News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can "second life" EV batteries work as grid-scale energy ... by Lucian6 on Thursday October 23, 2025 @05:31PM (#45687495)
Having worked extensively with battery systems, I think the grid storage potential of second-life EV batteries is more complex than it appears. We found that typical EV batteries retain 70-80% capacity after 8-10 years of vehicle use, but the real challenge is standardization and integration. Different manufacturers use vastly different battery management systems (BMS) and cell configurations - a Tesla pack is fundamentally different from a Nissan Leaf pack.

The economics are interesting though. New grid storage batteries cost around $200-300/kWh, while second-life EV batteries can be acquired for $50-100/kWh. However, you need to factor in significant integration costs (~$50-75/kWh) to build compatible BMS systems and thermal management. We also found cycle life degrades about 20% faster in repurposed packs compared to new ones, likely due to accumulated stress patterns from automotive use.

Has anyone here successfully integrated mixed second-life batteries at scale? I'm particularly curious about how you handled thermal management across different pack designs while maintaining safe operating parameters.

Re:Can "second life" EV batteries work as grid-scale energy ... by chrisra on Thursday October 23, 2025 @08:54PM (#45689470)
> the real challenge is standardization and integration

In what sense? I'm a newbie, but curious because I'm working on stuff related to https://mesastandards.org/mesa-der-std/.

Re:Can "second life" EV batteries work as grid-scale energy ... by adwn on Friday October 24, 2025 @12:16AM (#45690693)
> New grid storage batteries cost around $200-300/kWh

That doesn't sound right. You can already get high-quality, prismatic LFP cells for ~50 US$/kWh [1] from European distributors at low-volumes, so bulk from China should be even cheaper. And there's no way that balancing and BMS cost an additional 150-250 US$/kWh at scale, not even a tenth of that.

[1] https://www.nkon.nl/novat/eve-lf230-prismatic-230ah-230a-lif...

Re:Can "second life" EV batteries work as grid-scale energy ... by mcbishop on Friday October 24, 2025 @08:44AM (#45694041)
Right, $200-300/kWh is more the range for ~16kWh residential stationary energy storage systems.
Re:Can "second life" EV batteries work as grid-scale energy ... by overfeed on Friday October 24, 2025 @12:17AM (#45690710)
> Having worked extensively with battery systems, I think the grid storage potential of second-life EV batteries is more complex than it appears.

Complex, by t very much doable. Toyota implemented such a system with enough packs to power a Mazda factory [1]

> However, you need to factor in significant integration costs (~$50-75/kWh) to build compatible BMS systems and thermal management.

Shouldn't this be a once-off cost per battery-pack version? Or was this your armortized cost for your deployment capacity. If you've written the BMS for a 2019 Model 3 Panasonic battey pack once, won't you reuse it for all the subsequent battery packs of the same model/SKU?

1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44998010

Re:Can "second life" EV batteries work as grid-scale energy ... by adwn on Friday October 24, 2025 @02:47AM (#45691620)
> Shouldn't this be a once-off cost per battery-pack version?

A BMS isn't just software. It requires a µC, voltage and temperature sensors for cell monitoring, and power electronics for cell balancing. However, those are all comparatively cheap, especially at scale, and the quoted cost of 50–75 US$/kWh looks ridiculously overpriced to me.

Re:Can "second life" EV batteries work as grid-scale energy ... by overfeed on Friday October 24, 2025 @09:46PM (#45700767)
I expect EV batteries to have all those components preinstalled already, and naively thought the grid-integration involves reverse engineering the battery's protocol, and perhaps bypassing/replacing a µC or 3.
Re:Can "second life" EV batteries work as grid-scale energy ... by Xemplolo on Friday October 24, 2025 @06:50AM (#45693249)
How can this be a real issue?

We don't have a lot of car makers and we do not have a huge amount of EV models.

Either you are doing this on small scale, than you can select one or two specific EV models and use these batterie packs or you do it in big scale, than you can also easily adapt the most x batterie packs and only use these across your system.

If you go down to the cell level, its more effort true but then you probably only handel cell types of a handfull of manufacturer again.

Re:Can "second life" EV batteries work as grid-scale energy ... by DanielHB on Friday October 24, 2025 @09:16AM (#45694298)
You can't really mix different types of cells together in the same pack. Even cells with the same manufacturer and chemistry can be problematic to mix if they are at different wear levels (or even from different batches from the same factory).

This is only practical if you reuse the whole pack, or at least the modules. And for that to work well you also need a lot of complex software to keep the packs working well with each other (like balancing power levels between the packs).

BMS software is no joke, it is already hard and complex enough when using brand new battery packs and cells of the same chemistry and manufacturer and wear level. Any kind of mixing massively increases the complexity and safety concerns.

Re:Can "second life" EV batteries work as grid-scale energy ... by Xemplolo on Friday October 24, 2025 @11:14AM (#45695503)
So they already come with a BMS.

Create a MetaBMS. The BMS of the cell pack doesn't care if a car requests energy between 0 and max and a BMS doesn't care either if it gets 0-100 kWh.

My car can easily charge from a household plug up to fast charger. My car consumes very random amounts of energy while i drive.

Re:Can "second life" EV batteries work as grid-scale energy ... by jwr on Friday October 24, 2025 @11:15AM (#45695516)
> the real challenge is standardization and integration. Different manufacturers use vastly different battery management systems (BMS) and cell configurations - a Tesla pack is fundamentally different from a Nissan Leaf pack.

Isn't that exactly what the article is about? Have you actually read the article?