News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by aurareturn on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @04:29PM (#45203171)
Kind of bad news for human kind if we find out the life also started in Mars. One Great Filter down.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:00PM (#45203639)
I think the filter was eukaryogenesis [1]. (Which in turn depends on the endosymbiosis of mitochondria.)

Put simply, I expect the universe is littered with single-celled life. I think multicellular life, on the other hand, is rare.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eukaryogenesis

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by Qem on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:53PM (#45204462)
> Which in turn depends on the endosymbiosis of mitochondria.

Which in turn depends on existing enough atmospheric oxygen for mitochondria to make sense in first place. I believe the filter is atmospheric oxygen. If Earth had more iron in the crust, perhaps the cyanobacteria would never finish oxidizing all of it, and we would be doomed to only host microscopic life forever. Macroscopic life requires high-energy metabolism molecular oxygen allows.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by lawlessone on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @08:48PM (#45206287)
Could that be down to planet size?

We have lots of iron , but most of it sank to the core during the "iron catastrophe" . And Mars is red because of theres so much iron.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by andrewflnr on Thursday September 11, 2025 @11:49AM (#45213004)
Eukaryogenesis != Multicellularity. There are tons of unicellular eukaryotes. Also, multicellularity has evolved a bunch of times, at least in eukaryotes, so I doubt it's that rare.

If your thesis is specifically that oxygen-powered metabolism fueling multicellularity is rare... that wasn't clear. And I'll still say that endosymbiosis being the shortest path to scaling oxygen metabolism is probably Earth happenstance (with a reminder that cellular endosymbiosis is also common). But some critter had to originally evolve oxygen metabolism before being turned into mitochondria. What if that had evolved in a cell prepared to directly take advantage of it?

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by JumpCrisscross on Thursday September 11, 2025 @04:43PM (#45215938)
> There are tons of unicellular eukaryotes

But no multicellular prokaryotes. You're right that eukaryotes can be single celled. But my hypothesis is that multicellular life is rare because eukaryotes are rare.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by andrewflnr on Thursday September 11, 2025 @06:24PM (#45216726)
The second half of my comment still applies then. I think Earth-style eukaryogenesis is probably just one way to achieve the energy budget and complexity needed for complex multicellularity... bearing in mind, of course, that colonial bacteria that collaborate for survival definitely exist, spirulina for instance, stromatolites, and all the gross things that form biofilms.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by estimator7292 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:16PM (#45203861)
It's pretty unlikely that life emerged independently on two planets in adjoining orbits.

The much more reasonable explanation is that life emerged on one planet and transferred over. Earth and Mars aren't particularly close, but they're close enough for material to transfer between them, particularly early in the solar system when there were far more asteroid impacts kicking rocks and dust out into space.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by pantalaimon on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:34PM (#45204150)
Why would you say it's unlikely? For all we know simple life could emerge very easily if conditions are right and it's the step to complex life that's the hard one.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by tim333 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @12:29PM (#45213465)
It would be very interesting to get a sample of life on Mars if there is some to see if they have the same chemistry or not.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by awesome_dude on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:12PM (#45206463)
My hunch was completely the opposite

Two planets in the "habitable zone" both receiving "ingredients" from the same stream of comets/meteors/cosmic dust, both with what we believe to be environments conducive to life (liquid water, surface temperatures/atmospheric pressures that aren't like Venus..:)

In fact, I'm more surprised that life didn't start independently on both planets at roughly the same time (it could turn out that life did indeed start at the same time on both planets too, just it didn't "take hold" or "last as long" on Mars)

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by Supermancho on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @10:41PM (#45207103)
Alternately, an impact to one world caused an upheaval that transferred the blocks to another.

I do think the "galactic seeding" theory is more likely.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by freakynit on Thursday September 11, 2025 @03:53AM (#45209011)
The transfer of life from one planet to another("panspermia") seems plausible in principle. However, the immense energy released during asteroid impacts makes survival unlikely in many cases, as the very organisms hitching a ride may be destroyed in the process. That said, evidence suggests that microbes shielded deep within rocks could potentially endure the violent stages of ejection, space travel, and planetary re-entry.

