Re:Warp Drive May Be More Feasible Than Thought, Scientists Say
by Dylan16807 on Tuesday September 18, 2012 @06:40PM
(#4540913)
Well, either one can send a single message. It's the reply from a different frame that causes trouble. In fact you can have unlimited FTL messages sent in a single reference frame. It's only when you combine multiple FTL reference frames that things get wonky.
Re:Warp Drive May Be More Feasible Than Thought, Scientists Say
by lmm on Wednesday September 19, 2012 @04:56AM
(#4542751)
But if B can't send an FTL-message to A because he's going to receive an FTL-message from A in what to him is the future, that's your causality violation right there.
Re:Warp Drive May Be More Feasible Than Thought, Scientists Say
by Dylan16807 on Wednesday September 19, 2012 @01:15PM
(#4544461)
Right, I should be more precise with the scenario. A cancelled-message is still a transfer of information. To avoid problems you have to set up the scenario such that only one ship would send a message no matter what. But it can be either ship, and you don't have to know which ahead of time.
Of course the cheap answer is that it violates SR (and common sense, given the complete symmetry of the situation) for A to be able to send an insta-message to B but B not able to send an insta-message to A.