News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by throw10920 on Friday September 19, 2025 @01:28PM (#45304231)
And here we have a double demonstration of both stupid and malicious.

> If economy grows by roughly even percentage each year same should be true about government budgets

Stupid. For the purposes of this discussion, the government exists to provide services. The cost of those services, in general, decreases with economic productivity.

> Otherwise you just leave money on the table for billionaires to scoop up and sit on.

Both stupid and malicious. Mind-bogglingly stupid, because that profit isn't just captured by the wealthy, but by all economic classes. Malicious, because you'd rather sabotage the economy than let some people take excess profits based on their wealth alone.

Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by scotty79 on Friday September 19, 2025 @03:25PM (#45305393)
Government doesn't provide services. Government owns the land and the population simply by the fact of having army that can exert control. It provides monetary system you measure worth of everything in. You provide the service of producing economic value.

You can't with straight face claim that profit is not captured by billionaires but by everybody if economy grows 3% but billionaires wealth doubles in the same period. They not only capture the entire new profit of economy growth but also extract wealth from all other parties including government.

Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by throw10920 on Friday September 19, 2025 @05:16PM (#45306727)
> Government doesn't provide services.

Yet again, factually incorrect. The government provides many services - social security, food stamps, military protection, utilities, research funding, pharmaceutical oversight, and many, many, many other things. You're just wrong.

> You provide the service of producing economic value.

Also wrong. That is not a "service" provided to the government - it's just something that people do, and they have the right to keep those rewards.

> You can't with straight face claim that profit is not captured by billionaires but by everybody if economy grows 3% but billionaires wealth doubles in the same period

Those things are unrelated.

Yet again - a mixture between stupidity and malice, driven by base greed, envy, and resentment of what others have that you don't.

Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by scotty79 on Friday September 19, 2025 @07:14PM (#45307920)
> Yet again, factually incorrect. The government provides many services - social security, food stamps, military protection, utilities, research funding, pharmaceutical oversight, and many, many, many other things. You're just wrong.

Sorry for using a short-hand. Government doesn't provide services for your benefit. The only goal of providing those benefits is to best enable you to produce economic value that government and the rich can capture.

> That is not a "service" provided to the government - it's just something that people do, and they have the right to keep those rewards.

The only right of the physical world is might.

Why do you think anyone just lets people do what people "just" do? They let people do it because powerful benefit.

It's the same reasoning why a warlord lets peasants grow crops and raise animals and chases away neighboring warlord. Because then there's something he can take for himself. Political systems change but the basic mechanic never did. Democracy and capitalism are just a way better tool for exploitation than feudalism could ever be. Efficient. Stable. Didn't you ever notice that with development of new, more enlightened systems of power tax burden doesn't shrink but grows instead?

> Those things are unrelated.

We have one monetary system. It's all related.

> Yet again - a mixture between stupidity and malice, driven by base greed, envy, and resentment of what others have that you don't.

I have plenty, way more than I ever deserved. I'm at risk of being directly negatively financially affected by policies I advocate for. Drop the armchair moral psychoanalysis because you miss every time, on all counts.

Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by throw10920 on Friday September 19, 2025 @07:40PM (#45308121)
> The only right of the physical world is might.

Ok, you're just evil. No need to justify anything to an evil person.

Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by scotty79 on Saturday September 20, 2025 @10:39AM (#45313810)
Wrong again. Being a realist doesn't make someone evil, but hell is paved with good intentions.
Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by throw10920 on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @09:43PM (#45355273)
> Being a realist

Factually incorrect. "The only right of the physical world is might." is not a realist statement, because being a realist is when you look at the factual truth of the world - it's a cynical worldview, which is non-truthful and therefore non-realist, by definition.

It's always entertaining to watch evil people try to justify their actions and (lack of) morality.

Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by scotty79 on Thursday September 25, 2025 @08:08AM (#45371864)
> Factually incorrect. "The only right of the physical world is might." is not a realist statement,

It's absolutely correct. Familiarize yourself with concept of "monopoly on violence". That's the physical source of any other arrangements including rights.

You handwave about morality a lot and think it's a substitute for a robust argument. It's tiresome and boring.

Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by throw10920 on Thursday September 25, 2025 @09:31AM (#45372434)
> Familiarize yourself with concept of "monopoly on violence". That's the physical source of any other arrangements including rights.

Now you shifted the goalposts from "The only right of the physical world is might." - so you can't even be consistent with your own positions.

> You handwave about some vague morality a lot

It should be pretty obvious that an evil person or someone with a repellent ideology's claims on morality are invalid, and how that's relevant to assertions about the function of the government, for instance.

The "might is right" ideology means that you believe that every tyrant, like Mao and Hitler and Stalin and Mussolini, was justified in their genocides and war crimes, because they were powerful enough to effect them, and therefore morally right by definition. That is, as any sane person would tell you, a perverse and evil morality.

I don't really need to go on further, because I know that I can't convince an evil and immoral person that they're evil. My only goal is to convince future HN readers that that idea is evil, and that therefore your assertions are invalid, and I think I've succeeded at that, given the downvotes on your other comments, and the general HN understanding that "might is right" is an abhorrent ideology.

So, my goal is fulfilled. Feel free to continue digging yourself a hole for future readers, if you wish :)

Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by scotty79 on Friday September 26, 2025 @03:13AM (#45383679)
> Now you shifted the goalposts from "The only right of the physical world is might." - so you can't even be consistent with your own positions.

I was just trying to get through your confusion and reach thinking part of your brain. I repeatedly failed.

> It should be pretty obvious that an evil person or someone with a repellent ideology's claims on morality are invalid

You are so deep in your confused morality that you didn't even notice I made no moral claims except for "Being a realist doesn't make someone evil".

"The only right of the physical world is might." is not a moral claim same way "Acceleration due to gravity is indistinguishable from any other acceleration" is not. It's a factual claim. The fact that it's more vague and general and uses the word "right" doesn't turn it into a moral claim.

> The "might is right" ideology means that you believe that every tyrant, like Mao and Hitler and Stalin and Mussolini, was justified in their genocides and war crimes, because they were powerful enough to effect them, and therefore morally right by definition.

Again you are so confused that you can't tell apart narrative from a factual state. Saying that Mao had was justified because he had might is a moral claim (a wrong one) and is of no interest to me.

What I'm saying is that the only reason Mao could have awarded any rights to himself, his enforcers or his victims was because he had might. In this aspect he doesn't differ from any post WWII president of US. If you don't have might you are not the one who can create and award rights. Not in the real world. It has nothing to do with morality. Morality comes later to evaluate how benevolently the entity with might used its right to create further rights for themselves and others.

> My only goal is to convince future HN readers that that idea is evil, and that therefore your assertions are invalid, and I think I've succeeded at that, given the downvotes on your other comments [...]

Sorry to interrupt your victory lap, but not a single of my comments, on the path between the first one I made and this one, has karma below 1 at this moment. Even in theory, all you did was basically use ad hominem "you are evil" to declare my points invalid.

I had no goal in this thread other than being understood by you and I failed. If that makes you a winner, I don't really care.

> Feel free to continue digging yourself a hole for future readers, if you wish

I think it's plain to see which side tried to make arguments and which started and ended by flinging accusations of immorality, greed, envy and resentment and pretty much avoided the point altogether.