Funny. There are actually a whole bunch of libertarians of Thiel's ilk whose views have the same flaw but in reverse. They assume that if they can stop the government from "debasing" money and "devaluing" their savings, they can sit on money today safe in the knowledge that it will be worth more tomorrow. Of course, without technological innovation that won't happen either. Worse, if this were possible it'd be far more toxic to technological progress than any "welfare state" could ever be; taxes merely make it slightly less profitable, whereas this libertarian idea is pretty much guaranteed to drive returns on all but a handful of investments into the negative compared to just sitting on the money. With no financial incentive to innovate, why bother?
Re:The End of the Future (2011)
by seanmcdirmid on Sunday September 23, 2012 @08:48PM
(#4562706)
Exactly. What libertarians want sounds very similar to a feudal society where the landed gentry are able to live comfortable lives on their perpetual (across generations) investments while the have nots (and there have to be many of these...) become virtual serfs just to survive.
A dynamic economy where you can't just sit on wealth is necessary to promote technological innovation as well as economic mobility. If you look at history, we didn't really start moving forward very quickly until we got that (around the renaissance time frame).
If a society borrows from the future in times of growth, the additional prosperity will cover the debt payments and nobody really suffers. If society borrows from the future in times of stagnation or decline, however, both the debt payments and the cost of living now come from the same fixed income, so the quality of life suffers. This not only applies to financial debt, but to infrastructure, educational, and other kinds of non-monetary debt.
In other words, Theil's piece is a warning that we need to get our act together. We re-start the technological growth engine, stop borrowing from the future, or tighten our belts and prepare for a general decline in our standard of living. We may not be at the tipping point yet, but it is coming if we don't change course.