News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin Thieves Yet to Spend Stolen Hoard by eropple on Wednesday September 19, 2012 @11:31AM (#4543999)
Your post strikes me as naive. All that laundering does is tag more addresses as "hot". You still have a graph of where the bitcoins have gone.

Bitcoin is done with computers. It's no more "annoying" to trace one hundred transactions than it is to trace one.

Re:Bitcoin Thieves Yet to Spend Stolen Hoard by feral on Wednesday September 19, 2012 @12:28PM (#4544238)
>Your post strikes me as naive. All that laundering does is tag more addresses as "hot". You still have a graph of where the bitcoins have gone.

Lets say you have an address with 1000 bitcoins in it.

A thief steals a lot of bitcoins, and maliciously, unknown to you, sends you 10 stolen bitcoins.

You now have an account/address with 1010 bitcoins in it. The system you have just proposed tags your address as hot.

What happens next?

[This is not a hypothetical scenario: in the 'allinvain' alleged theft, we saw several organisations and individuals receive stolen bitcoins from quite soon after the theft; probably as unsolicited donations.]

Re:Bitcoin Thieves Yet to Spend Stolen Hoard by eropple on Wednesday September 19, 2012 @03:19PM (#4545068)
You now have an account/address with 1010 bitcoins in it. The system you have just proposed tags your address as hot. What happens next?

Then, as with every criminal investigation, you follow up that lead. Not all Bitcoin addresses will be resolveable to a person in an area where you have LEO authority, but I'm fairly confident that eventually it'll happen and you start tracking back up the chain.

I didn't say the solution was entirely technical--I've said more than once that nerds who default to "computers can solve every problem" are wrong. It does still involve old-fashioned detective work. And you're not going to solve every case. But Bitcoin gives you a lot of clues.

Re:Bitcoin Thieves Yet to Spend Stolen Hoard by Dylan16807 on Wednesday September 19, 2012 @01:47PM (#4544604)
Send the 10 back. There, you're not longer tainted.
Re:Bitcoin Thieves Yet to Spend Stolen Hoard by elliottcarlson on Wednesday September 19, 2012 @01:57PM (#4544667)
Once it is added to your wallet you can't send it back, you just have a quantity in there without any differentiation on which bitcoin is which. Sending 10 back would in essence aide in laundering the bitcoins.
Re:Bitcoin Thieves Yet to Spend Stolen Hoard by Dylan16807 on Wednesday September 19, 2012 @01:59PM (#4544676)
If you send 10 to the same address you have sent it back. That does not aid in laundering at all.
Re:Bitcoin Thieves Yet to Spend Stolen Hoard by elliottcarlson on Wednesday September 19, 2012 @11:53AM (#4544085)
What if one of your physical paper currencies in your wallet right now was involved in a robbery at some point? Should that serial number no longer be valid and cause you to lose that money when you attempt to spend it in the store? If currency is successfully laundered it frequently will end up in someone elses wallet - the same would happen with bitcoins, with the main difference being that it could be tracked back to the originating offense. Maybe an exchange will want to keep an eye out for that - but what makes you think a laundering site or gambling site will care? I give you $100, and you give me back $95 from your wallet and since I can use a different wallet to receive the funds it isn't tied together. In the end someone will end up with those hot bitcoins and fractions there-of, but they might be completely innocent - so should they not be able to use those funds? Should every person care about the source of their money? If you could track your paper currency back, would you reject any transactions that were at some point involved with some illicit behavior? I'm not talking about the technical feasibility, but really if people are bothered enough to care.