News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by tgsovlerkhgsel on Monday October 27, 2025 @07:59PM (#45727817)
This is how DEI should work, and probably does in some, or maybe many, cases.

In other cases, it boiled down to "this quarter, we only have headcount for 'diverse' candidates", metrics for DEI hiring that turn into goals, and e-mails stating "only accept new L3 candidates that are from historically underrepresented groups".

I expect that I'll get accused of making this up, which is why the latter is an exact quote shown on page 28 in this court case: https://www.scribd.com/document/372802863/18-CIV-00442-ARNE-...

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by the_sleaze_ on Monday October 27, 2025 @09:28PM (#45728346)
I sat in an all hands where the vice president of HR proudly crowed to the company that they had hired 75% non-whites that quarter.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by analog31 on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:11PM (#45728874)
That's a lot of whites for a roofing company.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by epistasis on Monday October 27, 2025 @09:34PM (#45728376)
Seems like a lawsuit right there... is this happened I sure hope that there was a lawsuit! Or at least HR implementing new hiring practices company wide afterwards...
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by tick_tock_tick on Monday October 27, 2025 @10:54PM (#45728793)
Who's going to start a lawsuit and get blacklisted? HR is normally pushing for this.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by mensetmanusman on Monday October 27, 2025 @10:03PM (#45728544)
No one is brave enough to start such lawsuits. Likelihood of winning too low, first mover disadvantage at play.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by gcanyon on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:59PM (#45729090)
In your mind, if the company had researched their past hiring and found that whites/males had been favored for the previous history of the company, how long would it be reasonable for them to favor minorities and other underrepresented groups to balance the scales?
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by xdennis on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @12:33AM (#45729225)
If that's the case, I do think favoring non-whites and non-males is perfectly okay.

But how do you think people arrive at the conclusion that whites/males have been favored in the past? Do they:

1) inspect their hiring practices and find evidence of discrimination

2) look at the proportion of minorities in the company vs proportion of minorities in the general population and conclude that any disparity is proof of discrimination

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by 3oil3 on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @03:29AM (#45730032)
I think they come to that conclusion with that segregation thing? Besides that, all nonsense. We need the best for the job, the best we can have. Just the best, with no regards to anything else but the abilities to fulfil the job and all around it. Instead of non-sense of choosing someone based on racial, etnic, religous, etc... it goes both way. Instead of that, put more teachers in schools, provide free books/uniforms/utilities. Fix that damn airco in that kindergarden class. Better what makes better.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by amanaplanacanal on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @04:23AM (#45730326)
We think we want the best, and then at hiring time we look for "culture fit", or hire people we already know, or our relatives instead. Then we wonder why everybody is just like us.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by 3oil3 on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @11:33AM (#45734220)
Yep, you'r 100% right, it reminds me I once read that of all given jobs offers, 50% would be taken by someone who got introduced internally. Out of personal exeperience as employer, that so was decided by me because it was filling the need instantly. And out of those personal experiences, bad employees brought bad recruits, good employees brought good recruits. Unknown recruits? half good, half bad. Ironically chiraldic.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by gcanyon on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @08:22AM (#45731875)
> We need the best for the job

I'm curious why you say that, since we've arguably been managing without "the best for the job" for centuries, anytime the best was a woman or a minority.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by 3oil3 on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @11:26AM (#45734116)
Because we must do better than our ancestors, we have no escuses, whereas e.g. 1880 gobal ileteracy rate > 80%. More comfortable schools with less pupils per 1 teacher we need, fix the issue, not give painkillers.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by gcanyon on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @08:21AM (#45731856)
Companies know their own historical data and practices best.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by typewithrhythm on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @12:39AM (#45729253)
You cannot make a fair system by introducing subjective ideas like historical balance.

A set of rules for fairness require that current decisions only account for individual merit; not special status.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by gcanyon on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @08:15AM (#45731807)
I didn't propose subjective harm in the past, why would you suggest that I did?

But in any case, it seems like your answer is zero, right?

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by Ohmec on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @01:20AM (#45729424)
Inverting the privilege pyramid does not make for a balanced and healthy system.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by klipt on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @02:40AM (#45729758)
"If countries conscripted only men for thousands of years, for how many thousands of years is it reasonable to conscript only women to balance the scales?"
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by akimbostrawman on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @04:27AM (#45730353)
If these people where actually sincere and not just hiding behind a ideological smokescreen that only benefits them they would be for this same as with DEI in other men dominated jobs like sewage cleaning, road building or other physically taxing but underpaid jobs.

It really makes you think that all the "men and women are the same and sometimes women are even better" always starts at the silicon valley jobs and stops right at enlistment which would be actual equality.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by gcanyon on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @08:19AM (#45731845)
I'm a white male, there is zero chance DEI benefits me directly. But I think we all benefit from a diverse society, with female plumbers and electricians, minority software developers, etc. etc.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by akimbostrawman on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @08:37AM (#45732042)
It's not only not benefitting you but actively putting you at a disadvantage because of the way you where born.

Why do you think that? Because it makes you feel good or because there is an actual measurable benefit? And no you don't need to have a specific skin color or sexual orientation to be considered diverse/different. If you think "all white dudes are/think the same" maybe change white to black and say that in front of a mirror.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by rectang on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @03:13PM (#45737492)
(Not gp but...) I believe it because diversity is not a zero sum game, where every gain for a demographic other than mine means a loss to my demographic which must be fought tooth and nail.

First, we are all enriched by having a variety of experiences and perspectives available to draw upon.

Second, I feel stronger bonds with historically marginalized humans than with humans who happen to belong to my own demographic.

> If you think "all white dudes are/think the same"

Ha, we definitely do not all think alike.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by klipt on Saturday November 01, 2025 @04:55PM (#45785263)
> diversity is not a zero sum game

The moment HR rejects a candidate for being "insufficiently diverse" that's a zero sum game isn't it?

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by rectang on Sunday November 02, 2025 @06:48PM (#45794458)
Considering how many of your posts are focused on purported overwhelming discrimination against men, I’m pretty sure that no matter what I say you will continue to see a workplace not dominated by men in only negative terms.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by gcanyon on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @08:34PM (#45741179)
What makes you think I think "all white dudes are/think the same"? Did I say anything to suggest that?

The difference, I think, is that I'm not blind to the advantages I receive every day for being a white male. In the words of Louis CK, "If you're a white male and don't admit that it is thoroughly awesome, you're an asshole."

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by cutemonster on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @05:06AM (#45744394)
Reading your other comments, I was just thinking that you seemed to group everyone who look the same, together, and think about them as if they were 1 type of person you could generalize about. For example, white men, or black men, or women. - So, yes I suppose you did.

For example, if your country gets attacked, primarily the men go and defend their country and people. Is that "thoroughly awesome"? Anyway have a nice day

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by akimbostrawman on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @09:12AM (#45746409)
>advantages I receive every day for being a white male

Really like what? There are many concrete examples of how "white dudes" are statistically are disadvantaged.

