>> We have a universe of discourse that has a bunch of atomic things. A "set" is then a collection of things
This is where I get stuck. In set theory, they define numbers (and addition) starting from a set and element-of operator. I cannot imagine a bunch of atomic things without imagining numbers/counting first. (PS: "collection" would be another word for a set, so does not help to define it.) So it seems to me that unless set and element-of are left undefined (as others here have suggested), natural numbers are more fundamental than sets.
>> 0,9999... = 1
What I am getting is that the "limit" is implicit in the statement above even though often unstated. The ellipsis is what signifies the limit there, being otherwise not mathematically defined.
>> Call that collection A
I get the precise definition of sack B. I am missing it for sac A. I understand what happens on a given cube, and that cubes in sac A are numbered 1 though infinity. Is there anything to say about the numbers written on two different cubes in sac A?
Basically what you are saying is that sac A cannot have all possible combinations like sac B is defined to have. I am not sure why that is. I see that you just added a comment on another related comment from me. I'll read that first.
>> We have a universe of discourse that has a bunch
>> of atomic things. A "set" is then a collection of things
> In set theory, they define numbers (and addition)
> starting from a set and element-of operator. I cannot
> imagine a bunch of atomic things without imagining
> numbers/counting first.
The point is that you can start with nothing, and define the set that has nothing in it. That's {}. Now we have one thing. We can define a set containing that, so we have { {} }. Now we have two things, and we can definea set containing both of them, and so on.This is what happens when people want to construct a model of numbers and arithmetic using set theory as the basis. It proves that we can useset theory as the foundation. It doesn't mean it's a sensible thing to do in real life- it's a lot like programming in machine code.
> So it seems to me that unless set and element-of are left
> undefined (as others here have suggested), natural numbers
> are more fundamental than sets.
What are numbers? What is your model for numbers? What is "723"? >> 0,9999... = 1
> What I am getting is that the "limit" is implicit in the
> statement above even though often unstated. The
> ellipsis is what signifies the limit there, being otherwise
> not mathematically defined.
So what is your question? You seem to be saying that when you write down "0.99999..." that is intended to represent the limit of the sequence 0.9, 0.99, 0.999, ... Define what you mean by limit. Once you make a careful definition of "limit" wou find that the limit of the above sequence is 1. >> Call that collection A
> I get the precise definition of sack B. I am missing it for sack A.
Sack A has a cube with the number 1 written on it. And it has a cube with the number 2 written on it. And it has a cube with the number 3 written on it. And it has a cube with the number 4 written on it. And it has a cube with the number 5 written on it. And so on. > I understand what happens on a given cube,
I assume you mean a cube in sack B. > ... and that cubes in sack A are numbered 1 though infinity.
You can't say that with precision, because it is infinity you are struggling with. What you can say is that for every number n there is a cube with n on it, and that every cube has exactly one number written on it.This level of detail matters.
> Is there anything to say about the numbers written on
> two different cubes in sack A?
Yes - they're different. > Basically what you are saying is that sac A cannot have
> all possible combinations like sack B is defined to have.
No. I'm saying I have two collections of objects. I have very carefully defined what these objects are. And I'm saying that you cannot pair them off, one-to-one, without having things from sack B left over. > I am not sure why that is.
I haven't proved it yet, so I haven't explained why this is so. I have merely claimed it is true to see where your understanding fails so far.This may be nailing it -- struggling with infinity.
When you say "every number n there is a cube with n on it", what does "every" mean. Does every number include infinity? Or should not not consider infinity to be a number? If the latter, this is probably where I went wrong.
> When you say "every number n there is a cube with n on it",
> what does "every" mean.
To be more precise, every finite number. > Does every number include infinity?
No, in these sorts of discussions infinity is never considered to be a number. You need explicitly to be discussing transfinite arithmetic, and we're not. > Or should not not consider infinity to be a number?
> If the latter, this is probably where I went wrong.
Absolutely you should not be thinking of infinity as a number.This helps a lot. I get it finally. :-) Thanks!
So given a point (x,y,z) in 3D space, the new values of x, y, and z are obtained by equations like a * x + b * y + c * z. If you then chase through how to combine two of these transformations, one after the other, the definitions of matrix multiplication drop out.
This, by the way, also explains why you can't always divide by a matrix. Sometimes the transformation collapses the space into a lower dimensional space, and that can't be undone.
For unit vectors u and v, the dot product tells you how much of u points in the direction of v. Then we want it to be true that doubling the vector length doubles the size of the product. Then the result you ask about - the magnitude of dot product in 3D is a.b.cos(theta) - automatically follows.With the cross product, that can be defined as the area of a parallelogram that has the vectors as the side. Again, thinking about that interpretation shows how we get the answer you ask about.
Set theory is often regarded as axiomatic, and so you can go back to the axiomatic definitions. We have a universe of discourse that has a bunch of atomic things. A "set" is then a collection of things, and then each set becomes a new thing in our universe. Thus sets can contain other sets.So a set is defined by what things are in it, so the "belongs-to" concept is fundamental to how the set in question is specified.
People trip up on this in part because they think somehow that something is moving, that 0.999... "approaches" something. But no, when we write "0.999..." we have a representation of a point on the real line. Deciding what it is that you are defining requires that you be clear and detailed about what you think 0.999... means.So what does it mean? We drop back to saying that it's the limit of the sequence 0.9, 0.99, 0.999, 0.9999, ... so we need to ask what real number can possibly be that limit? Let's call the limit L, and ask what it might be.
Well, clearly:
... and so on.Now, for every number X that's less than 1, there'll be something in that sequence that will be bigger than X. That means that the limit can't be less than 1. But equally, none of those numbers is bigger than 1, so the limit can't be bigger than 1.
In fact, the smallest upper bound of { 0.9, 0.99, 0.999, 0.9999, ... } is 1.
And then, why should it not be 1? We have different representations of points elsewhere. 2/3 is also 4/6 and 6/9, and sqrt(8) is the same as 2 * sqrt(2). These are simply different ways of specifying the same place on the real line. Likewise, writing 0.9999... is just a different representation of the point more often written as 1.
You said:
You tell me what you mean by 0,9999... and then I'll answer your question in more detail. Well, there are two different types of infinities based on set theory, but you're probably asking about cardinal infinities, the infinity of counting stuff - "How many things are in this set."So here, I have a sack with a collection of cubes, and they're numbered from 1 onwards. Call that collection A.
Now let's take a cube and divide one face into two sections. Flip a coin, and write the result in one of the sections. in the other section, divide into two, flip a coin, write the result in one section, and then lather, rinse, repeat. We can fit infinitely many coin flips onto the cube in this way. In sack B put a cube with every possible result of this process.
I claim that the cubes from sack A and sack B cannot be paired off with nothing left over. I won't prove that here, I'm now out of time.
So, ask questions.