Wearing a seatbelt does not prevent death in a car accident. There are many people who wear seatbelts who still perish in car accidents.
While you can find a vocal minority who claim cholesterol is not related to heart disease, the best evidence we have is that it is. A lot of the doctors pushing cholesterol denialism are into quacks, such as Uffe Ravnskov who pivoted from denying a link between LDL and CVD into preaching Vitamin C to treat COVID when that hit the news.
However, it's not the only actor in determining heart attack risk.
LDL is used as a predictor because it is easy to measure not because LDL itself causes heart disease. Lowering LDL doesn't actually do anything on its own, because it is just a proxy metric for the underlying problem.
It's more cranky to shutdown discussions by misrepresenting someone's position as "cholesterol denialism". What does that even mean in this context? Finding better predictors is denialism. Great now we just need a ministry of truth.
Is this some sort of weird philosophical statement? Because, of course, it's completely nonsensical, and completely at odds with all data on this file.
Lowering LDL reduces CVD incident rates, with no other interventions. People with genetically low LDL also have lower CVD incident rates. This is extraordinarily well proven.
So it sure seems -- you know, 100% of medical science -- that lowering LDL does "something".
The human body is a complex machine, however, and CVD is multifactorial, and for CVD to develop the current thinking is that you need inflammation and high cholesterol over decades. Inflammation can be caused by things like high blood pressure and the like. But everyone has inflammation to some degree as a facet of living, and the easiest component of that to treat (not just measure) is LDL.
And yes, there is an industry of cholesterol denialists, among whom there are just loads and loads of chiropractors. These clowns have built armies of poorly informed disciples that run to HN to tell us that cholesterol doesn't matter and lowering LDL doesn't do anything.
I get my CRP measured every year. I have zero inflammation and I am in my late 50s. So not everyone has inflammation.
You’re saying a lot of nonsensical stuff in your comment like high blood pressure causes inflammation , which tells me you are not serious in this discussion. Because that makes absolutely no sense.
It's like saying a flying bullet can't do anything on its own. It is a meaningless statement.
>As I pointed out in another post over 75% of people who have heart attacks have normal LDL.
The actual study authors were advocating for lower LDL guidelines, particularly among the elderly.
A heart attack is the destination, not the journey. What someone's LDL was at admission for a heart attack says literally nothing about their state for the decades before. In actual studies tracking cholesterol, even over a five year period lowering LDL has a potent beneficial effect.
>You’re saying a lot of nonsensical stuff in your comment like high blood pressure causes inflammation , which tells me you are not serious in this discussion
Hypertension can cause endothelial inflammation, leading to blood vessel damage and promoting the release of inflammatory mediators. This is extremely well documented, and it's why getting hypertension under control medically is considered extremely important in the CVD battle. Inflammation and hypertension often are found hand in hand, and there is uncertainty over the cause and the effect, but strangely controlling hypertension alone dramatically reduces inflammation. Weird, right?
>I have zero inflammation
Sorry, but LOL. Not only is that a singular and very narrow test, inflammation is literally just a facet of living. As is oxidization. There isn't a single human alive with "zero inflammation", nor is there anyone that has magically non-odidizing LDL.
No one knowledgeable here is saying that inflammation isn't worth paying attention to, but people acting like because inflammation is also important that LDL does nothing just aren't living in reality.
Your comment about blood pressure actually reveals more about your knowledge here than the person you're replying to.
FDG-PET is a signal we can use to detect tissue inflammation, and we know that higher blood pressure is highly correlated with increased FDG-PET in arterial walls:
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6994784/
High blood pressure is also feed-forward loop with Angiotensin, which increases inflammation:
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3377325/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4192119/
Blood pressure results in shear stress to your arteries. This results in several things that amplify Angiotensin II and NF-kB activity, including expoosing adhesion molecules which then results in foam cell activation and cytokine signaling, etc.
It is quite well established that high blood pressure will contribute to increased inflammation.
We know that low LDL does not prevent CVD. Therefore we know that you do not need high cholesterol over decades.
https://www.lipidjournal.com/article/S1933-2874%2825%2900317...
That people can still experience a heat attack even with low LDL does not change that fact. We have very large studies showing the efficacy of lowering LDL.
Literally one of the most proven truths in medical science is that LDL levels has an almost directly relationship with CVD risk over the long term. Someone with low cholesterol can of course still have CVD, but their odds are much better than someone with high cholesterol. And of course the damage from cholesterol is additive, so the earlier you control LDL, the more of a benefit.
>A new national study has shown that nearly 75 percent of patients hospitalized for a heart attack had cholesterol levels that would indicate they were not at high risk for a cardiovascular event, based on current national cholesterol guidelines.
The damage from high cholesterol happens over decades. Yet the people who actually have heart attacks are often older.
So yes, if gramps spent his life with high cholesterol but now he barely eats and is sedentary, he might have low cholesterol now but that says literally nothing to what you're claiming it does.
Which is it? Does lowering help or not? You've come to the conclusion that it doesn't seem to matter.
The current guidance from the AHA and NLA is that lower is better for as long as possible.
What did I "shout"? What are you even going off about? Don't project your angry fanaticism on others.
Further, your literacy is not my problem. Nothing in my comment was contradictory or confusing to anyone but you.
https://www.uclahealth.org/news/release/most-heart-attack-pa...
And lower cholesterol is not without its own risks. You need cholesterol to make hormones and things like CoQ10, which are important for our health. So what’s better? Lowering oxidative stress and inflammation or lowering cholesterol?
I haven’t seen any clear evidence that low blood cholesterol has actual risks, just hypothesizing. Is there any?
PCSK9 inhibitors when coupled with statin therapy have gotten people to ~10 LDL without negative impact in clinical trials. The body is good at producing cholesterol where it needs it - it doesn't pass the blood brain barrier, yet the brain is full of it. It produces it's own, the same as quite a lot of other tissue
For hormones, de novo synthesis of cholesterol is a thing when it comes to steroidgenesis, as well as recycling and re-uptake. PCSK9 inhibitor studies specifically looked at this because of this concern, and found cortisol/aldosterone/testosterone/estrogen/etc. were not impacted by having very lower levels of LDL-C.
The issue with statins and CoQ10 isn't cholesterol - it's the mevalonate pathway. They block a reductase in the pathway and this results in lower serum CoQ10 levels. Data around if this is of any clinical relevance is a mixed bag, but this is easily supplementable if needed, and should not be a reason to not take life saving medication. PCSK9 inhibitors make large dents in LDL but do not impact CoQ10 levels at all because they do not impact the mevalonate pathway.
https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/ATV.0000000000000164 https://www.acc.org/Latest-in-Cardiology/Clinical-Trials/201... https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36779348/
As for which is better... lower both. Why wouldn't you want to lower all the causal factors you can? Statins even do this!
But lowering your LDL does not prevent heart disease. There are many many people with normal LDL who have heart attacks.
In fact, it is the norm. And I can’t imagine how many people are being told. They have no heart disease risk just because their LDL is normal. It’s a crime and it needs to be stopped.
https://www.uclahealth.org/news/release/most-heart-attack-pa...
A new national study has shown that nearly 75 percent of patients hospitalized for a heart attack had cholesterol levels that would indicate they were not at high risk for a cardiovascular event, based on current national cholesterol guidelines.