Higher rate to being victim of a violent crime, suicide, homelessness, harsher sentences, dying at work, dying younger, dying in a war, white guilt

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by ModernMech on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @03:48PM (#45738081)
Disability accommodations are a cornerstone of DEI. As an able-bodied individual, you may not feel you would benefit from those today; but if you are blessed enough to grow old, one day you will likely be disabled in one way or another. When that day comes, you'll be asking for accommodations to get into public areas, and if those accommodations are not available to you, you will likely find how that limits your ability to participate in public life very unfair.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by gcanyon on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @08:37PM (#45741203)
> if you are blessed enough to grow old, one day you will likely be disabled in one way or another

Oh for sure, for sure. It's hard to predict exactly how the secondary effects play out. But I was referring to the primary intended effects, which I think is what the person I was replying to was talking about.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by throwawaypath on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @12:52PM (#45749563)
>Disability accommodations are a cornerstone of DEI.

You missed the memo, they're not pushing this narrative any longer. The poor attempt to launder DEI via the disabled is twisted and transparent. The ADA predates DEI by decades, and has broad support from both sides of the aisle.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by ModernMech on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @04:51PM (#45752846)
I am not saying disability law originated in the DEI movement of today, I'm pointing at the through line between the passage of the ADA and the modern DEI movement. From the civil rights era in the 60s, to women's rights in the 70s, to the ADA in the 90s, to gay rights in the 00s, to DEI today. The principles behind disability accommodations -- access, fairness, inclusion -- are foundational to DEI as a broader movement. The ADA was an early expression of those principles in law; DEI later extended them into other social and organizational contexts.

And yeah, the ADA has received broad bipartisan support in passage because it's well understood even by partisans that disabilities affect everyone, so it's important to have protections in place.

What's not so understood by partisans is how those disabilities manifest, so since the passage of the ADA there has also been widespread pushback on what qualifies as a disability, and what accommodations are reasonable. THAT is a whole different conversation which, as someone who is disabled and covered under the ADA, I will say can be like pulling teeth to get protections guaranteed under the law. For example, businesses are often loathe to make physical accommodations like ramps and elevators, and there is often resistance to providing accommodations for mental health conditions or neurodiversity.

But DEI itself is about creating equitable access and participation for everyone. This includes people who are disabled, and at no point in time has DEI not included disabled people. Maybe for the terminally online right, who only focus on gender and race, but that's not what it's all about in the real world. Notably, DEI also has been a driving force for veteran employment (having dedicated veteran hiring pipelines is absolutely DEI). It's very common for people to do what you're doing now -- "All the accommodations I like and/or benefit me are sound law and not DEI; all the accommodations I don't like are DEI and must be outlawed"

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by throwawaypath on Saturday November 08, 2025 @01:11AM (#45854552)
>The principles behind disability accommodations -- access, fairness, inclusion -- are foundational to DEI as a broader movement.

No they're not. Fairness is antithetical to DEI.

>But DEI itself is about creating equitable access and participation for everyone.

DEI is specifically designed to exclude those who rank low on the oppression Olympics rankings, access and participation are antithetical to DEI.

>Notably, DEI also has been a driving force for veteran employment (having dedicated veteran hiring pipelines is absolutely DEI).

These existed before DEI.

>It's very common for people to do what you're doing now -- "All the accommodations I like and/or benefit me are sound law and not DEI; all the accommodations I don't like are DEI and must be outlawed"

"All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others."

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by gcanyon on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @08:16AM (#45731815)
Okay, so we've established that your upper bound is "less than thousands of years" but what's your lower limit? Or were you just strawmanning?
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by kelnos on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @03:16AM (#45729963)
This isn't a thread about what's reasonable, it's a thread about what's legal.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by gcanyon on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @08:19AM (#45731849)
That means a "what's reasonable" question is disallowed?
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by 0xDEAFBEAD on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @03:51AM (#45730140)
Suppose you were abused by your parent. How much would it be reasonable for you to abuse your child, in order to balance the scales?
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by gcanyon on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @08:13AM (#45731782)
That's a bad metaphor.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by rayiner on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @08:21AM (#45731865)
It’s a good metaphor. You can’t undo racial discrimination against someone who is now dead by discriminating against someone else who is now alive.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by TimorousBestie on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @10:08AM (#45733110)
No, it’s a bad metaphor.

The correct analogy is, “Suppose you were abused by your parent; should you be allowed to establish a benefit specifically and only for the abused children of other parents?”

You and 0xDEAFBEAD answer that question no, because that benefit discriminates in your mind against all non-abused children. And against all adults, probably. I don’t know how deep the grievance mobilization goes.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by rayiner on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @11:46AM (#45734382)
To make your analogy work, the benefit would be for people who weren’t personally abused, but whose parents or grandparents were abused. And yes, that would be quite odd.

The rationale for racial preferences in 2025 is not that they are a benefit to individuals who were personally harmed by racial discrimination. The institutions engaging in these practices insist that they are otherwise engaged in race blind practices. If such practices existed, DEI as we know it would be unnecessary. We could simply just enforce the existing laws in a race-blind way.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by TimorousBestie on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @01:23PM (#45735859)
> To make your analogy work, the benefit would be for people who weren’t personally abused, but whose parents or grandparents were abused.

No, this is a consequence of your ideology, which assumes that racial discrimination ended with the Civil Rights Act and etc. (Hence “we could simply just enforce. . .”) Mine does not.

Note that the metaphor as stated by 0xDEAFBEAD, which you already said was good, did not include this additional generational gap.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by rayiner on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @04:25PM (#45738653)
It’s not just “my ideology.” The universities and corporations that practice DEI do not believe they discriminate against people in the present. They see it as a remedy for historical discrimination.

It’s also not even an ideological matter. It’s a testable fact. There’s very little evidence that universities and corporations are discriminating against non-whites/asians.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by gcanyon on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @08:29PM (#45741152)
So if admission rates are below population averages, is it your contention that:

