News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wireguard FPGA by ohdeardear on Monday October 13, 2025 @04:20AM (#45566048)
I think with a comment like this you have absolutely no clue what is relevant for adoption.

Adoption is about offering something that is 1) correct 2) easy to install 3) has reasonable performance 4) stable.

Wireguard provides all of those. OpenVPN was not meeting criterium 1 even a few years ago and IMO, if it doesn't work after a decade of development, it's _never_ going to work.

Now, let's look at your comment, which is full of techno mumbo jumbo (don't worry, I know everything you talk about), doesn't even mention half of those.

I think an extremely naive, but popular position is that when someone comes out with some new tool that "works on their machine", that they assume that everyone else believes immediately that they are not just as stupid as everyone that came before them. This was even true for Wireguard, since Wireguard was _not_ bug free either. In fact, one could argue that Wireguard is still an amateur project despite it working stable for some of my systems.

The problem with software like Wireguard is that there is no incentive to actually make bug free software. If software always works and has all the required features, nobody will call the person or company associated with it anymore. When was the last time that the author of "grep" was recognized as a great programmer? Never. Now, I am not saying that grep is free of bugs, but I just took a fairly stable program as an example. An economy for software like SaaS has much better incentives in that regard (even though they often also do not reach bug free status). curl is also an excellent example of bug ridden software that an entire industry is using, while it is written by an amateur (that has no incentive whatsoever to produce something that doesn't need to have bugs fixed).

If humanity had somewhat more of a collective intelligence, a million people would come together and just all paid $100 to implement a wireguard replacement (possibly even using the same protocol) to perfection such that no new implementation would ever be needed and that would adapt to any hardware automatically. Instead we prefer to continue to fuck around with inferior shit all day long.

Re:Wireguard FPGA by philipallstar on Monday October 13, 2025 @06:20AM (#45566745)
> When was the last time that the author of "grep" was recognized as a great programmer? Never.

Ken Thompson wrote grep, and he is definitely recognised as such.

Re:Wireguard FPGA by ohdeardear on Monday October 13, 2025 @06:40AM (#45566885)
man -T grep | grep 'Free Soft\|Thom'

  (Cop)108 348 Q(yright 1998-2000, 2002, 2005-2023 Free Softw)-.1 E(are F)
Sure, he wrote _a_ version of grep, and probably the first, but who cares? "The" (sure, you might run some bsd grep) current version of grep certainly doesn't.
Re:Wireguard FPGA by jacquesm on Monday October 13, 2025 @08:52AM (#45567804)
No, he wrote grep. Before he wrote it there was no grep. And yes, he's recognized as a great programmer. With Multics, Unix, B, C, UTF-8 Plan9, Inferno and grep to his name (and probably others that I forgot) he has more than deserved that.

Future grep versions, including the FSF one, were all re-implementations.

Your statement in the GP is nonsensical.

Re:Wireguard FPGA by ohdeardear on Monday October 13, 2025 @10:01AM (#45568446)
I do not agree he was a great programmer. All of his programs are trivial from a computer science perspective.

In fact, you can quite easily check this by trying to let an LLM generate a program like grep. It can do that. Now, there also exist programs for which LLMs can't generate code, because it's too complex.

Re:Wireguard FPGA by jacquesm on Monday October 13, 2025 @10:17AM (#45568586)
You have absolutely no idea what you are talking about. And that's fine but it is kind of adding a lot of noise and zero signal.
Re:Wireguard FPGA by ohdeardear on Monday October 13, 2025 @10:41AM (#45568821)
I have a research degree in computer science from one of the best universities on the planet, I have been using Unix systems for over 25 years, have been the go to person for billion dollar companies (you know the person they beg for help), and I don't know what I am talking about?

I have even used Plan9 and the silly editor.

I probably have forgotten more than you (or Thompson) has ever known.

Thompson is an amateur, because all of his programs are of "trust me, bro"-quality. Call me when Ken (and all the n00bs from that era) grows up and implements grep in Rocq.

Re:Wireguard FPGA by jacquesm on Monday October 13, 2025 @11:20AM (#45569318)
Yes, so you say, and I'm the pope on alternate Sundays. Meanwhile, I highly doubt you are qualified to polish Thompson's shoes, all I see is an AC novelty account making dumb claims with hindsight. Anyway, enough with you, off to the ignore list.
Re:Wireguard FPGA by YouAreWRONGtoo on Tuesday October 14, 2025 @10:16PM (#45587376)
Not sure what kind of idiotic website this is that people more qualifed than the average idiot here are "flagged". Thompson is completely irrelevant to computer science. Any idiot can write a program, but only some people can make an actual contribution. Knuth actually did something useful in comparison. Also, Knuth was able to articulate.

You are the nobody here.

Re:Wireguard FPGA by philipallstar on Monday October 13, 2025 @11:32AM (#45569487)
I'm just saying this is incorrect:

> When was the last time that the author of "grep" was recognized as a great programmer? Never.

He is recognised as that. Your opinion on him is nothing to do with anything.

Re:Wireguard FPGA by pastage on Monday October 13, 2025 @04:09PM (#45572801)
Do you have examples of stable systems?
Re:Wireguard FPGA by ohdeardear on Thursday October 16, 2025 @05:52AM (#45603419)
CompCert would be a good example, but everything I have done professionally is also stable; with exclusively people like me, bug tracking systems would not need to exist.

I also have made some software that is proven (meaning from a small 500 line proof kernel) to be correct relative to a trivial implementation (and yes, full correctness is difficult to achieve).