Sure, antivirus has never been 'complete' protection but, speaking from a lot of firsthand experience, some of it used to be pretty darn good compared to lately. Now even 10-15% protection from AV sounds like a stretch. Hence, in terms of the soho PC segment I've dealt with day to day, I'd say The Antivirus Era Is Over And It Has Been For Awhile.
I'm not going to dispute that AV vendors have become complacent recently, but 10-15% is on the low side. Most families of widespread malware are detected by most solutions within a few months (yes, that slowly.) It's probably around 80-85%, but, at the same time, 90%+ of the really dangerous (and especially targeted) malware is more often than not in the remaining 15-20%.
Ultimately, what this article and your comment insinuate is that you can uninstall antivirus and be "just as safe." That is not true (except in rare cases where the AV software itself is vulnerable and provides a way to escalate privileges.) I'm all for getting rid of shoddy blacklisting, but we need a replacement, such as innovations in OS security models (a la Chromium OS.)
> "Ultimately, what this article and your comment insinuate is that you can uninstall antivirus and be "just as safe." That is not true..."
Agreed, but at the same time it's hard to recommend paid AV solutions that don't really work for what people perceive as 'a virus'. What I've come to do is:
* de-emphasize the importance of AV to my clients; tell them it may help but don't count on it
* recommend running the free AV of their choice
* emphasize the importance of updates
* emphasize Chrome + 'Click to run' as the primary protection approach: http://www.pcstrikeforce.com/taking-chrome-security-next-lev...
> "I'm all for getting rid of shoddy blacklisting, but we need a replacement, such as innovations in OS security models (a la Chromium OS.)"
right on
So should malware authors all figure out what Flame (or other more advanced malware) is doing, and how to do it themselves, eventually current day AV _will_ be useless.
No?
It's probably more helpful to think of these classes of malware as being "obscure" or "wide-spread" than "smart" or "stupid" (I apologize for my previous analogy.) "Advanced persistent threats" don't really exist on a higher plane than common, boring malware (although these have included some impressive payloads), they're just tailored toward something specific in most cases.
I think it's a logical impossibility that all malware should suddenly become as obscure as these were. The payload can certainly be shuffled around, but nothing stops AV from recognizing and stopping whatever mechanism decrypts and runs them. That doesn't, in any way, make AV a panacea--but that's the way it's always been.
I guess we'll have to wait and see!
Now, this doesn't mean that antivirus is useless, or that the antivirus era is over--by the logic of this post, the antivirus era was over the minute it began. What it means is that antivirus is a tool that helps protect you against "stupid"/mass malware, but not a tool that gives you any kind of "complete" or "100%" protection (although every AV vendor will certainly try to convince you that their products do), and this is particularly true--today as it was 10 years ago--when it comes to malware that isn't widely distributed, or, put more fashionably, "targeted malware" and "advanced persistent threats" (hence: malware which belongs to a "family" that hasn't been caught, analyzed, and added to a binary/behavioral signature/heuristic database of some kind beforehand.)