Beyond panspermia, I lean toward another perspective:

Life exists because it serves as a natural means of accelerating "entropy" production. In an otherwise relatively stable system, life provides a shortcut, catalyzing processes that dissipate energy gradients far more efficiently than non-living chemistry alone.

At the microbial level, metabolism drives the dissipation of redox gradients, pushing chemical systems toward lower free-energy states. While cells locally maintain order and complexity, their activity increases the overall entropy of their environment. In this sense, life is not a violation of thermodynamic laws but a direct expression of them.

If this is true, life may be extremely common in the universe, arising naturally wherever the right conditions exist to favor energy dissipation.

What may be rare, however, is complex life. Complexity requires not only a lucky balance of stability and change, but also the ability to endure, or even be forced forward, by catastrophic events such as mass extinctions, without wiping out all of it. Earth's active techntonic plates provided yet another means to enable evolution.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by GuB-42 on Friday September 12, 2025 @11:00PM (#45228957)
> If this is true, life may be extremely common in the universe

It should be observable. Planets with life as entropy generators should absorb light from their star and reemit it as thermal radiation. More so than a lifeless planet of the same type. It is the case for Earth.

I have seen this idea somewhere, though I don't know how serious it is.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by freakynit on Monday September 15, 2025 @01:01AM (#45246263)
You’re right. If life really does boost entropy production, then in principle it should leave a footprint in how planets handle energy. The tricky part however, is telling apart what's due to biology versus what's just weather, geology, or atmosphere.

Of course, to notice something like this from such vast distances, the energy transformations would have to be happening on a very large scale. So, it's possible life is out there, but just not at a scale on those planets that our current instruments could pick up.

By any chances, do you have any good reading references for this: "I have seen this idea somewhere" .. I am genuinely curious to read more on this.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by JoeAltmaier on Friday September 12, 2025 @03:46PM (#45225943)
Earth is strange - a billion years of water and chemistry on every grain of sand on every beach. Every combination of temperature, sunlight, wetting and drying as tides slosh things around in every phase.

It's like a bioreactor for creating life. One could argue, it's highly unlikely given all those experiments and all that time, that life would avoid being created.

And Mars? It has a moon too, two of them. Tides as well, lunar and solar. Pretty much the same deal.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by 5tk18 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @04:49PM (#45203467)
Would you mind elaborating on this? I don’t understand the point. Maybe naively, I would think that evidence of life on mars would increase the probability of life on exoplanets.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by nwah1 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @04:56PM (#45203569)
If the solution to the Fermi Paradox is that there's a great filter that prevents many advanced civilizations from sticking around long enough to be observable, then we hope that the filter is behind us rather than in front of us.

The more common that life is, the more likely it is in front of us.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Filter

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by Qem on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:00PM (#45204572)
If the origin is not independent, that doesn't necessarily change the position of the filter.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by Razengan on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:12PM (#45203811)
The Fermi "Paradox" is based on so many naive self-referencing assumptions it's ridiculous that it's considered so seriously so often.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by mr_mitm on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:16PM (#45203862)
I don't even understand why people call it a paradox. A paradox has no obvious solution. This one has many obvious solutions, the most obvious one that the premise is faulty: perhaps life is not common at all.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by benbayard on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:35PM (#45204155)
That's part of the Great Filter answer to the Fermi paradox. Though, I agree, it's not really a paradox. If the great filter is true, the first filter is life forming at all. We hope that the filter is behind us and that's why intelligent life in the universe seems rare, rather than ahead of us. If life is common, but intelligent life is uncommon, that's concerning because it makes it more likely that the filter is ahead of us. Meaning, something like, once an organism has control over the whole planet there's something that prevents them from going to multiple planets.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by credit_guy on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:20PM (#45206521)
There is another premise that is faulty: that the answer to "where's everybody" is that "since we see nobody, there is nobody". But for all we know the planets around Alpha Centauri may be teaming with life, and there would be no way for us to detect that. If only 1% of the solar systems in our galaxy host intelligent life, then the number of intelligent life forms would be truly mind-boggling, yet we wouldn't be able to detect a whisper of their presence. For the simple reason that space is also mind-blowingly vast, and all signals decay with the square root of the distance.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by estimator7292 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:31PM (#45204109)
I mean, we don't have any other perspective to look through. There is no other point of reference to draw from. We try to compensate by assuming that our system, planet, and species aren't particularly special and are probably about average in terms of supporting life.