   1. Fewer minorities *want* to go to college -- what do you think causes that bias?
   2. Minorities want to go to college, but due to factors of their environment are less able to make it to college -- what do you think leads to that inability?
   3. Minorities want to go to college, and their environment is just as supportive of that goal as for white, but minorities are less capable (on average) of achieving that goal -- what are we to make of this?
   4. Some other explanation I haven't thought of?
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by rayiner on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @02:04AM (#45743193)
My contention is that the evidence of discrimination against (non-asian) minorities in universities is non-existent. I don’t have an opinion to what’s causing admissions rates to be different than population averages. If someone proves that it’s caused by discrimination against minorities, then we have laws to address that and I’d support enforcing those laws.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by gcanyon on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @08:07AM (#45745724)
If we have the fact of lower admission rates, it is incumbent on us as a society that cares about all our members to figure out what's going on. You've refused to express an opinion. Of course, others have proposed rationales, and the solution proposed is unacceptable to you. So what are we to do with that?
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by rayiner on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @10:27AM (#45747289)
Society faces many problems—individuals don’t need to have an opinion as to the causes of all of them. I’m not an education expert, so I can’t tell you what causes lower admissions rates. If you think the reason is universities are discriminating, then it’s incumbent on you to build a case for that. I’m sure I’d support enforcing the laws against discriminatory conduct that you can show is happening. But I’m not going to support indicting people without evidence of wrongdoing.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by gcanyon on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @01:36PM (#45750284)
I'm not an education expert either, and I'm happy to let universities decide. It's your lot who won't let them.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by 15charlimitdumb on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @01:02PM (#45749731)
By this logic we should stop giving college scholarships to women. They are over represented in enrollment compared to men, so that can only be sexism right?
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by gcanyon on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @08:31PM (#45741161)
I'd argue the correct analogy is "Suppose you were abused by society; should society be forced to address that abuse." But that's just me.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by 0xDEAFBEAD on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @06:49AM (#45745087)
You're asking too much of society with such vague complaints. We should focus on getting basics right: prosperity, jobs, reduce crime, reduce road death, and so forth before navel-gazing about "abuse by society". In any case, even if society does somehow "address the abuse", it shouldn't come in the form of randomly abusing other people. But that's what you appear to be advocating for: Because some people were discriminated against, we should now randomly discriminate against some other people.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by gcanyon on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @08:10AM (#45745748)
You complain of vague complaints, then propose vague solutions. Your terminology escalation to "abuse" seems absurd to me: it's not a zero-sum game, and white people in general seem to have done fine over the past fifty years of "abuse".
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by 0xDEAFBEAD on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @10:28PM (#45755778)
>You complain of vague complaints, then propose vague solutions.

???

>Your terminology escalation to "abuse" seems absurd to me

It was an analogy.

>white people in general seem to have done fine

Black people in the US are also doing far better than Black people in Africa or frankly pretty much any other country with a large Black population.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by 0xDEAFBEAD on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @06:46AM (#45745062)
>The correct analogy is, “Suppose you were abused by your parent; should you be allowed to establish a benefit specifically and only for the abused children of other parents?”

That analogy is invalid because the original injustice here was discrimination, and people are proposing more discrimination in order to correct the original discrimination. Maybe that would be reasonable if you could be sure that the new discrimination narrowly targets people who unjustly benefited from the old discrimination. However, in practice this is unlikely to be the case: You'll have a situation where senior engineers benefited from discrimination, and we discriminate against a different set of junior engineers in order to "balance the scales". Two wrongs don't make a right.

Furthermore, as a method for achieving justice this is highly dysfunctional. There's no way to get consensus on what the "sentence" should be. There's no way to measure the degree to which the "sentence" has been meted out. It's just a big case of "squeaky wheel gets the grease". The more DEI professionals you hire, the more they will advocate for the need to hire DEI professionals, until the thing collapses into self-parody and Trump gets re-elected.

It's already possible to sue corporations for discrimination and violation of civil rights law. Why is this remedy insufficient? Maybe because there isn't actually a good legal case to be made that the alleged discrimination actually occurred, and people are just grasping at straws?

In any case: We can play these sort of zero-sum and negative-sum games until the cows come home. Functional societies don't cry over spilled milk, and instead focus on positive-sum games. To facilitate positive-sum games, we need a stable and predictable legal framework, not quixotic justice quests which mysteriously get ever more urgent the more the injustice recedes into the past.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by dctoedt on Saturday November 01, 2025 @06:45PM (#45786139)
> You can’t undo racial discrimination against someone who is now dead by discriminating against someone else who is now alive.

A better way to look at it: We can and should try to mitigate the indirect, generational disadvantages of past racial discrimination. Some of those disadvantages are domino effects, manifested over many years. They're the evil twin of generational wealth.

Those generational disadvantages can be a drag on the descendants of the victims of the past discrimination. That gives a certain amount of comparative advantage to those of us whose ancestors didn't suffer racial discrimination — and who benefit from present-day white advantage even when our ancestors weren't among the racial oppressors.

Sure, my various immigrant grandparents, great-grandparents, and great-great-grandparents had to deal with a certain amount of ethnic discrimination. But it was nothing like that suffered by nonwhites.

The YouTube "head start in the race of life" video is spot on. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8vvHWAjh3Ks

Some will say, it's not my job to mitigate today's effects of past discrimination. That seems ... uncitizenly, if you will.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by epistasis on Monday October 27, 2025 @09:33PM (#45728372)
> "this quarter, we only have headcount for 'diverse' candidates",

Such a statement from those with hiring authority is highly illegal. Any HR department that would let this message be delivered, either explicitly or implicitly, would open the company to massive lawsuits, such as the one you linked to. It's as bad as allowing sexual harassment.

Linking the term DEI to illegal hiring practices is like linking having a male manager to sexual harassment. The entire point of DEI was to eliminate illegal biases.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by jchw on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @12:17AM (#45729154)
> Linking the term DEI to illegal hiring practices is like linking having a male manager to sexual harassment.

Obviously, it is not fair to discredit all DEI initiatives simply because some of them (possibly a small minority of them) have lead to illegal hiring practices, but it is nonetheless an issue that it happens. That's obviously still true even if it seems entirely antithetical to the point of said initiatives. How much of an issue it really is we can only really postulate, though.

Personally, I feel the existence of illegal discrimination in service of improving diversity numbers felt like it was treated as an open secret for almost as long as I've been working in tech. I honestly figured it was mostly an urban myth, but it does seem to be a recurring problem that needs addressing.

(I also was somewhat skeptical of police ticket quotas being prevalent, as they are routinely brought up in every day conversation despite being illegal in most jurisdictions I've been, but that also turned out to be largely accurate. Color me surprised.)

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by alistairSH on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @05:46AM (#45730876)
How much of an issue it really is we can only really postulate, though.

Between the Labor Dept and various think-tanks/economic research groups, there should/could be data.

I suspect there are a small number of very public MegaCorps doing illegal DEI and that’s enough to illicit the backlash we’re seeing.

I know from my own employer, DEI is about outreach during recruiting and a combination of training for all employees and providing opportunities for people to gather and talk (via coffee talks and round tables that with DEI topics, but open to all).

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by potato3732842 on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @06:26AM (#45731099)
>I and that’s enough to illicit the backlash we’re seeing.

Gee, it's almost like we're re-learning what the origin of the phrase "even the appearance of impropriety" is.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by TimorousBestie on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @06:49AM (#45731230)
Unfortunately, it’s trivial these days to gin up the appearance of impropriety even where there is none.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by rayiner on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @08:21AM (#45731855)
I would estimate illegal DEI was happening at more than half of top 100 firms. I’m not as familiar with corporations, but I would be checked if it was less than 25% of Fortune 100s. The HR folks all attend the same conferences together. And the big corps set the permission structure for how everyone else acts.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by jchw on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @12:49PM (#45735310)
My thought is, if this sort of problem was happening at a company as big and influential in the industry as Google, that's already pretty bad. The backlash may not be warranted either way but the other position (that everything is fine and nothing needs to be done) isn't necessarily correct either.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by epistasis on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @02:19PM (#45736699)
> that everything is fine and nothing needs to be done

That's a complete statement that nobody is even advocating for. We already have the enforcement mechanisms in place.

