Re:Vibe Engineering
by flakiness on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @07:33PM
(#45510293)
"Vibe coding" sounds too good. Catchy, ridiculous and still cool. It'd be hard to beat. It's a genius move from Andrej Karpathy.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Different strokes I guess. I've always thought it sounded pretty stupid (right up there with asshat and awesomesauce). Conjures up an image of the Big Lebowski writing code while listening to a cheech & chong album.
Yes, that exactly. If you have to read the code or the manual, you’re not vibe coding. I think vibe coding is super good for the industry and people in general.
I feel like “memetic” is probably the best descriptor, you either love it or hate it but either emotion is a good way for something to stick in your brain.
I am on the stupid side, personally.
Re:Vibe Engineering
by CuriouslyC on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @09:11PM
(#45510928)
Except that we're not going to be "coding" very soon. We're going to be firing off jobs that get tracked in VCS, gated through CI, then reviewed by a panel of agents with different specialties. At the end you'll have a few select sections of code that these agents flagged for human review, and thousands of lines of stuff that you don't need to worry about.
Then it turns out that your CI gates are green because your tests are all subtly broken, the code you've been reviewing doesn't matter and the code you haven't been reviewing is what's broken in production. You learn from that and rebuild the universe, but now you're compute-limited from rebuilding your agents to deal with the underlying issue in your tooling and you have to dig yourself out of a hole you dug with a large derrick using nothing but a shovel.
Re:Vibe Engineering
by CuriouslyC on Wednesday October 08, 2025 @07:00AM
(#45514690)
That's absolutely one possible outcome, just like when manually coding you have a team that doesn't know what they're doing and doesn't build anything close to what the customer wanted. YOLO'ing development has never worked, there's skill in everything.
Re:Vibe Engineering
by vibefeelsgood on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @09:35PM
(#45511092)
This guy selling AI snake oil btw. In case it wasn't obvious.
Re:Vibe Engineering
by CuriouslyC on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @09:45PM
(#45511151)
Why the hostility? We can have a civil discussion without relying on throwaway accounts.
Re:Vibe Engineering
by vibeinmybooty on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @10:44PM
(#45511497)
Long-time lurker and I think you're full of it too!
Re:Vibe Engineering
by CuriouslyC on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @10:57PM
(#45511573)
This isn't X, please maintain community standards.
Re:Vibe Engineering
by iammrpayments on Wednesday October 08, 2025 @09:41AM
(#45516086)
You can offer Chatgpt 7 for free, I’ll never use VCS. If it ever get that powerful I’ll instead tell to recreate it without the bloat and battery drainage.