We can't know or even begin to guess at what an alien civilization may do or think or how they evolved. Best we can do is assume it's probably somewhat similar to our experience. At least it's based on something factual. Anything else is really just wild speculation.

We pretty much have to assume aliens will be sort of similar to us because we haven't met any. Our experience is the only one we've got, so it's the most reasonable baseline we have. We know that aliens will probably be wildly different from us, but it's so unknowable as to be moot. Do we base our assumptions on Heinlein's writing? Asimov? Douglas Adams? Anything other than what we know from our own experience is just fanciful fiction.

But also you're not supposed to take as read the Fermi paradox, Kardashev scale, or any other ways of thinking about aliens. It's implied that they won't be anything like us. You're not supposed to take it as a literal statement that alien species will be hairless bipeds with a warlike society who think and look like us. You're supposed to follow the assumptions that statistically, we're probably not special as a species and probably any aliens we meet will have evolved along similar lines and probably will be relatable to us. Implicitly we understand that this likely is not true. We just don't know and there aren't really any options that are more reasonable or reliable than basing assumptions on the one and only planet we know that has intelligent life.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by feoren on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:52PM (#45205209)
This is too pessimistic. We can absolutely "begin to guess" at what an alien civilization might look like or how they might have evolved. Reasonable possibilities are very heavily constrained by information theory, the laws of thermodynamics, the very finite number of elements that make up the universe, chemistry, particle physics, etc. You can appeal to fantasy by dreaming up multi-dimensional energy beings, and of course such things have some tiny but nonzero probability of existing. But you can do the same thing regarding what we might find if we look at some random pond water under a microscope. Maybe we'll find crazy silicon-based life forms, or some phylum we never knew existed, or a microscopic Tyrannosaurus Rex! Maybe. But it's perfectly reasonable to ascribe an extremely small probability to such things based on everything we already know about the universe, and it's reasonable for the same reason to ascribe a very small probability to the existence multi-dimensional energy beings that would completely defy our understanding. For any given alien life form we might find, there's a very high probability (I give it at least 90%) that it would be based on chemical pathways that would make us go "oh, neat", but not go "THIS CHANGES EVERYTHING!"
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by Razengan on Thursday September 11, 2025 @04:25PM (#45215767)
I'm a complete layman, but I wonder if chemistry on Earth (and rest of our solar system) is also influenced somewhat by the particular properties of our star, its and our magnetospheres etc. and the gas clouds our planets coalesced from.

As in, different stars may encourage slightly different chemical reactions and interactions on their planets.

Like, for example, could it be possible for a planet to form with a naturally highly magnetized mineral in its crust? Would it affect the rest of the chemistry on the planet? Would it cause the ground to interact with its star's magnetic envelope, like our atmosphere within the Auroras does?

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by AIPedant on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:15PM (#45203855)
Putin and Xi fantasizing about immortality via 3D-printed organs quite starkly illustrated that many adults do not understand the difference between science and science fiction.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by kjkjadksj on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:00PM (#45203630)
The elephant in the room here is that advanced intelligent life as we understand it is some inevitable step in evolution. A random walk of mutations on top of mutations lead us to this and only because the environmental context favored adaptions toward intelligence in the case of our species at the time. This is probably why most sci fi is not written by evolutionary biologists.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by sillyfluke on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:26PM (#45204026)
Yes, but as time goes to infinity there will eventually be an environment context and mutation path that will result in something that has a similar level of intelligence.

In fact, this makes the preoccupation with humans escaping a Great Filter all the more childish. Even on a single planet the species that will evolve from humans by the time Earth is swallowed by the sun will have less in common with humans than we do now with single cell organisms. Internalize that fact a little bit. Once you realize it is absurd to talk about the human species being preserved as is to the end of time, you will understand the silliness of this obsession. Cause after that point you might as well believe in a deity.

If it makes you feel warm and fuzzy inside, it suffices to hope that only single cell organisms survive the Great Filter, since given enough time it might lead to something that is as intelligent or more intelligent and kind than humans.

Embrace the silliness. The answer to "Why should we humans spread to other planets?" need only be "Why the fuck not?"