Just because a law is violated doesn't mean that we get rid of the entire scheme and try something else. Theft does not mean that we need to get rid of property rights, and theft doesn't mean that we need to stop people from seeking material goods.

Perhaps there should be better enforcement mechanisms, but I'm sure that all the DEI advocates would be all ears, because the illegal violations of the law are not what DEI advocates want, precisely because it leads to backlashes in addition to being counter to the explicit goals of all DEI advocates I have ever heard.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by jchw on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @06:28PM (#45740099)
> That's a complete statement that nobody is even advocating for. We already have the enforcement mechanisms in place.

> Just because a law is violated doesn't mean that we get rid of the entire scheme and try something else. Theft does not mean that we need to get rid of property rights, and theft doesn't mean that we need to stop people from seeking material goods.

> Perhaps there should be better enforcement mechanisms, but I'm sure that all the DEI advocates would be all ears, because the illegal violations of the law are not what DEI advocates want, precisely because it leads to backlashes in addition to being counter to the explicit goals of all DEI advocates I have ever heard.

My point is just that it seems to be a real problem worth discussion and consideration, not just something made up for concern trolling. Whenever you have potential incentives to violate the law, there is reason to be somewhat concerned. It doesn't always manifest, but sometimes it does.

(P.S.: It is true that nobody is advocating for illegal hiring practices, at least not in good faith. Still, disregarding the apparent connection between DEI initiatives and illegal hiring practices they can incentivize just terminates the discussion.)

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by alistairSH on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @01:31PM (#45735980)
Agreed, I think.

The solution to "DEI has run amok!" is not "Ban DEI!" but "better define what DEI means and what is within bounds/outside bounds". But, the latter doesn't fit on a campaign poster, so here we are...

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by rayiner on Monday October 27, 2025 @10:00PM (#45728522)
> Such a statement from those with hiring authority is highly illegal. Any HR department that would let this message be delivered, either explicitly or implicitly, would open the company to massive lawsuits, such as the one you linked to.

You’re correct about the law, and the EEOC interpretation has been consistent for decades: https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/guidance/section-15-race-and-color.... But in practice, in many though not all places, “DEI” became a vehicle for double standards, quotas, and other illegal hiring practices.

I suspect what happened is that a generation of professionals went through university systems where racial preferences were practiced openly: https://nypost.com/2023/06/29/supreme-court-affirmative-acti.... When they got into corporate America, including law firms, they brought those ideas with them. But even though pre-SFFA law authorized race-based affirmative action in universities, it was never legal for hiring.

So you had this situation where not only did the big corporations engage in illegal hiring practices. But their law firms advising them were themselves engaged in illegal hiring practices. They all opened themselves up to major liability.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by KPGv2 on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:06PM (#45728853)
> I suspect what happened is that a generation of professionals went through university systems where racial preferences were practiced openly

I feel like you're ignoring that racial preferences were practiced openly for the entirety of the existence of the university systems in the US. It's just that for almost all of time, the preference was for "white non-Jews" (where "white" was historically malleable: Benjamin Franklin wrote a somewhat famous screed about how Germans and Swedes weren't white, they were inferior, and they were "darken[ing America]'s people"

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by rayiner on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:22PM (#45728928)
The Civil Rights Act of 1964 banned that and it was awhile before the discrimination was rebooted to run in the opposite direction.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by KPGv2 on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:32PM (#45728976)
So in other words, it went on for a few centuries like I said.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by rayiner on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:37PM (#45728991)
Correct. Then we made it illegal, but universities started doing it in the other direction. That’s the timeframe relevant to my point, which is about the people who made the illegal hiring decisions in 2020. They went to universities in the 21st century, not in 1945.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by amanaplanacanal on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @04:25AM (#45730338)
How else are they going to balance out all the legacy admissions?
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by koolba on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @06:02AM (#45730973)
Why does an hard working non-legacy white boy deserve less of a shot than a non-legacy black one? Why should he be penalized because someone else’s father with a comparable skin tan was accepted 25 years ago?
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by drekk on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @04:00AM (#45743956)
43% of all white students at Harvard are legacy, athletes, directly related to faculty, or have family that donated to the university. That number falls to 16% or lower for black, latino, and asian students.

75% of that aforementioned group of white students would not have been admitted had it been based on merit. 70 percent of all legacy applicants are white, compared with 40 percent of all applicants who do not fall under those categories.

Why does the average applicant need to be penalized when their grandparents legally could not attend these institutions? I think it's pretty obvious why people have such reactions to DEI when it's literally just "legacies for people who legally were barred from participating".

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/ncna1060361

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by koolba on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @06:08AM (#45744775)
> Why does the average applicant need to be penalized when their grandparents legally could not attend these institutions? I think it's pretty obvious why people have such reactions to DEI when it's literally just "legacies for people who legally were barred from participating".

Averages are meaningless, only individuals matter. Suggesting that preference for legacies be removed is a fine topic on its own, but it's orthogonal to explicitly discriminating against individual applicants based upon the color of their skin.

Since you clearly feel strongly about this topic, I'll ask again. Why should the poor white kid with no legacy relationship get cast aside for some other non-legacy kid with a tan?

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by rayiner on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @08:43AM (#45746095)
> Averages are meaningless, only individuals matter.

Exactly. We shouldn’t treat similarly situated people differently because of group averages. That’s the definition of racism.

It’s also irrational in practice. If you want to compare whose grandparents had it harder, Indians and Chinese are clearly entitled to the most affirmative action.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by rayiner on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @08:08AM (#45731742)
Why do you need to balance them out?
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by TimorousBestie on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @12:01AM (#45729100)
Discrimination didn’t magically end with the Civil Rights Act, either. American universities are still mostly good ol’ boy networks in all the relevant ways.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by rayiner on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @08:12AM (#45731771)
Discrimination mostly ended with the civil rights act, yes. Universities and large employers are highly merit-based today. My dad was born in a village in Bangladesh. He took a boat to school during monsoon season. His son went to Yale and works at J.P. Morgan. His other son (me) went to Northwestern for law school and ended up at a white shoe law firm that used to not hire Catholics. We’re not even that smart, just grinders in a country that values grinders and doesn’t care about your skin color.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by wredcoll on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @03:42PM (#45737992)
> The Civil Rights Act of 1964 banned that and it was awhile before the discrimination was rebooted to run in the opposite direction.

Wow, I am extremely happy to know that all racism ended in 1964!

