News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CIA Secret Kept for 35 Years Is Found in the Smithsonian'... by tptacek on Saturday October 18, 2025 @05:36PM (#45630531)
Do I understand part of the complexity of the situation is that Kryptos is in some sense "crackable" (unlike real cryptography), and these two people sleuthed their way to the answer book without solving it? Which is not quite exactly the same thing as them independently working out a solution; it's more like a nicer and more legal version of breaking into the guy's house and stealing it out of his desk drawer?
Re:CIA Secret Kept for 35 Years Is Found in the Smithsonian'... by sgustard on Saturday October 18, 2025 @07:06PM (#45631009)
Can we even determine if what they found is the key, or just the plaintext? The article mentions they recognized bits of plaintext (Berlin clock) in the archives.
Re:CIA Secret Kept for 35 Years Is Found in the Smithsonian'... by HPsquared on Saturday October 18, 2025 @06:17PM (#45630733)
"What we think intelligence agencies do" vs "what intelligence agencies actually do"
Re:CIA Secret Kept for 35 Years Is Found in the Smithsonian'... by moron4hire on Saturday October 18, 2025 @05:48PM (#45630598)
At the state level, it's a method that is in bounds.
Re:CIA Secret Kept for 35 Years Is Found in the Smithsonian'... by tptacek on Saturday October 18, 2025 @06:21PM (#45630757)
I don't have an opinion! As a cryptography pentester, Kryptos has always kind of set my teeth on edge (Wikipedia had editors covering cryptography topics whose expertise was rooted in Kryptos puzzle-crypto). But one of the smartest people I know is also a Kryptos enthusiast so this is all very complicated for me.
Re:CIA Secret Kept for 35 Years Is Found in the Smithsonian'... by irjustin on Saturday October 18, 2025 @09:13PM (#45631460)
Yes, but all things considered, that's outside the bounds of this cypher - which is why "we all" feel cheated.
Re:CIA Secret Kept for 35 Years Is Found in the Smithsonian'... by codeduck on Sunday October 19, 2025 @04:46AM (#45632851)
Technically what they accomplished is a successful side channel attack.