The US has been directly or indirectly involved in all conflict in the middle east in the past few decades, and the instability in the region is due to the US's failed foreign policy.
Maybe the US should stop pretending they know what they're doing. The US can't keep domestic terrorism at bay, why are they trying in a foreign setting?
And yeah, the US should get out of the Middle East - we need to stop pretending is that sharia-law is compatible with western liberal democracies*.
* This IMO is the socio-cultural reason for the Middle East's instability following the US’s interventions - and why similar interventions had more success elsewhere.
Also, speaking frankly, there's an implications that people don't want Iran to have nuclear weapons because it's a Muslim country. This is false. It would be far palatable for Saudi Arabia or the UAE to develop nuclear arms because even though neither country is 'Christian' or 'democratic', they are at least allies.
Ironically, this statement could apply to Pakistan, which has had nuclear weapons since 1998 and yet has never used them. How strange! According to Western leadership, all Muslims are supposed to be barbarian religious fanatics who want a worldwide nuclear holocaust!
Iran having a nuclear weapon would make the Middle East and the world a much safer place - if Ukraine had not disposed of their nuclear weapons in the 1990s, there would be no war happening right now! Possession of nuclear weapons is the only way for a country to guarantee its own sovereignty, which is something America and its coalition do not want for Iran - they want a weak puppet like the Shah who will let Exxonmobil come in and take all their oil revenue for themselves.
> According to Western leadership, all Muslims are supposed to be barbarian religious fanatics who want a worldwide nuclear holocaust!
Thanks for telling me what I and every other westerner thinks!
As you have clearly stated, we can therefore easily conclude that all muslim countries (and by extension their people) are equivalent and all must therefore share the explicit ideological goal (enshrined in their constitution) to "fulfil the ideological mission of jihad" and hopes for "the downfall of all other [non-islamic] governments". [1]
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_Iran#Preamble
Just to be clear: all muslim countries (and people) are equivalent = obvious sarcasm. To believe that I'd have to be about as braindead as someone who believes that all citizens of western countries share the same values, goals, and ideologies as each other (and their governments).
To be clear: Pakistan is a military dictatorship with Sharia Law and Sharia courts in effect for decades, and Islam as their state religion (something that isn't even true of Iran, a country of great religious diversity that's not reflected in Western propaganda). They are as much a theocracy as Saudi Arabia, yet their nuclear weapons aren't an issue because they play patty-cake with Western interests and have no oil reserves for Exxonmobil to salivate over.
> Is there something uniquely dangerous about Muslims in possession of nuclear weapons that you'd like to tell the class?
Nope, just that religious fanatics (of all flavours) who believe they have the moral duty to kill, conquer, and subserve - and who proudly state their goals - have caused a disproportionate amount of unnecessary suffering throughout history.
> something that isn't even true of Iran
Do I really need to give you their constitution again?
> great religious diversity
Diversity doesn't mean the ruling class aren't islamic fundamentalists. The suffering of these diverse peoples under Khamenei's rule should be enough to show you how much water your statement holds. It also demonstrates the exact willingness to persecute others which makes me think twice about supporting their nuclear armament.
https://iranhumanrights.org/2025/04/imprisonment-of-christia...
> They are as much a theocracy as Saudi Arabia
The country who's flag is the Shahada? Ok.
> Saudi Arabia, yet their nuclear weapons aren't an issue
The Saudis don't (officially) have nukes. Do you know something I don't?
An openly athiestic person who isn't born Jewish might have a harder time converting, but even that is possible with certain rabbis. In any case conversion is a long process and a rare edge case.
You are pig-headedly refusing to accept that you're wrong. People who are "Jews" purely because of their ancestry, i.e. people who have parents or grandparents who are ethnically Jewish, can migrate to Israel under the law of return regardless of what religion they practice (including none).
If you don't believe this, google it.
Ashkenazis are ethnically European. For example, Benjamin Mileikowsky (aka Netanyahu) is Polish as was David Grün (aka Ben-Gurion) and Golda Mabovitch (aka Meir) was Ukrainian.
There are also hybrid or quasi-theocratic states. Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, Mauritania, Sudan, Brunei. Not that it's a state but the parts of Yemen controlled by the Houthis also qualify.
Israel is not a theocracy. Israel is akin to the U.K., Greece, Italy, Denmark.
Israel was created for a variety of reasons. If you have to summarize it into a sentence, Israel was created to provide Jewish self-determination and refuge, particularly after centuries of persecution.
People of Ashkenazi ancestry are ethnically Jewish. Jews are from Judea. Ashkenazi Jews have Middle Eastern origins, but have some European admixture due to centuries of intermixing in the diaspora.
Israel is pure theocracy. No religion gets free citizenship to the U.K. for instance. Israel is much like Vatican City, only it’s a colony illegally placed on Palestinian land.
Personal attacks will get you banned here, so please don't post like that.
Also, please don't perpetuate religious/nationalistic flamewars on HN. It's not what this site is for, and destroys what it is for. I realize other commenters are feeding it, but the important thing is to stop feeding it regardless of what other commenters are doing.
Jews are an ethnic/cultural group that traditionally follow a religion called Judaism, but certainly not all of them today. Your point is sort of like saying Italian-ness is Catholicism. No, that is part of it, but it is broader, and the fact that Italy is a state for Italians doesn't mean it's a theocracy.
"Jews can become Israeli citizens" -- yes, this is true regardless of whether they believe in or practice the religion.
Sounds like a great idea, with the best of intentions! What could possibly go wrong?
> Don't you think it'd be better to normalise relationship with them so that they become friendly?
There's no normalising of relations with a country who's constitution enshrines that '[Iran's military is] not only for guarding the country but for "fulfilling the ideological mission of jihad in God's path"' [2] and that hopes that "this century will witness the establishment of a universal holy government and the downfall of all others" [2] (hint: that's us).
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_Iran#Sharia
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_Iran#Preamble