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by CyberDildonics on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @11:10PM (#45742188)
Marijuana was made illegal in 1937 and it stopped being used completely for the next 70 years.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by potato3732842 on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @06:15AM (#45731040)
>Benjamin Franklin wrote a somewhat famous screed about how Germans and Swedes weren't white, they were inferior, and they were "darken[ing America]'s people"

I am going to use the crap out of that reference whenever I see people on HN creatively redefining Europe to exclude parts in order to dishonestly back up some point.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by veeti on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @02:09PM (#45736568)
Should we be giving Swedish people special treatment and privileges in 2025, or how long until bygones are bygones?
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by FloorEgg on Monday October 27, 2025 @10:01PM (#45728527)
I don't think that's quite fair, as in many cases there were federal regulations that pressured industries into behavior that was discriminatory to one group in order to favor others. In fact there was an accumulation of contradictory laws and regulations over 15+ years. In many cases regulations were set that had financial repercussions if hiring practices that were considered illegal weren't followed. There is a respectful interpretation of one of the conservative concerns during the election in that the accumulation of regulations made it impossible to conduct business legally and compliant with regulations in some industries.

Personally I'm very much for the goals of DEI and very much against some of the means that were being taken to reach those goals. It's an extremely difficult and complex problem.

I can't help but wonder if the movement had just focused on inclusion and primarily where there is leverage towards future prosperity, if there wouldn't have been such a backlash and the efforts would have been enduring and compounding.

Slipping that "equity" in there is a trap to confuse responsibility with privilege and cause a lot of trouble that is extremely hard to work through. It's the justification for representation-driven hiring and selection (affirmative action), and equity based hiring practices that were both federally mandated AND constitutionally illegal at the same time.

I can't help but suspect it's something like satisfaction, where if you pursue it directly it's fleeting and destructive but if you focus on the inputs you get more of it and it's enduring.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by renlo on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:15PM (#45728892)
Most eye opening experience in my personal development was attending HR conferences (we sold an HR product but I am an engineer), where speakers were openly saying this out loud. I know you won’t believe me given your statement, but using codewords they said they were trying to hire “diverse candidates”, retain “diverse candidates”, explicitly mark “non-diverse candidates” leaving as non-regrettable churn, filtering and searching for diverse employees within the company to fast track for promotion, etc. I was in shock how brazenly they were saying the quiet part out loud, and breaking the law. This was 10 years ago, there were no repercussions for it, in fact they were all lauded.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by rayiner on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:25PM (#45728942)
It wasn’t even coded in many cases. I’ve had pitch meetings where I had to explain how I was brown as part of an express consideration of the business decision. White people talked about my race to my face more in 2020-2021 than during seven years in the south starting right after 9/11.

Some “DEI” was high level measures like recruiting at a broader set of universities. But in the last 5 years it routinely got down to discussing the race of specific individuals in the context of whether to hire them or enter into business relationships.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by cycomanic on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @05:35AM (#45730813)
It's funny how everyone brings up all these anecdotes, but then the reality is that there are plenty of studies that show that if your name is associated with being black you have much lower chances to be invited to an interview.

So seems like all this talk by HR people didn't really change any hiring practices. It's also funny how everyone is outraged by the DEI programs, instead of the real discrimination that is happening in hiring.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by WesolyKubeczek on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @05:56AM (#45730942)
Hint: if everyone has such anecdotes, they are no longer anecdotes.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by heroprotagonist on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @11:34AM (#45734240)
No, they're still anecdotes.

   anecdote   /'ænɪk,doʊt/
   noun
   short account of an incident (especially a biographical one)
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @04:07PM (#45738408)
It's enough to show that something isn't ultra rare, but it's not enough to show whether it's happening at 0.1% of companies or 90% of companies or where in between.

If someone is racist in a manner that's outweighed 10:1 by opposite racist practices, that's something we do want to stop, but it shouldn't be top priority and definitely shouldn't be treated as the example of what racism looks like these days.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by rayiner on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @02:18AM (#45743263)
There is very little evidence of those “opposite racist practices” that are supposedly 10 times more common, at least in large corporations and universities. Microsoft was out there promising to double the percentage of black executives. Where is the big corporations promising to double the number of white executives?
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @04:06AM (#45744012)
As mentioned a couple comments up, something like this: https://bfi.uchicago.edu/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/A-Discri... is way more impactful then some CEO choices.

I can't find the Microsoft thing, but apparently among fortune 500 companies only 1.6% of CEOs are black. Even double that would still be an extremely low number. So unless you think some truly cosmic random odds happened here, that 1.6% is evidence of lots of racism.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by rayiner on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @08:16AM (#45745815)
These studies are misleading, because they try to create race signals by using names that are also class signals: https://newsroom.ucla.edu/releases/ucla-study-suggests-resea....

Also, the study suggests that, even with this flawed methodology, a bulk of industries are in the least discrimination category with only a 3% lower callback rate for “black sounding names.”

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @10:57AM (#45747669)
Do you have any numbers for trying to correct for that factor?

And the bulk are not at 3%, the bulk are between 5 and 10. 3 was the absolute lowest.

Also you didn't mention the CEO thing, does that mean my numbers were sufficient to address that worry?

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by rayiner on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @08:23PM (#45754903)
As I read it, the industries were grouped into three categories. “Least discriminatory” was at 3%. Those are all the industries in green. These are small differences in a study that’s not well designed to begin with.

The explicit discrimination in universities against whites and asians is huge in comparison: https://nypost.com/2023/06/29/supreme-court-affirmative-acti.... A black applicant to Harvard with an academic index in the 5th decile had an 800-900% higher chance of admission than a white or asian candidate with the same qualifications. This isn’t just CEOs. The pattern was similar at UNC, a state school.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by Dylan16807 on Thursday October 30, 2025 @03:59PM (#45764603)
> As I read it, the industries were grouped into three categories. “Least discriminatory” was at 3%.

The least single industry was 3%. And each single industry is a very noisy data point, based on a couple companies and needing more data points. By the time you aggregate into more solid data, like those bigger categories, it's more than 3%.

But the whole thing could use better methods and more data for sure.

> The explicit discrimination in universities against whites and asians is huge in comparison

In comparison to this specific resume effect it's pretty big, but that was just a basic example, not an attempt to list the biggest issue.

In comparison to the fortune 500 CEOs the overall effect here is smaller (no I'm not going to look at 5th decile in isolation).

Also even after this bias was applied, they're admitting a below-population-average amount of black students and a far above-population-average amount of asian students. So there's a bunch of other data necessary to properly analyze what's going on and how bad it is. Should there be a super tight correlation to academic decile? There are huge differences in school quality that muddy the signals, and those differences often correlate with race.

I'm not saying they did nothing wrong, but I'm saying it's unclear what the numbers should have been.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by JuniperMesos on Thursday October 30, 2025 @12:52PM (#45762159)
Why is that a low number? What is the correct percentage of Fortune 500 CEOs to be black, or any other specific ethnic background.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by tgsovlerkhgsel on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @11:53PM (#45756260)
What do you think happens when one level of leadership sets a metric as a goal, and likely ties someone's bonus to that goal?

