How is it not a great thing that Apple is competing with them on this? Don't we need more well capitalized global mapping infrastructure?
Re:Get the Fainting Chair by kmfrk on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @02:52PM (#4577317)
I find the backlash totally fine, but I am incredibly bothered by the rational shortcuts people take to bash Apple based solely on idle speculation and misinterpretation of facts.

"They could just have done so and so", as if we are privy to any inside information.

I really hate it when people choose to make up arguments with no solid ground when there are plenty of criticisms to be made.

Re:Get the Fainting Chair by Locke1689 on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @02:47PM (#4577288)
I have only one rule regarding my technology purchases: it has to work. Apple maps don't, so no iPhone for me. I'm not sure if that's what you mean by animus.
Re:Get the Fainting Chair by tptacek on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @02:50PM (#4577303)
Not at all! If Apple's maps don't work for you, that strikes me as a very good reason not to buy an iPhone. I might even go so far as to suggest that "reasons not to buy an iPhone" are a good thing; the whole market could use more competition.

It's the "Apple has made a terrible irresponsible mistake" stuff that confuses me.

Incidentally, where are you that Apple's maps don't work for you? I'm in Chicago and they work better for me than the old one did.

Re:Get the Fainting Chair by Locke1689 on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @02:52PM (#4577319)
I recently moved from Chicago to Seattle, but I rarely like to drive in Seattle so transit directions are essential for me.

Edit: What were your problems with Google maps in Chicago? I remember it was kind of stupid sometimes (e.g., it would tell me to take the pink line 3 blocks and transfer instead of just walking three blocks and getting on the red line), but I don't remember them being inaccurate.

Re:Get the Fainting Chair by tptacek on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @02:53PM (#4577321)
You don't think maybe not baking in transit was a good move? Allows space for companies to build apps with transit as a real focus?
Re:Get the Fainting Chair by Locke1689 on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @02:59PM (#4577368)
That depends. First, if they had worked with a company prior to release that makes some sense, however I really need access now, not in 6 months.

In addition, I often feel that public transit and walking directions go hand-in-hand. I would be willing to see someone try to separate them, but I'm skeptical of the user experience.

Re:Get the Fainting Chair by erickhill on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:53PM (#4577973)
Agreed. This is an exciting area to watch battles in innovation over the years. Note how Amazon also recently announced their own mapping API (using Nokia's or UpNext's mapping data, I think). http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4532099

All of the big boys are angling to be in the game (don't forget Bing maps).

I may keep a folded paper map handy whilst traveling abroad, however, for the foreseeable future.

Re:Get the Fainting Chair by manaskarekar on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @02:49PM (#4577298)
Quote from Linus.

> THE USER DOESN'T CARE.

Source: https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=638477#c129

Re:Get the Fainting Chair by tptacek on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @02:50PM (#4577307)
Quote from me.

> NOT MY POINT.

Source: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4577307

Re:Get the Fainting Chair by bathat on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:09PM (#4577746)
I don't think anyone minds that Apple is competing. I've been fiercely critical of the new iOS 6 maps, and I welcome competition. I can't speak for others, but what bothers me is not that Apple released a different mapping solution, but that the new map app is just so unbelievably terrible for many people [1]. Even with the third-party add-ons, you still can't use Apple maps to plan an inter-city itinerary, or one that crosses the "territory" of multiple transit agencies. In some American cities, that means you can't use iOS 6 maps to plan a trip across town. These are things that did work in iOS 5.

I completely understand how it makes business sense for Apple to develop it's own mapping product, but that doesn't mean that they have to release software that is missing huge chunks of functionality. There seems to be this false dichotomy that Apple had two options: "release a product that is nowhere near ready to ship," and "rely on Google forever." There is a third option, which is "develop maps secretly, do the first two 90%'s of the work, then drop Google maps." Many on HN have argued that maps can't improve until they are used. That is doubtlessly true for some aspects: POIs, especially businesses, aren't going to be added until Apple maps gain mind-share, and there will be errors in the data that Apple bought until someone bothers to tell Apple to correct it. I can forgive Apple for that. But those are the things belong to the third 90% of the work.

If anything, this piece at Daring Fireball just reinforces the idea that Apple has a problem somewhere in the chain of command. It really seems like there's nothing that would have prevented Apple from waiting another 6 to 12 months to announce it's mapping product, except that someone drastically underestimated how difficult it would be to compete with Google. Frankly, I think that's why iOS 6 doesn't have transit directions--the only thing you can do with a late product is drop features or push back the ship date.[2]

I really do welcome all the things that Apple is trying to do maps in iOS 6, and I think they will have a good product in a year's time (or maybe two). That does not, however, mean that I want or will accept broken maps on my phone in the interim.

[1] Apparently this is everyone in Japan, a dude in Portugal, and many people who use public transit to get around in big American cities. For some, the addition of turn-by-turn is a bigger gain than the loss of public transit and street-view.

[2] This is also why I can't see the third-party transit thing as a viable solution. The end-game is that Apple will bring transit in-house the same way they did with the rest of maps. Actually, maybe it's a brilliant strategy on Apple's part to pick really good team to do transit directions. Embark seems to be doing a good job, but they seem to be focusing on just a few transit systems in big cities, with no inter-city transit. Hopefully Apple will acquire them and provide the resources to have really complete coverage.

Re:Get the Fainting Chair by cookiecaper on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @02:55PM (#4577334)
Sure, it's a good long-term strategy, but the replacement was immensely premature. See my comment further down the thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4577215 .
Re:Get the Fainting Chair by tptacek on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @02:56PM (#4577354)
One way to look at this: Apple is willing to pay, in eroded market share during the transition, for earlier control of their own mapping infrastructure.

Again: isn't that a good thing?

Re:Get the Fainting Chair by Locke1689 on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:06PM (#4577405)
It's certainly a daring thing. I suspect that you're right and that it won't be such a huge issue in a year or so.

I do wonder if this is an opportunity for Microsoft to sell a complete platform experience while Apple is taking a breather.

Disclaimer: I just recently started working for MSFT in a position not at all related to Windows Phone. I also don't own a Windows Phone.

Re:Get the Fainting Chair by tptacek on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:09PM (#4577419)
I have a hard time believing Apple didn't see this coming. This isn't like Siri staggering under its load; the gaps in Apple's data, and moreover in the Maps feature set, are plainly obvious.

Apple knew this was going to happen, and did it anyways. It is therefore part of a strategy.

Re:Get the Fainting Chair by malvim on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:32PM (#4577543)
Yes, that might well be a good move for Apple. We're talking "market share" and "control of infrastructure" and all that. That makes sense.

One problem, though: It sucks that, in order to make a move that makes economic sense, you have to break stuff for your users. And not just break. REALLY break.

Gruber talks about the options Apple had, and one is "wait one more year having less features than their competitors". Well, that sounds exactly like what Apple would do in the past, in order to have a better user experience. You know, the infamous "customers don't want this or that" that Jobs would always say when they didn't have something ready.