News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Upcoming Rust language features for kernel development by a-dub on Thursday October 16, 2025 @09:19AM (#45605008)
> Torvalds seems to disagree with you.

i don't really care for mindless appeals to authority. make your own arguments and defend them or don't bother.

this gpu driver looks pretty cool though. looks like there's much more to the rust compatibility layer in the asahi tree and it is pretty cool that they were able to ship so quickly. i'd be curious how kernel rust compares to user space rust with respect to bloat. (user rust is pretty bad in that regard, imo)

Re:Upcoming Rust language features for kernel development by mekoka on Thursday October 16, 2025 @09:50AM (#45605318)
Mindless appeal to authority? I don't think that's how the fallacy really works. It's pretty much the authority that seems to disagree with your sentiment, that is if we can agree that Torvalds still knows what he's doing. Him not sharing your skepticism is a valid argument. The point being that instead of giving weight to our distant feelings, maybe we could just pause and be more curious as to why someone with much closer involvement would not share them. Why should we care more about the opinions of randos on hn?
Re:Upcoming Rust language features for kernel development by j-krieger on Thursday October 16, 2025 @10:56AM (#45606175)
> i don't really care for mindless appeals to authority. make your own arguments and defend them or don't bother.

You previously appealed to Linux being the largest worlds most important source tree and then you choose to eschew the opinion of that project's lead.

Re:Upcoming Rust language features for kernel development by ynx on Thursday October 16, 2025 @09:43AM (#45605252)
To be fair, assigning the highly competent BDFL of Linux who has listened to a bunch of highly competent maintainers some credibility isn't mindless.

Unless you have a specific falsifiable claim that is being challenged or defended, it's not at all a fallacy to assume expert opinions are implicitly correct. It's just wisdom and good sense, even if it's not useful to the debate you want to have.

Re:Upcoming Rust language features for kernel development by serious8aller on Thursday October 16, 2025 @09:51AM (#45605329)
Not every mention of an authority's opinion needs to be interpreted as an "appeal to authority". In this case I think they're just trying to give you perspective, not use Torvalds opinion as words from god.
Re:Upcoming Rust language features for kernel development by 15155 on Thursday October 16, 2025 @09:30AM (#45605127)
> i don't really care for mindless appeals to authority.

This isn't an appeal to just any authority, but the authority that defines Linux and is its namesake.

[dead]
Re:Upcoming Rust language features for kernel development by EGG_CREAM on Thursday October 16, 2025 @10:12AM (#45605600)
It’s very intellectually lazy of you not to be curious about why the creator and decades long, knowledgeable guardian of Linux has the opposite opinion as you, all because you read the Wikipedia about logical fallacies one time.
Re:Upcoming Rust language features for kernel development by mynameisash on Thursday October 16, 2025 @10:21AM (#45605707)
Also the guy that created "the world's most important piece of software", as you put it. Appealing to the authority on the exact thing you raised concern about is the single most important authority one can cite.
Re:Upcoming Rust language features for kernel development by lesuorac on Thursday October 16, 2025 @10:47AM (#45606032)
Eh?

Surely it's better to cite the authority's reasons as to why they think this way than just to cite the authority itself ...

It's not like there's a lack of times he's talked about rust. Just link his commentary similar to linking ashai linux.

Re:Upcoming Rust language features for kernel development by mekoka on Thursday October 16, 2025 @12:12PM (#45607210)
> Surely it's better to cite the authority's reasons as to why they think this way than just to cite the authority itself

Why? When disagreeing with an authority, you want the audience to pay closer attention to your arguments as you demonstrate why the authority has it wrong. When you're just sharing distant and likely under-informed opinions with no arguments to back them up, it's not up to other people to do homework to show you why you're wrong. Appeal to authority is a legit call to a fallacy only when people give next to no consideration to your arguments, focusing instead on the opposing party's stature.

Re:Upcoming Rust language features for kernel development by Anonbrit on Thursday October 16, 2025 @03:05PM (#45609400)
So rather than pointing to experts who're in the best position to know, you'd prefer bad rephrasing and airchair experts? Do you 'do your own research' too?