The metric-goal gets pushed down to lower hierarchy levels, and from then on, all it takes is turning a blind eye and you get the results we've seen in the court case I cited above. The smart ones just don't put it in writing.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by JuniperMesos on Thursday October 30, 2025 @12:51PM (#45762147)
A lot of the contemporary formal scientific process is done incredibly badly, for a variety of reasons including overt political bias on the part of individual scientists working in the academic system, pressure to publish any results including poor ones, and outright laziness and fraud. In general we shouldn't assume that if a bunch of public scientific studies purport to show that some phenomenon is happening, that that phenomenon is actually happening. It takes substantial time, effort, and experience to evaluate whether a claimed scientific result is valid; and all the moreso when that result has immediate political policy implications.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by klipt on Monday October 27, 2025 @09:46PM (#45728439)
That's like saying "the Crusaders weren't real Christians because real Christianity is peaceful"

See also: No True Scotsman Fallacy

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by epistasis on Monday October 27, 2025 @09:57PM (#45728503)
No, that's not at all the case, the crusaders were acting under the blessing of the church. It still may not be "real" Christianity, but it's not like there were DEI advocates out there giving guides on how to break the law. I was at two companies promoting DEI that were explicit about non-discrimination and had extensive training on it to prevent the illegal actions linked in that lawsuit.

There's no "this is DEI this is not DEI" but any halfway sane and truthful assessment would focus on what the proponents claimed, said, and propagated as their intentions. Just as the Christians of the time were intending to do with the crusades.

Calling this a "no true Scotsman fallacy" is just attempting to misapply a logical fallacy to avoid looking at the issue truthfully and honestly.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by FloorEgg on Monday October 27, 2025 @10:07PM (#45728566)
> it's not like there were DEI advocates out there giving guides on how to break the law

I think you're very mistaken. Not only were their guides, but there were federal regulations mandating that the laws be broken. It is/was a mess.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by judahmeek on Monday October 27, 2025 @10:35PM (#45728705)
What are your sources?
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by FloorEgg on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:02PM (#45728838)
The federal regulations... It's not hard to find if you go looking...
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by judahmeek on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:07PM (#45728857)
Then it shouldn't be hard for you to say something other than 'do your own research'
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by FloorEgg on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:32PM (#45728977)
I became aware of the legal contradictions last summer and spent a few hours doing searches and reading through the relevant regulatory language for a few industries. I don't have all the references handy.

I don't work for you. It's not my job to do research for you. If you're genuinely curious and interested in the truth it won't be hard for you to find. Literally go search and read the regulatory language in a few major industries. Start with the department of education. It doesn't seem like you're curious though, it seems like you're combative.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by epistasis on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @12:50PM (#45735317)
That's fine, of course you don't work for anyone else! But you are also not going to convince anyone else by being vague and refusing to give any specifics.

Usually when somebody makes broad vague assertions of evidence but refuses to back it up, I find that they are either mistaken about their experiences and that their take aways do not really follow from their primary evidence. Though usually it's those on the more DEI side that say "I'm not responsible for educating you" that make these mistakes! In the past year I'm seeing it from people that think DEI is about discrimination, so it's an interesting evolution. The argument is still unconvincing, no matter who says it. And again, I'm not saying you must produce anything for anybody else, I'm just saying that you end up looking like you don't have anything to actually produce.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by FloorEgg on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @03:20PM (#45737627)
Actually, I work for many people: My customers, my colleagues, my family. I just don't work for strangers on HN.

My mistake was answering judahmeek's question directly. They asked "What are your sources?" and I answered with the truth, that my impressions came from reading the regulations myself. Instead I should have just not replied at all, because I didn't have the time then to go re-do the research and find all the links. It's not like I save every link I visit when exploring my own curiosity. I am not trying to get some paper published here, just trying to understand whats going on and occasionally share what things seem like to me on HN. Also if they had said something like "This is shocking to me, can you point me where to look into this for myself" I would have probably waited and made a more constructive response.

I hope you appreciate that I just took time out of my day to do this for you, primarily because I found your response (in contrast to judahmeek's) reasonably respectful.

What I noticed when I looked into this last year was that regulatory implementations of the affirmative action executive order 11246 continuously increased and seemed to hit a couple inflection points. I think one was in 2000 and one was in 2021, but there may have been more. I didn't save all the sources that I read to give me the impression I got last year, but after spending about 30 min trying to find at least some of them, it wasn't hard to start to see the picture again.

Note that there is a lot of disparate facts here that paint a picture, and they will paint different pictures depending on the stance the reader starts with before engaging. When I explored this last time, I came at it with curious skepticism. The picture they painted for me, was that something that was well intentioned (affirmative action) came with an assumption: if organizations hire blindly based on merit, over time the distributions of their workforce will match the distributions of the pool of applicants applying to work there. To implement affirmative action these organizations need to include everyone in the pools of applicants, which may require disproportional outreach to invite minorities. Based on this assumption, recommendations were made into outreach programs and requirements were set to measure outcomes. Over time the outcomes didn't match expectations, so regulatory pressure was increased. As the regulatory pressure increased, it put more pressure on all levels within these organizations to take action beyond just outreach programs. So what was federally mandated across many industries specifically was race, gender, sexuality reporting and making plans to reach distributions representative of the broader population. Given this accountability set by federal regulations, and decades of efforts to try to solve the problem with outreach and merit based hiring not leading to the expected outcomes, efforts naturally expanded beyond outreach into all relevant decisions (hiring, promoting). That is how you get people being hired and promoted based on race, gender, sexuality instead of merit. (The exact opposite of the original intention).

For example in Title 41: https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-41/subtitle-B/chapter-60/... See 60-2.16 placement goals

Federal contract compliance programs https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2014/12/09/2014-28...

FAR 52.222-23 https://www.acquisition.gov/far/52.222-23 Construction firms must set goals for gender participation in workforce

SEC Release no 34-92590 https://www.sec.gov/files/rules/sro/nasdaq/2021/34-92590.pdf Publicly traded companies that don't have at least two minorities on their board risk being delisted from exchanges

What I remember from last year as most shocking were Department of Education regulations and NSF incentives, but I can't find those primary sources now. The NSF website seems gutted. What I recall was that NSF set criteria in grant awards to incentivize institutions to have a diverse workforce. I can find evidence of this from secondary sources, but not the primary source I remember seeing last year. Similarly what I remember, is that the DOE mandated DEI reporting and planning and tied it to federal funding/support. The effect was that leaders would put pressure on the organization beyond just job placement recruitment/outreach. The reporting and accountability focused on diversity and representation throughout the entire organization, and so the "plans" and more importantly implications would extend beyond just outreach and impact placement decisions from hiring, to special training / career acceleration programs and promotions.

I think it crossed a line for some people in the years following 2021 (EO 13985) when these regulations were expanded to include factors related to peoples sexual orientation and preferences. Once some manager who was just trying to get through their quarter and hire the candidate that will the do best job has to forgo what seems like the best candidate in favor of some other candidate because of how they chose to identify or who they like to have sex with, well... yeah it was getting ridiculous.

Let me be extremely clear that I don't condone discrimination. I think we should do our best to support everyone to thrive. We just have to be careful about confusing responsibility with privilege, and respect how hard it is to design incentive systems that actually produce the desired outcomes.

