News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The End of the Future (2011) by corporalagumbo on Sunday September 23, 2012 @07:17PM (#4562473)
This is just hokum. Collapse of art and literature? Soft totalitarianism of political correctness? The "sordid worlds" of popular entertainment? Thiel sounds likes just another rich guy losing all connection to reality and morphing into a know-it-all railing against popular tastes. What does he know? And all of this "nature red in tooth and claw" shit - "most human beings through the millennia have existed in a naturally brutal, unchanging, and impoverished state" - who is he to spit on thousands of generations of living, breathing people, and say their lives were shit? What gives him that right?

The other thing I find strange is his talk of a still-to-come "energy revolution." Thiel sounds like just another false prophet of growth. I'm pretty sure we already had an energy revolution - fossil fuels. Massive reservoirs of stored energy that we discovered, learnt how to extract, process, and utilise, leading to a bewildering array of techniques and technologies. Does it dissapoint Thiel that the fruits of these achievements have gone to relatively simple things - more homes, cars, appliances, holidays and health care for more people. Does it disappoint him too that population and desire expansion soak up our technological advances? We live in the most resource-intensive society in history - and apparently it's still not enough. We need to grow some more. It hasn't worked before, but next time, it'll be enough, for sure.

So what does Thiel want? Science to break the fundamental rules of physics? Science to break the fundamental principles of living species? Seems like Thiel is pretty uncomfortable with human eistence. He wants that 50s vision - clean, pristine, glowing, perfect, anxiety-free (a vision invented to sell vacuum cleaners to the most anxious generation in history, if I recall correctly.) Thiel is the classic modern: living in the most disease, conflict, death and accident-free society of all time, terrified of the physical realities of human existence, callously dismissive of 99% of all that humans have experienced on this planet, bitterly dismissive of the achievements of modern technology, blithely dismissive of popular tastes, wanting to have his cake (liberal human rights and the free market system) and eat it (techno-transcendence and mass adoption of his political views) too.

My advice to Thiel would be to decide exactly what it is that he wants (more fundamental physics research, better solar/wind/algae, more noble pop culture, authoritarian domination by a cultural elite, space resource extraction, better education, better sci-fi novels), figure out what's at the heart of his chosen problem and (just like a good hacker) go and come up with an innovative solution to transform the problem himself. Either research or advocate or fund or all three. But he should stop trying to preach like this on the failures of our civilization, because he is just talking out of his ass.

Re:The End of the Future (2011) by s_tec on Sunday September 23, 2012 @07:45PM (#4562550)
Many people assume that we can spend money we don't have today because we will just earn more tomorrow. This is especially true on capitol hill, but you can see the assumption pretty much everywhere. Thiel's is basically pointing out that this assumption may no longer be true. Without technological progress, tomorrow won't be better than today.

If a society borrows from the future in times of growth, the additional prosperity will cover the debt payments and nobody really suffers. If society borrows from the future in times of stagnation or decline, however, both the debt payments and the cost of living now come from the same fixed income, so the quality of life suffers. This not only applies to financial debt, but to infrastructure, educational, and other kinds of non-monetary debt.

In other words, Theil's piece is a warning that we need to get our act together. We re-start the technological growth engine, stop borrowing from the future, or tighten our belts and prepare for a general decline in our standard of living. We may not be at the tipping point yet, but it is coming if we don't change course.

Re:The End of the Future (2011) by makomk on Sunday September 23, 2012 @08:27PM (#4562656)
Funny. There are actually a whole bunch of libertarians of Thiel's ilk whose views have the same flaw but in reverse. They assume that if they can stop the government from "debasing" money and "devaluing" their savings, they can sit on money today safe in the knowledge that it will be worth more tomorrow. Of course, without technological innovation that won't happen either. Worse, if this were possible it'd be far more toxic to technological progress than any "welfare state" could ever be; taxes merely make it slightly less profitable, whereas this libertarian idea is pretty much guaranteed to drive returns on all but a handful of investments into the negative compared to just sitting on the money. With no financial incentive to innovate, why bother?
Re:The End of the Future (2011) by seanmcdirmid on Sunday September 23, 2012 @08:48PM (#4562706)
Exactly. What libertarians want sounds very similar to a feudal society where the landed gentry are able to live comfortable lives on their perpetual (across generations) investments while the have nots (and there have to be many of these...) become virtual serfs just to survive.

A dynamic economy where you can't just sit on wealth is necessary to promote technological innovation as well as economic mobility. If you look at history, we didn't really start moving forward very quickly until we got that (around the renaissance time frame).

Re:The End of the Future (2011) by spiffage on Wednesday October 03, 2012 @01:58PM (#4608732)
Most libertarians I know are fully aware that they can't stop the government from debasing money and devaluing savings anytime soon.
Re:The End of the Future (2011) by truethurts on Sunday September 23, 2012 @07:28PM (#4562504)
"go work on it himself"

Amen.

Some of his philanthropic efforts may prove beneficial to science. He could just be a quiet philanthropist. But these sort of PR pieces, even putting aside how annoying they are in terms the total lack of sound thinking^1, are designed to sell people on investing in "Web 2.0" companies and Silicon Valley of which he is conveniently positioned as a beneficiary.

