I will benefit from medical AI. There will soon come a point where I will pay a premium for my medical care to be reviewed by an AI, not the other way around.
Paying for AI diagnosis on your own will only be helpful if you can shoulder the costs of treatment on your own.
Which is often a very, very low bar.
What do you call a doctor who was last in his class in medical school? A doctor.
They made an absolute statement claiming that AI will "at least" let them dodge false diagnosis, that implies a diagnostic false positive rate of ~0%. Otherwise how can you possibly be so confident that you "dodged" anything? You still need a second opinion (or third).
If a doctor diagnosed you with cancer and AI said that you're healthy, would you conclude that the diagnosis was false and skip treatment? It's easy to make frivolous statements like these when your life isn't on the line.
> What do you call a doctor who was last in his class in medical school? A doctor.
How original, they must've passed medical school, certification, and years of specialization by pure luck.
Do you ask to see every doctor's report card before deciding to go with the AI or do you just assume they're all idiots?
This may be acceptable to you as an individual, but it’s not to me.
> All that is needed is an external actor to take the risk and show a step change improvement
Who's going to benefit? Doctors might prioritize the security of their livelihood over access to care. Capital will certainly prioritize the bottom line over life and death[0].
The cynical take is that for the time being, doctors will hold back progress, until capital finds a way to pay them off. Then capital will control AI and control diagnosis, letting them decide who is sick and what kind of care they need.
The optimistic take is that doctors maintain control but embrace AI and use it to increase the standard of care, but like you point out, the pace of that might be generational instead of keeping pace with technological progress.
[0] https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/death-rates-rose-hospit...