That is, unless you want to fund your rocket company. In which case you have to make people believe in a deity.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by soiltype on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:15PM (#45203853)
Er... No that's not a meaningful critique. There's no framework that doesn't assume it's a random process. The point is to find out how likely each step is to occur, randomly.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by kjkjadksj on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @11:21PM (#45207373)
Even the Kardashev scale is based on the assumption that unfettered economic activity as humans conceived of it in the mid 20th century would be a common enough phenomenon to classify, including shoehorning in our wildest science fiction ideas. Only the most unscrupulous of our species probably want to maximize production of widgets beyond the limits of this planet to the point where a Dyson sphere must be built. Would a Buddhist monk have any interest in that for example, or are their metrics of “productivity” more metaphysical perhaps? Or someone considering preserving a system and not exceeding what it is capable of sustainably offering? How about a blue whale, do they have an increasing energy demand per capita as well?
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by soiltype on Monday September 15, 2025 @11:44AM (#45251091)
How does this respond to my previous comment? In trying to respond to this, I completely forgot what the context was.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by withinboredom on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @04:56PM (#45203565)
We’re working off the assumption that life is rare in the universe (and thus a great filter). That is why the stars aren’t covered in life.

If this isn’t true, and life is actually common throughout the galaxy ... then the great filter might still be ahead of us — such as not surviving technological adolescence. Meaning we’re not special, we just haven’t died off yet.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:04PM (#45203696)
> assumption that life is rare in the universe

Great filters start with the observation that we have detected no signs of alien technological civilization. The assumption is this means they’re rare.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by withinboredom on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:14PM (#45203840)
That doesn’t mean much. If it is actually common and the great filter is passing technological adolescence, then at least one civilisation would need to be around at least a hundred thousand years ago to be detected by us. Then, they would need to survive the great filter. We’ve only been broadcasting for 80 years or so, and any modern technology is probably indistinguishable from noise...

In other words, even if the average technological civilisation lasts 1000 years, the odds of those civilisations overlapping are nearly zero if the great filter is ahead of us. Unless civilisations manage to last much, much longer than 1,000 years (millions of years), the chance that two blips overlap in time and space closely enough to detect each other is basically negligible.

That is why the “life on Mars” point feels ominous:

- If abiogenesis is easy, the filter isn’t there.

- If the filter is later (like surviving technological adolescence), then most civilisations blink out quickly.

Which means overlapping, detectable civilisations would be vanishingly rare, explaining the silence, but also suggesting our future may be short.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by pantalaimon on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:41PM (#45204272)
Life is pretty robust, civilization is not. I'd say it's pretty intuitive that the filter is ahead of us - civilizations collapsing has happened multiple times already in the last few millennia. Earth becoming sterile has never happened as far as we know.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by withinboredom on Thursday September 11, 2025 @02:24AM (#45208449)
Yes, but a civilization collapsing doesn’t kill off an entire species nor (usually) wipe out knowledge completely. Thus it wouldn’t be a great filter. However, perhaps it is pretty common to create a grey goo, or nuke yourself, or whatever. That would be a life ending event.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by pantalaimon on Thursday September 11, 2025 @07:09AM (#45210169)
It's still about what we are able to observe. If there is a bronze age civilization in the vicinity of betelgeuse, how would we tell? You'd need a civilization advanced enough to do radio communication - and that has a lot of fragile interdependencies.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by harshalizee on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:10PM (#45203778)
Or just really hard to detect with existing technology. Combine that with the vastness of the universe, it's not a unreasonable take.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by estimator7292 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:45PM (#45204337)
Not really. The great filter idea is only one of many proposed solutions to the Fermi paradox. The Dark Forest hypothesis would have the universe filled with life, which is all in deep hiding from an intergalactic civilization hellbent on destroying all other life.

Personally I think the great filter is a dumb idea for precisely the reason you posit. The universe is (probably) infinite, which means there's an infinite probability that we aren't special or alone. Maybe we're the first; the universe is (relatively) pretty young from what we can tell. I doubt that too, but I think it's one of the most plausible explanations.

But really what it comes down to is that in an infinite universe, the probability of anything happening exaxtlt once is infinitely small. It is infinitely more probable that there is or will be other life out there.