1. Sound thinking is, I thought, what National Review, or at least WFB, Jr., was all about. This kind of contribution is pure rubbish. It's a wonder he didn't start name dropping a handful of "Web 2.0" companies to whet investors' appetites, as Andreeson does when he writes for the NYT.

Re:The End of the Future (2011) by guylhem on Sunday September 23, 2012 @07:41PM (#4562539)
I don't agree on that one. Maybe it's in his interest or objectives, but such a writing sure won't make me invest a dime in web 2.0 companies or any companies based in a country engaged in a process of self destruction.

Why can't you consider the alternative, that he may truely very worried, and try to share his views, his warning?

Altruism is a human trait. The frequency can be debated, but when we see a problem we like to warn our fellows.

Re:The End of the Future (2011) by truethurts on Sunday September 23, 2012 @08:07PM (#4562619)
What if you are a policy maker, or someone poised to influence policy makers, that could affect the prospects for Silicon Valley and "Web 2.0"?

I cannot take him and his arguments about "science" seriously because 1. he is using the concept of scientifc progress, which many of use would agree always worthy of pursuing, under the guise of "Web 2.0" which you might guess is not my idea of science and 2. his background is Stanford Law School, a Wall Street trading desk, a hedge fund and then PayPal and Palantir. He has little credibility on this topic: science.

If he were focussed on preaching the merits of philanthropic donations to scientific causes, and he has some credibility on this, I would not be criticising his writings. But as we all know there is more to his agenda and these PR pieces. They always include references to "Web 2.0" and Silicon Valley. No harm in trying to pump up the market for web startups, as long as you're within the law, but when you start sugar-coating these pitches with talk of "scientific progress", then I take issue.

It's true he may warning of a general problem with a growing disregard for science. But why does he have to connect it to "Web 2.0" and Silicon Valley? Maybe because that is the only things he knows that is remotely reminiscient of science? Or is there some other reason? Because he is a venture capitalist in that sector? What is the purpose of Section III?

How does he know that science is being ignored? Is he working in a lab somewhere and short on funding for his research? No. He's a Silicon Valley venture capitalist investing in "Web 2.0". He would know if Silicon Valley is being ignored or could use a little more attention. Of that I am certain.

Re:The End of the Future (2011) by guylhem on Sunday September 23, 2012 @09:16PM (#4562772)
It's ok to question his background and credentials on science, however the formula he uses - basically substituting science by economical growth is consistent with what I know about Sollow growth model, which tends to no growth unless an external variable called technical progress is introduced.

I am also worried by the growing disregard of science, but IMHO it is less worrysome that the actual slowing down in technical progress.

I wouldn't call web 2.0 startup, social networks and the likes "progress". We are just focusing more about ourselves instead of exploiting our environment more.

We think we are doing things, but we're not actually building new physical stuff - only barely improving.

The drug innovation example is spot on.

Re:The End of the Future (2011) by truethurts on Sunday September 23, 2012 @10:38PM (#4562951)
Agreed. What if someone with Theil's resources "brute forced" some area of therapeutic development, like Gates did with vaccines? I say brute forced because the natural tendency of investment has never tended toward vaccines. It has tended toward small molecules with large target patient populations that can pay high drug prices. But through sheer force of philanthropic will, Gates allowed something to happen that might not have happened otherwise, by virtue of economics (choose whatever theory you like).
Re:The End of the Future (2011) by guylhem on Monday September 24, 2012 @01:53PM (#4565976)
Yes- that's the interesting point : when you get so much money, you can invest it in interests worthy to you, with an overhead equal to what you will tolerate and will normally be less that what a bureaucracy will tolerate - so it's more efficient than a similar sized government projects. The Gates example is perfect.

We, the human race, have capital and more than before. We could be investing it in science. But we don't do it as much as we did previously.

This worries me, because all the evidence seems to point to a cultural explanation. I don't know how to call it - so far the best way I've found to express it is "a reduction in the will to live", a reduction of hope in the future.

The alternative explanation would be that accumulating the capital in fewer persons leads for some reason to a deceleration of investment, a notion I can't find any explanation for, since the richest would have more and more surplus as they venture away from the needs of everyday's life and therefore more and more reasons to invest it in technical progress instead of spending it on the necessities of life.

There is this idea of ostentious consumption and Veblen goods, but it seemed to me that with the decreasing marginal interest (who needs a 12th Ferrari?), investment and therefore progress would be the tendancy.

It's not. So I'm worried. Maybe there is a decreasing marginal interest in the will to live, that impacts investment and progress ? This could be supported by the decreasing birth rates in most countries and they get away from basic survival.

Re:The End of the Future (2011) by spiffage on Wednesday October 03, 2012 @02:13PM (#4608821)
Paypal and Palantir are both good examples of new technologies that Thiel started that _did_ solve important problems that previously had no good solutions.

He's backed plenty of Web 2.0 nonsense that didn't solve important problems (and just backed lots of new companies in general), but Paypal and Palantir are actually counterexamples of that.