In proprietary/closed source it depends on ability to spend the money these tools would end up costing.
As there is more and more vibe coded apps there will be more security bugs because app owners just don’t know better or don’t care to fix them .
This happened when rise of Wordpress and other cmses and their plugin ecosystem or languages like early PHP or for that matter even C opened up software development to wider communities.
On average we will see more issues not less.
That being said, most modern exploits are already auto-generated though brute-force, as nothing more complex is required.
>Does anyone disagree?
CVE agents already pose a serious threat vector in and of itself.
1. Models can't currently be made inherently trustworthy, and the people claiming otherwise are selling something.
"Sleeper Agents in Large Language Models - Computerphile"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wL22URoMZjo
2. LLMs can negatively impact logical function in human users. However, people feel 20% more productive, and that makes their contributed work dangerous.
3. People are already bad at reconciling their instincts and rational evaluation. Adding additional logical impairments is not wise:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Pc3IuVNuO0
4. Auto merging vulnerabilities into opensource is already a concern, as it falls into the ambiguous "Malicious sabotage" or "Incompetent noob" classifications. How do we know someone or some models intent? We can't, and thus the code base could turn into an incoherent mess for human readers.
Mitigating risk:
i. Offline agents should only have read-access to advise on identified problem patterns.
ii. Code should never be cut-and-pasted, but rather evaluated for its meaning.
iii. Assume a system is already compromised, and consider how to handle the situation. In this line of reasoning, the policy choices should become clear.
Best of luck, =3
I somewhat share the feeling that this is where it's going, but not sure if fixing will be easier. In "meatbag" red vs. blue teams, reds have it easier as they only have to make it once, blue has to always be right.
I do imagine something adversarial being the new standard, though. We'll have red vs blue agents that constantly work on owning the other side.
Does anyone disagree?
This is purely my intuition, but I'm interested in how others are thinking about it.
All this with the mega caveat of this assuming very widespread adoption of these defenses, which we know won't be true and auto-hacking may be rampant for a while.