You can look at the evidence that I am presenting here and call it weak and argue against it. Or you can consider that I dug this up in 30 min on my lunch break as a favor to you, as someone with no motive other than curiosity and concern.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by SR2Z on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @05:38PM (#45739573)
See Brigida v Buttigieg, if you want a spectacularly dumb example of how bad a DEI program can get. These are not hard examples to find, although I will concede that the "post-truth" anecdotes from the anti-woke camp can lead to a lot of cruft to sift through.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by FloorEgg on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @06:26PM (#45740083)
Actually it took me almost an hour to re-do a portion of the research and lay it out, which I did further down the thread, if you care to look.

Also you didn't ask me to link you to my sources, you asked me what my sources were. I answered your question directly in the best way I could at the time.

Expecting an internet stranger to spend an hour digging up sources for you, when you don't ask respectfully or with any inclination of curiosity comes off as combative - I am not here to debate, I am here to discuss. If you are genuinely curious, take 30 seconds to scroll down and find the other comment I made that took me an hour to put together.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by judahmeek on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @01:08AM (#45742846)
I appreciate that you took the time to follow through with sources to support your claim.

You & I definitely have different definitions of "not hard to find", however.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by FloorEgg on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @08:06AM (#45745723)
I guess so, but it's relative. An hour isn't hard if you're driven by curiosity, but it is if it's a chore you're doing for someone else.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by xdennis on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @12:44AM (#45729266)
Here's an example: the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 allocated grants to help restaurant owners. It did so on a racist basis: if the restaurant is owned primarily by women, veterans, or the "socially and economically disadvantaged".

There was a trial. The government lost. https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca6/21...

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by epistasis on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @01:37AM (#45729510)
That is not an example of DEI advocates giving guidelines on how to break the law.

That is Congress passing a law distributing grants in a way that was determined to be illegal, quite different! And in fact there are long standing government contracting preferences of that sort, from long before DEI was a term or something that corporate America sought.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by tremon on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @09:18AM (#45732517)
I fail to see any difference between "congress passing a law that is in violation of another law" and "federal regulations mandating that laws be broken". Can you explain how these situations differ quitely, other than that "regulation" and "law" are different words?
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by epistasis on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @12:45PM (#45735248)
The difference was an incentive grant program that was found to be discriminatory, versus regulations which dictate how private entities act. This a pretty big distinction.

It's an especially big distinction when the question was for sources of DEI advocates handing out instructions to corporate decision makers no how to break the law. It's not even remotely connected.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by judahmeek on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @02:12PM (#45736610)
Regulations are made by federal agencies.

Laws are made by Congress.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by rayiner on Monday October 27, 2025 @10:29PM (#45728671)
Your point is well taken. Not everyone was violating the law. But meanwhile Microsoft was setting explicit numeric targets on hiring employees from particular racial groups: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/wells-fargo-microsoft-diversity....

Companies were also demanding race-conscious staffing practices at the law firms they used: https://www.wsj.com/business/law-firm-clients-demand-more-bl.... Microsoft offered financial bonuses to law firms for promoting lawyers from specific racial groups: https://today.westlaw.com/Document/If3eb4570033e11eb8e48d387....

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by rlprlprlp on Monday October 27, 2025 @10:01PM (#45728532)
Sure, but you’re god deciding who goes to hell.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by colechristensen on Monday October 27, 2025 @10:57PM (#45728809)
Illegal stuff happens all the time in the workplace and very frequently goes unreported, underreported, or otherwise results in nothing.

Using claims that something is illegal to discredit an argument is extremely dubious.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by throwaway48476 on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @02:45AM (#45729790)
Whether something is illegal is only loosely correlated with whether it is common. Eg the war on drugs.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by gcanyon on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:57PM (#45729082)
Did that case ever resolve?

In your mind, if Google researched their past hiring and found that whites/males had been favored for, let's say, the past 15 years, how long would it be reasonable for them to favor minorities and other underrepresented groups to balance the scales?

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by hitekker on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @02:47AM (#45729800)
YC's Jessica Livingston and the founder of TripleByte observed the similar racial and sex quotas from the inside: https://x.com/jesslivingston/status/1884652626467303560

IBM's CEO infamously championed DEI-as-quota which led to wave of lawsuits that IBM was forced to settle.

The memory holing on this topic is concerning.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by virx61 on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @12:19PM (#45734861)
“Memory hole” is a term that should be reserved for things everybody actually forgets. This is more of a thing lots of people probably remember, but they don’t bring it up all the time.
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by SR2Z on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @05:36PM (#45739556)
No, lots of people willingly stuck their heads in the sand and ignored the abuses that were happening. See Brigida v Buttigieg for a particularly egregious example around the hiring of ATC.

The FAA, on an official test that ATC candidates were required to take, would disqualify applicants if they didn't answer questions like "what was your worst subject in school" with answers like "math" or "science." This explicitly was to increase racial diversity, which is both patronizing in the extreme and really stupid.

When I bring this up in SF, people accuse me of making it up. It's not that people don't remember it, it's that political polarization has blinded us to our side doing batshit crazy things. Another similar example was "defund the police" which is a crazy slogan on its face, yet for a year Democrats felt compelled to sanewash it.

I am about as blue and pro-DEI as someone could reasonably be and I think that this stuff is small potatoes compared to a president who has been continuously trying to send the army in to crush Democratic-leaning cities. That being said, I'm pretty sympathetic to people who are suspicious of DEI because we do not have a good track record of auditing these programs.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by davorak on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @10:05AM (#45746999)
> YC's Jessica Livingston and the founder of TripleByte

I listened to video and I did not see anywhere where Jessica made an observation along those lines.

I did not hear quotas talked about explicitly either, though companies wanting more diverse candidates from TripleByte, which might have been caused by quotes in the company but Harj does not indicate any companies came out and said that.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by hitekker on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @06:13PM (#45753769)
The rest of the Spotify podcast covers Jessica's side, but I think you've missed the subtext.

I'll summarize: TripleByte guy describes how companies prioritized diversity over merit in their hiring goals; quotas in layman's terms. He was annoyed that many companies refused to acknowledge the trade-off and instead blamed TripleByte for (in my words) real-world, supply-side scarcity.

IMHO, the part that rankles from that interview into this thread is the dishonesty around that trade-off. The comforting lie that diversity and merit can be found at scale, even when the world market only has so many "diverse" and "meritorious" candidates available for a given position. This comes up in other fields, like Music. "Blind auditions are merit, therefore DEI" was once espoused, until the more dedicated DEI supporters realized that focusing on the fruit of work wasn't creating enough diversity https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/16/arts/music/blind-audition...

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by davorak on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @09:36PM (#45755447)
> The rest of the Spotify podcast covers Jessica's side, but I think you've missed the subtext.

Link's? Timestamps? I skimmed the much of the podcast now and I did not hear anything like this from Jessica.

> prioritized diversity over merit in their hiring goals; quotas in layman's terms

Quota is specifically a fixed share of something. "prioritized diversity over merit in their hiring goals" is not a quota, but an approach like that could be motivated by a quota.

