Re:GPT-5-Codex
by aitchnyu on Tuesday September 16, 2025 @01:03AM
(#45258190)
Did anybody switch away from Aider for a compelling alternative? What was the feature?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:GPT-5-Codex
by dsrtslnd23 on Tuesday September 16, 2025 @01:50AM
(#45258488)
I still like aider but multi-step agentic flows are very useful so I mostly use codex and claude nowadays. If I want to do very specific edits I use aider.
Re:GPT-5-Codex
by faangguyindia on Tuesday September 16, 2025 @01:58AM
(#45258524)
I don't find multiple agents helpful at all for coding, here you can see i am running a modded aider and single shot most features, https://www.reddit.com/r/ChatGPTCoding/comments/1nh7bu1/3_ph...
I also use claude or codex but i do not find them much useful for what i do.
Where does regular Aider fall short?
Re:GPT-5-Codex
by faangguyindia on Tuesday September 16, 2025 @06:59AM
(#45260601)
bruh, i posted a video for you to see where it falls short. If you are an aider user you can tell based on video what it can or cannot do.
I was a #1 aider stan for months, but ultimately switched to Claude Code.
For me it was (1) lack of MCP (2) excessive hand-holding required (3) availability of the Max plan meant I wouldn't have to monitor cost.
Claude Code's skill curve felt slightly longer than aider's, and had a higher ceiling.
I think if I were more cost-sensitive, I would give Aider another whirl, or Gemini CLI (based on what I've heard, I haven't used it yet).