And .9999==1 in the hyper-reals
>>If it were, then any operation involving only real numbers >>would behave identically to the real number system. >Why is that a problem? Seems to me that that's desirable.
Consider the expression ".999... - 1" in the real number system. As has been established earlier, this simplifies to 0.
Consider the same expression ".999... - 1" in the hyper-real number system. As all the numbers are real, this expression simplifies just as it would in the real number system. Meaning that ".999... - 1 =0" in the hyper-real system. Adding 1 to both sides ".999... = 1" in the hyper-real system.
One could also argue that because the statement ".999... = 1" is true in the real number system, and the hyper-reals are a superset of the reals. Then ".999... = 1" is true in the hyper-reals.
So you're right, and I was answering a different (although related) question.