I think quota has specific legal ramifications too so when the term was used in the comment but not used in the link I thought it was important to point it out.

> prioritized diversity over merit in their hiring goals;

I have only fully watched the video you linked to as of yet, not the full podcast. The companies Harj talked about wanted diversity in that top TripleByte metric pool, something that Harj said they were not able to supply. To me it sounds like the companies are clearly saying what they want but Harj/TripleByte was not able to supply.

Harj's says the companies would not explicitly ask for lowering the metric cut off for diversity. My attempt to transcribe what he said "noone would actually want to explicitly say that".

> He was annoyed that many companies refused to acknowledge the trade-off and instead blamed TripleByte for (in my words) real-world, supply-side scarcity.

Most clients in my experience are annoyed when they want something, want to pay you for it, and you can not provide it. The details and complexities often do not factor in, they want a black box they stick money in and get a solution out so they can focus on their companies core competences.

> IMHO, the part that rankles from that interview into this thread is the dishonesty around that trade-off. The comforting lie ...

You seem to making a big claim, but it is not detailed in a way that I can respond to. I do not see TripleByte or Harj claiming they are doing science or demographic research about the world populations I do not think an large or sweeping claims can be built off what they are saying.

> This comes up in other fields, like Music. "Blind auditions are merit, therefore DEI" was once espoused, until the more dedicated DEI supporters realized that focusing on the fruit of work wasn't creating enough diversity https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/16/arts/music/blind-audition...

The article you link to here is a particular persons opinion and advocates for change that person wants, it does not document anything more general than that like your statement implied. It does not document a trend in the field of moving away from blind auditions, I don't follow the field closely so I would know if there is one, but this article does not document it.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by kelnos on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @03:13AM (#45729943)
> This is how DEI should work, and probably does in some, or maybe many, cases.

It's hard to take these sorts of complaints seriously unless you can quantify in what percentage of cases we get the bad kind of DEI you describe.

Sure, if 90% of DEI is discriminatory hiring practices, then sure, that's a problem. But if it's 10% instead, then we should certainly call it out, but we should accept that, in any kind of initiative, there's going to be some bad behavior.

(Instead, of course, the right turns it into a culture war topic.)

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by tgsovlerkhgsel on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @03:58AM (#45730180)
Given that it was technically illegal (but IMO very common) back then, it's hard to quantify. Usually, they were smart enough to not put the most blatant parts in writing, and of course the same HR departments pushing this were also doing outreach.

All that I can say is that the form of DEI that I, myself, saw and experienced certainly included a lot of the "bad" form, people were justifying it (and some still are in this thread), and it was very clear that daring to criticize it would be a career-limiting move. You can look at the rest of the thread to see both personal anecdotes and further sources showing other large companies doing this.

The way it usually worked was that metrics for diversity hiring were set top down, without specifying how they should be achieved, and then the company openly turned a blind eye to such "bad behavior".

Even with the current backlash, at least I don't have the impression that proponents of DEI will be ostracized and/or fired just for daring to suggest it.

I suspect it works so well as a "culture war topic" because many people have personal experiences not just with such practices, but also with being silenced and gaslit (told that what they experienced doesn't actually happen and is just a culture war topic) when trying to speak out against them.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by cycomanic on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @05:47AM (#45730881)
If it really was this common how come that the percentages of e.g. blacks in tech jobs didn't actually change significantly. I mean if you listen to people here it sounds like companies were absolutely flooded by DEI hires.

It is also quite telling how everyone is up in arms about these discriminatory hiring practices, but the same people don't bat an eyelash about the fact that discrimination happens mostly the other way, I don't know how many studies I've read that showed that cv's with names associated with certain ethnicities have much lower chances to be invited to interview than the same cv with a white name.

> Even with the current backlash, at least I don't have the impression that proponents of DEI will be ostracized and/or fired just for daring to suggest it.

Have you read the actual article?

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by potato3732842 on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @07:29AM (#45731474)
>If it really was this common how come that the percentages of e.g. blacks in tech jobs didn't actually change significantly.

Because the race based pity hiring programs didn't actually address the pipeline problems.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by tgsovlerkhgsel on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @11:54PM (#45756265)
> Have you read the actual article?

The PSF grant one or a different one? In the PSF one, nobody is getting ostracized and fired for daring to suggest DEI, in fact, they are turning down a grant for a more pro-DEI stance.

You might be in trouble for actually implementing DEI programs, but it's not a taboo topic that can't even safely be talked about. Criticism of any DEI-related practice, whether it's illegal hiring discrimination or presubmits that yell at you for using an ever-expanding list of now-verboten words, was taboo in many places.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by throwawaykf10 on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @03:48AM (#45730124)
You have cited a lawsuit (of which there is no recorded outcome, so probably an out-of-court settlement) against the same company that has had to pay millions for discriminating AGAINST women and minorities.

https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/news/google-settles-28...

So maybe one could argue maybe they were not DEI enough!

On this topic HN almost always devolves into anecdotes. There's gotta be data on this. What does the data say? How much have DEI efforts shifted the demographics in these companies and/or the professional prospects of minorities?

My guess: no change at all, because it's all performative.

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by Thorrez on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @07:44AM (#45731587)
Check out Google's diversity report[1], pages 63-110. It contains a lot of data. E.g. for US tech hiring, in 2015 2.2% of hires were Black+, in 2024, it was 10.0%. For global tech hiring, in 2015 19.6% of hires were women, in 2024, it was 30.2%.

Disclosure: I work at Google.

[1] https://kstatic.googleusercontent.com/files/819bcce604bf5ff7...

Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by tremon on Tuesday October 28, 2025 @09:37AM (#45732733)
Only looking at hiring % doesn't mean anything if we don't know the composition of the hiring pool. For example, page 64 shows that Google's APAC offices have 90.7% Asian workers, up from 90.4% a year earlier -- at the expense of all other ethnicities. Is Google doing a bad job there, or is this an accurate reflection of the available workforce?
Re:PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant p... by Thorrez on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @09:07AM (#45746352)
throwawaykf10 said:

>On this topic HN almost always devolves into anecdotes. There's gotta be data on this. What does the data say? How much have DEI efforts shifted the demographics in these companies and/or the professional prospects of minorities?

>My guess: no change at all, because it's all performative.

I provided data. Not anecdotes. The data shows how the demographics of Google have shifted. The data shows how the professional prospects of minorities have shifted when it comes to Google jobs. The data does not show "no change at all".

A change from 90.4% to 90.7% percentage points I doubt is statistically significant. Phrasing it "at the expense" sounds like it's some terrible decline.

The conversation so far I believe has been about DEI in the US. Why focus on APAC, instead of the the US?

>Only looking at hiring % doesn't mean anything if we don't know the composition of the hiring pool.

What does that mean? Are you saying that if the fraction of CS grads that are Black+ also increased from 2.2% to 10.0%, then Google's DEI efforts did nothing? That conclusion doesn't hold. Google has a lot of DEI efforts, including ones to increase the number of Black+ people who choose to major in CS.