News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Privacy Badger is a free browser extension made by EFF to... by labcomputer on Monday September 29, 2025 @02:34AM (#45410901)
There is no flaw. If you go to any retailer where sales can be tied to accounts, and you run a few SQL queries on their sales history database, you can generate a table of counts of transaction_n and transaction_n+1.

You will find that the most probable (the mode of the distribution) thing to buy in transaction n+1 is either a substitute for, a complement of, or identical to transaction n.

Re:Privacy Badger is a free browser extension made by EFF to... by 4ggr0 on Monday September 29, 2025 @02:43AM (#45410953)
isn't there a difference between buying a gallon of milk every week because that's part of your standard household equipment versus an item you buy once every couple of years?

i think no one would disagree that there are things they buy very frequently, almost on a schedule. (then again, with these items people are probably very accustomed to buying the same brand of milk every week, so ads don't seem reasonable here as well).

Re:Privacy Badger is a free browser extension made by EFF to... by likium on Monday September 29, 2025 @03:09AM (#45411072)
The incentive to show post-purchase ads is: 1. people didn't like nth purchase so they're looking for a substitute. 2. reinforce purchase behaviors / reduce buyer's remorse.

Ads work at human psychology; they're not fully logical. Though I'm sure there's inefficiency in marketing but if post-purchase ads weren't ROI positive, I doubt the market would be paying for them.

Re:Privacy Badger is a free browser extension made by EFF to... by labcomputer on Monday September 29, 2025 @03:45AM (#45411261)
Like I said before, this phenomenon is broadly applicable across almost everything. I’m hedging with “almost” because I haven’t personally seen data for every category of product, but I believe that it applies universally.

In a sibling comment I replied to someone with an objection that it doesn’t apply to cars… with a personal anecdote that it does, at least sometimes, apply to even cars.

Even governments do it: Having previous purchased a nuclear submarine is highly predictive of future nuclear submarine purchases. Likewise, you probably have not purchased a nuclear submarine, which makes me think you probably won’t buy one this year. ;-)