News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by sokoloff on Monday October 27, 2025 @01:44AM (#45717770)
Because it’s easy and convenient for new parents.

The typical parent has never heard of Synology or Ubiquiti, doesn’t have a NAS, and gets whatever tech their ISP gave/rents them.

Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by skrause on Monday October 27, 2025 @03:11AM (#45718176)
The baby monitor could have its own SD card and webserver and then you provide a smartphone app which uses local network discovery to find the server and talk to it.

In that case no parent needs to know about Synology or even IP addresses.

Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by krisoft on Monday October 27, 2025 @07:56AM (#45719956)
> In that case no parent needs to know about Synology or even IP addresses.

But they need to know about networking enough to be on the same network. I understand that sounds easy, but every time someone gets confused about their cursed setup the company making the device will get a returned product and an angry review. Client isolation, multiple wifi networks, some devices being on wifi some on the mobile network.

Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by chipsrafferty on Monday October 27, 2025 @11:32AM (#45722136)
Companies are making it harder and harder to use, or at least to understand how to use, your own network for anything other than "get Internet on device"
Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by unethical_ban on Monday October 27, 2025 @01:54AM (#45717811)
There is no technical requirement for an easy-to-use baby monitor to be cloud-connected. If there is no easy-to-use baby monitor which is not cloud-connected, that is a market problem, not a technical problem.
Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by Aurornis on Monday October 27, 2025 @09:24AM (#45720815)
> There is no technical requirement for an easy-to-use baby monitor to be cloud-connected.

A common use case for baby monitors is being able to wander short distances away and still listen in: Work in yard, talk to a neighbor, go out to the detached garage.

Having a baby monitor which is not tethered to the WiFi coverage is a selling point. Many cheap monitors are WiFi connected or use their own WiFi network and the range is limited.

A lot of people in this thread are also completely missing the selling points of Nanit which include breathing tracking and sleep tracking features. It’s a product that could technically be implemented locally with enough extra processing power and cloud servers for coordinating out of home access and bouncing notifications, but obviously the number of people who would pay extra for that (instead of trying to roll their own solution HN style) is not large.

Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by GMoromisato on Monday October 27, 2025 @10:03AM (#45721152)
Agreed. Maybe the market for easy-to-use, self-hosted baby monitors doesn’t exist.

I’d least I never heard a parent complain that their biggest problem dealing with a baby is lack of E2EE.

Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by chii on Monday October 27, 2025 @01:52AM (#45717801)
It's more that a typical parent has not thought of the need to have a baby monitor, until they have a baby (in which case, they're too busy to build out their own baby monitor stack).

Pay money to solve a problem and time-save as a parent is a valid business idea/strategy. The externalities that the parents might suffer if these businesses do not completely adhere to good security practices don't seem to come back to bite them (and most parents get lucky and not have any bad consequences - yet).

Re:We Saved $500k per Year by Rolling Our Own "S3" by threetonesun on Monday October 27, 2025 @09:35AM (#45720905)
It's much easier and less stressful to put your baby to sleep and (maybe) have a radio monitor. More technology does not inherently decrease stress.