News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by bee_rider on Monday October 27, 2025 @02:49AM (#45718064)
I actually don’t really get the point of a cloud service for this. Aren’t babies usually left in situations where there’s at least one trusted adult locally available?
Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by thaumasiotes on Monday October 27, 2025 @03:47AM (#45718342)
Yes, the normal solution to wondering how a baby is doing is to look over at it.
Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by afro88 on Monday October 27, 2025 @04:47AM (#45718648)
24/7?
Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by ragebol on Monday October 27, 2025 @06:02AM (#45719150)
> There is usually no noise or evidence of struggle

from [0]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SIDS

So, 24/7 kinda, yeah... Realistically, the risk is relatively low I'd say, so to still stay a functioning parent with other duties (for baby or otherwise), you don't look 24/7

Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by avereveard on Monday October 27, 2025 @04:32AM (#45718571)
Leading cause of death under one year is sudden infant death syndrome which happens mostly at nap time, situations where the adult may need rest, self care or housekeeping. You cannot fathomly watch an infant 24/7 especially if one parent is working and there's minimal support sistem (living far from relative, working grandparents etc)
Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by breakingcups on Monday October 27, 2025 @04:45AM (#45718639)
"Measures not shown to be useful include positioning devices and baby monitors."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SIDS

Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by lupire on Monday October 27, 2025 @08:17AM (#45720115)
That statement is ambiguous with regard to automated video analysis.
Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by avereveard on Monday October 27, 2025 @09:46AM (#45721003)
you quoting wikipedia? lol.

ox and hearth rate baby monitor definitely alert on sids. prevent, no, and that's why they are not medical devices, and wouldn't make sense to pay a randomized controlled trial to certify as one.

works? yeah. hearth stops beating, ox goes under parameter, parents get an alert.

here's the FDA statement about it https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/cdrh_docs/pdf22/K222597.pdf

Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by hobofan on Monday October 27, 2025 @05:48AM (#45719029)
The "point" of the cloud service is that it's sadly usually the easiest way to create a [on-premise-device]<->[user's smartphone/laptop] for B2C/residential deployments of appliances (like the baby monitor in this case).

It's much easier to create a device<->internet connection + a smartphone<->internet connection that it is to deal with the myriad of issues that occur if you try to do local device<->smartphone connections in networks with unknown topology and quirks (e.g. ISP provider being overly conservative in their firewall presets). If that in general would be a more trivial issue you would see less cloud services.

(You would probably still a similar amount of cloud services due the increased monetization options, but this would level the playing field for local-only options.)

Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by cube00 on Monday October 27, 2025 @06:13AM (#45719215)
Hopefully as IPv6 gets more adoption we'll be able to open up some of these services, although IoT devices never get firmware updates so they'll have to sit behind Wireguard so maybe not.
Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by ghm2180 on Monday October 27, 2025 @08:28AM (#45720215)
Why is it hard for a local device to expose a REST API from home —a DDNS updater could update IP address for a cname — and then access all the local data local_device(REST API) <> Smartphone?
Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by philipallstar on Monday October 27, 2025 @09:18AM (#45720738)
I would imagine these were the reasons:

- most people want to build lovely structures in the cloud, as it's hard to fix bugs in software on devices

- you'd need to open up a firewall on the home router

- auth might be tricky

- can't bolt on value added "enhancements"

Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by JCM9 on Monday October 27, 2025 @07:48AM (#45719886)
It’s an over engineered solution to a, relatively, simple problem of access long the device on the local network. This used to be a hard problem to solve but in 2025 I’d question why they’re going through the headache of all this cloud stuff when they could just build a quality device that runs locally with a simple base station that triggers alerts. They only hosting they really need is something to send alerts to an app.
Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by Aurornis on Monday October 27, 2025 @09:29AM (#45720856)
Yes, a parent is always around. The part you might be missing is that the parent doesn’t want to have to limit their movements to areas where WiFi coverage is good.

Many cheap baby monitors are WiFi connected. You have to haul the video unit around and keep it live to hear when it cuts out, then move back toward where WiFi coverage was good.

This won’t seem like a big deal to someone who lives in an apartment or who has a house with 7 Ubiquiti APs covering everywhere inside and out, but it is a big deal to a parent who has a single WiFi router and wants to be able to do something like pull weeds in the yard, have a conversation with the neighbor, or go to a detached garage and work on a project without having to worry about their exact WiFi coverage at every moment to check on the baby.