Here’s another: https://suno.com/s/v3LuDD9SjVPohVB7

I listened to both and they both sounded soul-less.

Seemed adequately soulful to me. Not my favorite, but better than I could do. As another bit of anecdata.

Thx

Depends on what you mean by souless. According to the textbook definition, as someone who’s been into music production for more than 20 years in one capacity or another, and that has listened to innumerable songs across every genre imaginable, agree to disgree.

Not to your liking sure, maybe you think it even sucks. But souless nah

I did not feel anything when listening to the song. The purpose of music is to move oneself, particularly emotionally.

As an example to represent the point - this is known to put many on the verge of tears/in a stream of tears: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WxNbZLh0PaA&list=RDWxNbZLh0P...

The beauty of music is that it’s based on preference.

Some songs that move my friends have absolutely no effect on me, and vice versa. That doesn’t mean the song is soulless - it is just that the preferences don’t align.

Lol, you are not someone worth debating with. Stick to your biases and continue producing music that no one else cares about. Cool.

Just dont share it with the rest of us who actually have taste.

Lots of people love making them, almost nobody likes listen to them so you are the audience of the app you use to create it, not a creator.

Given parent’s handle I think you’re on to something.

My parents gave me a wonderful gift: a loophole for my narcissism

And theres nothing wrong with that. The issue is people like Altman thinking creativity et al is just a formulaic mish-mash of what exists and is not as difficult. Like yeah ok mate....

Fully agree on that. You have to pour your creative spirit into it in one way or another.

My favorite AI songs are those that have been created with human intervention and creativity, not just button mashing

As a tool, it could be useful as a starting point (a way to get your creativity going), but the sound is completely wrong.

Early Udio generated songs when run through a stem splitter were horrible to listen to and you could hear how it was just generating the frequencies with none of the texture—like a simulation of the frequencies an instrument would produce.

At the very least they should be re-recorded with real instruments and vocals or using the existing digital tools. Slop is one word; I like to use mush, as that is what it sounds like when you really listen closely.

I think it’s useful in a number of ways.

The sound is amazing if you’re doing it right. I produce music using the old fashioned way, with a DAW, and have done for decades, and there are some songs that I’ve made with AI that I go to again and again because they sound great.

I wrote an article on this: https://narcissus.medium.com/i-could-be-addicted-to-my-own-a...

Basically, what we’re seeing is the personalization of media.

Now create a HN clone where the Aai audience enjoys your content.