It is the new world kids and we all better break out our reinforced tin foil hats.
Scary stuff.
http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2012/09/aaron-swartz-felony...
Some extracts:
Like last year’s original grand jury indictment on four felony counts, (.pdf) the superseding indictment (.pdf) unveiled Thursday accuses Swartz of evading MIT’s attempts to kick his laptop off the network while downloading millions of documents from JSTOR, a not-for-profit company that provides searchable, digitized copies of academic journals that are normally inaccessible to the public.
In essence, many of the charges stem from Swartz allegedly breaching the terms of service agreement for those using the research service.
The case tests the reach of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, which was passed in 1984 to enhance the government’s ability to prosecute hackers who accessed computers to steal information or to disrupt or destroy computer functionality.
The government, however, has interpreted the anti-hacking provisions to include activities such as violating a website’s terms of service or a company’s computer usage policy
Also, the part you quoted ends with:
> "The government, however, has interpreted the anti-hacking provisions to include activities such as violating a website’s terms of service or a company’s computer usage policy, a position a federal appeals court in April said means “millions of unsuspecting individuals would find that they are engaging in criminal conduct.” The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, in limiting reach of the CFAA, said that violations of employee contract agreements and websites’ terms of service were better left to civil lawsuits."
Also of interest:
> The rulings by the 9th Circuit cover the West, and not Massachusetts, meaning they are not binding in Swartz’ prosecution. The Obama administration has declined to appeal the ruling to the Supreme Court.
Tweetie actually did a great job of delivering relevant ads in a way that wasn't very obnoxious at all. Then Twitter bought the client, stripped out the ads, and started delivering really lame and irrelevant "promoted tweets"
The amount of cognitive dissonance is amazing. They need to ban 3rd party clients to protect monetization, yet they don't monetize their clients in a meaningful way. They want to be a platform, yet they do everything possible to make that effort fail and piss off potential partners.
All I see from them are expensive campaigns linking traditional media to whatever the twitter platform is supposed to be. I can't see how a business model that boils down to giving teenagers a way to communicate with Justin Bieber's assistant creates any value.
Also betting on their API seems crazy now. Big companies or startups that spend other people's money might still be able to do it, but for a bootstrapper it seems like a recipe for disaster.
The amount of data they generate is humongous and can be very valuable. Data scientists can go through that data can do lot of pattern matching generate interesting insights. From how your product is doing in market or even complex predictions. That sort of stuff twitter wants developer community to build not yet another twitter client.
If you want "access to the data", you can get a firehose subscription from gnip.com or datasift.com I once built an elaborate options pricer, only to find that my "access to the data" - which was basically a scraper from finance.google.com, was cut off. So I switched to finance.yahoo.com and soon enough they cut me off too! So I asked my professor and did what he told me - pay the subscription to IV ( http://www.ivolatility.com/data/historical_data.html ) and voila, the socket was instantly open and I could suck in as much data as I wanted.
http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/twitter_to_sell_50_of_a...
The $360k price tag is not "implied", it's the actual price for access to 50% of twitter's messages (see the link I posted). 100% access can only be negotiated with Twitter itself. To be fair, from the information I could find, the cheapest plan from gnip is $500/month[1], datasift is $3000/month[2], both quickly go up. That means you can't just whip up a prototype in the weekend for some new idea anymore. This pricing probably filters out 99% of the things that could be built on it, limiting them to projects with investor backing and ready business models (which twitter itself still doesn't have).
[1] http://web.appstorm.net/how-to/social-media-how-to/gnip-the-...
If you take away third party API capabilities for those RSS feeds in an effort to push people towards making "apps", you're going to lose developers who were in it for the functionality, not the community.
He made it abundantly clear that Twitter doesn't want its API to be used for alternative twitter clients. IFTTT does not necessarily create alternative twitter consumption client but it can be used to accomplish that.
On a side note (and it may not be popular with HN community); so far we have seen API used (majority of times) for alternative twitter consumption clients. May be with these API changes, we might see more innovation using Twitter as a "platform"? Rather than people trying to create alternative clients.