News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What are imaginary numbers? by alok-g on Friday September 21, 2012 @04:53PM (#4555724)
>> You can't say that with precision, because it is infinity you are struggling with. What you can say is that for every number n there is a cube with n on it, and that every cube has exactly one number written on it.

This may be nailing it -- struggling with infinity.

When you say "every number n there is a cube with n on it", what does "every" mean. Does every number include infinity? Or should not not consider infinity to be a number? If the latter, this is probably where I went wrong.

Re:What are imaginary numbers? by ColinWright on Friday September 21, 2012 @05:09PM (#4555812)

  > When you say "every number n there is a cube with n on it",
  > what does "every" mean.
To be more precise, every finite number.

  > Does every number include infinity?
No, in these sorts of discussions infinity is never considered to be a number. You need explicitly to be discussing transfinite arithmetic, and we're not.

  > Or should not not consider infinity to be a number?
  > If the latter, this is probably where I went wrong.
Absolutely you should not be thinking of infinity as a number.