News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Turn your 404s into lost children alerts by sachingulaya on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @06:22PM (#4573012)
A friend of mine growing up had an older brother who was abducted. His mother quit her job and spent the next 5 years looking for him. Eventually, she found him. She called her mother's home and her son picked up the phone. He had been abducted by his uncle and told that his mother had sent him to live with his extended family. No one suspected it.

Now, I know n=1 is not a good sample size, but to downplay the significance of kidnappings by "someone the child knows" or that "it was a family member" is not reasonable.

Also, a study on the effectiveness of amber alert messages on the freeway be extrapolated to give data on results from a 404 campaign.

I can't estimate whether or not internet amber alerts are a good or a bad idea. Just tossing in my 0.02.

Re:Turn your 404s into lost children alerts by sliverstorm on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @06:30PM (#4573052)
Your parent is not arguing that kidnappings by non-strangers are insignificant; rather, that public service announcements about such kidnapping are unproductive.

Whether this is actually the case, I have no idea.

Re:Turn your 404s into lost children alerts by tlrobinson on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @09:23PM (#4573746)
And your parent was providing an example where public service announcements about such kidnappings could have been productive.
Re:Turn your 404s into lost children alerts by scotty79 on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @01:06AM (#4574231)
I don't think he provided example for successful public service announcement.
Re:Turn your 404s into lost children alerts by jmilloy on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @07:46AM (#4575115)
Right. Instead the example that refutes the idea that public announcements aren't necessary for finding kids who were kidnapped by family members because the authorities would have looked there anyways by providing a anecdote where a public service announcement could have helped find a kid who was kidnapped by family members and not found (for a long time).
Re:Turn your 404s into lost children alerts by rmc on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @05:17AM (#4574792)
Yes they did. In the original story, no-one doubted the uncle's claim that the child had been sent by their parents. If there were public service announcements that "This child is offically missing", someone might have copped that something was up.
Re:Turn your 404s into lost children alerts by grhino on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @06:56AM (#4575000)
If the right individuals had seen the public service announcment. Were there any public service announcements for that abduction example given?

I think it's a given that nearly all the impressions of a public service announcement of a child abduction will be seen by people who have never seen that child. There's a cost of seeing a PSA of a child abduction. People will now consider child abductions more likely than they actually are. This causes them to make decisions that may be against the best interest of their children like go outside and play.

Re:Turn your 404s into lost children alerts by fludlight on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @08:02PM (#4573471)
It would be more effective to have the FBI do face recognition on everyone's vacation photos on Facebook. Assuming that the kidnappers want to raise the kid as their own, they are bound to post pictures of him. This won't work for the 75% that chimeracoder alleges are murdered, but it might for the scenarios like the one you described.

Why would a kidnapper would post pictures of a child they kidnapped on FB? Criminals are not always rocket scientists, and even then they aren't always rational(1). The kids also tend to go to birthday parties, school, and other places where other people post pictures of them that get posted on social networks.

(1) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lisa_Nowak

Re:Turn your 404s into lost children alerts by alanh on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @08:18PM (#4573526)
Wouldn’t there be a prohibitive number of false positives? It sounds like the poster child for this sort of calculation: http://lesswrong.com/lw/2b0/bayes_theorem_illustrated_my_way...
Re:Turn your 404s into lost children alerts by tlrobinson on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @09:26PM (#4573757)
chimeracoder was saying 75% of kids who are murdered after being kidnapped are murdered within 3 hours of being kidnapped.

i.e. in conditional probability notation, P( A | B and C) = 0.75 where A = murdered within 3 hours of being kidnapped, B = kidnapped, and C = murdered.

Re:Turn your 404s into lost children alerts by r00fus on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @06:32PM (#4573066)
Some way to tag your children (see Woz's attempts) are probably going to be more successful than alerting random people.
Re:Turn your 404s into lost children alerts by xenophanes on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @06:57PM (#4573177)
Or how about raising children self-confident enough to make a phone call home and demand to talk to their mother directly after a couple weeks.
Re:Turn your 404s into lost children alerts by icebraining on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @07:07PM (#4573238)
And they would let him, why?
Re:Turn your 404s into lost children alerts by xenophanes on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @07:42PM (#4573388)
If they won't, he knows something is up. Did they never let him outside in public, never go to school, never have contact with anyone who could help?

If so, he was basically just locked in the basement, the whole thing about saying he was sent there didn't actually matter.

Re:Turn your 404s into lost children alerts by icebraining on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @08:18PM (#4573525)
I don't mean flat-out deny, There's a reason why simple social engineering works with a very high degree of success, and manipulating small children who have trust in his kidnapper (which isn't rare, since they're often family members) is even easier.
Re:Turn your 404s into lost children alerts by xenophanes on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @09:10PM (#4573706)
Which is why I suggested raising less gullible, passive, compliant people. Gullibility is a problem, here and elsewhere.

I think raising people to be good, independent non-gullible people is a better approach than sticking trackers on them.

Re:Turn your 404s into lost children alerts by jerf on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @10:18PM (#4573907)
While we perhaps inculcate a bit more compliance than is strictly necessary, you can't make children not gullible. To be not gullible irreducibly requires enough experience with what is normal to know when something is not normal, and alas, not only do children have a straight-up calendar disadvantage there, the children that we are talking about are also more likely to not have a normal to compare against in the first place.

This is the wrong time to play that tune.

Re:Turn your 404s into lost children alerts by CrankyPants on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:53AM (#4574743)
Re:Turn your 404s into lost children alerts by derleth on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @05:36AM (#4574844)
> Which is why I suggested raising less gullible, passive, compliant people. Gullibility is a problem, here and elsewhere.

Young children are going to be gullible and compliant because they are young children.

That isn't something you can change until they are no longer young children. It's a question of both the teaching time required and the mental development required to learn those skills.

Similarly, some older children and adults are going to be gullible and compliant because they are mentally handicapped. Again, this isn't something you can fix by training them.

Re:Turn your 404s into lost children alerts by sachingulaya on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @11:09PM (#4574008)
He was raised normally and went to school during those years.

I don't know what his thought process was but leaps of logic are a commonly observed phenomenon among kidnapped children.

Re:Turn your 404s into lost children alerts by klausjensen on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @06:02AM (#4574895)
A quick google on "Steve Wozniak children tag" and similar did not give any results. Can you provide a link? Would love to read more about that.