Really, out of uncountable trillions of planets in trillions of galaxies across tens of billions of years, how could it be that exactly one planet can produce life? I think it's egotistical navel-gazing in the extreme to assume we're alone.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by withinboredom on Thursday September 11, 2025 @02:18AM (#45208418)
If you take the beginning of the cosmos to be 1 second ago, the point where other galaxies will be unobservable is in just a few seconds (at T+7–8). We’ve only had civilization for about 700-800 nanoseconds. You could fit hundreds or even thousands of advanced civilizations in there and they’d never know the other existed.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by dgfitz on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:11PM (#45203800)
Oh, we thought that?

We aren’t special. We will die off.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by xg15 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @04:50PM (#45203487)
I guess the question is: If there was life on mars, what happened to it?
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by maxbond on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @04:56PM (#45203566)
Presumably the planet became much less geologically active, causing Mars to lose it's magnetic field and thus it's atmosphere, and that caused a mass extinction. If there was life on the surface in the past, I imagine it still exists deep underground or in lava tubes or such.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by rrmm on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @04:56PM (#45203574)
I think the building blocks of life are so common in the universe it might be a case of "easy come, easy go". It wouldn't be surprising if simple life happened anywhere it was given half a chance at all, but one would equally expect that it would die out just as quickly when conditions changed (which they certainly did on Mars).

And of course nothing is ruling out life in the nooks and crannies of Mars.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by estimator7292 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:52PM (#45204431)
We have proven that Mars used to have a magnetic field like Earth that protected it from solar radiation. We also know that it does not presently have a magnetic field. At some point in the distant past, Mars's core cooled and solidified, which removes the magnetic field.

The big problem is that the solar wind strips away the atmosphere and water, but that's (probably) not what killed all Martian life. As the magnetic field decreases, more and more harmful radiation reaches the surface. The planet was probably sterilized by radiation long before the atmosphere was lost and the oceans evaporated.

We're pretty sure this is what happened. We've been studying Mars's geology for a long time and we can see evidence for most of this process.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by Qem on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:18PM (#45204781)
Likely, when Mars went bad, their planet B was Earth. Nowadays they call themselves Earthlings (AKA us).
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by empath75 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @04:56PM (#45203584)
That actually isn't a hard question to answer. Mars lacks an active core or a magnetosphere, so the atmosphere blew away, freezing the surface and removing almost all of the liquid water.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by tim333 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @12:30PM (#45213478)
It may still be there doing it's thing, mostly underground. The surface of Mars is currently very dry for any life we know but there seems to be water underground https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-54337779
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by jordanb on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:23PM (#45203973)
The inner planets have exchanged a lot of material it's possible they also exchanged life. In fact I believe some theories for how life formed rely on it.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by withinboredom on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @04:48PM (#45203458)
For all we know, life started on Mars, not here. Hence the "sudden explosion" of life.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by elevaet on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @04:58PM (#45203607)
They keep pushing back the date of the LUCA - I think it's meant to be 4.2 billion years ago now, a time when Mars was more nurturing than it is now, maybe moreso than Earth at the time? I hope we find out it started on Mars and jumped to Earth, how cool would that be?
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by vlovich123 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @04:55PM (#45203537)
I prefer the theory that life is the natural evolution of physical chemical processes given certain conditions. That explains why we think that we’re likely to find life on Neptune. Otherwise it begs the question of why did life start on Mars, and that’s a turtles all the way down kind of situation.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by roncesvalles on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:02PM (#45203672)
In addition to one seeding the other, neighboring planets having life also gives support to extra-solar-system panspermia. An advanced civilization could've fired off the "seed" in some vehicles on calculated trajectories to all viable planets, and the Solar System happened to be within the radius of their efforts.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by vlovich123 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @07:59PM (#45205839)
Where do the turtles start?
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by estimator7292 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:54PM (#45204481)
Panspermia is such a juvenile take. It doesn't answer the question at all, just hand-waves it all away with a "because I said so". It's like a religion.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by roncesvalles on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:49PM (#45206724)
I was never attempting to answer where life came from. It's simply that if Mars and Earth both have/had life, the probability that they came from some common cosmic seeding project in our neighborhood becomes a bit more likely.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by vlovich123 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @11:54PM (#45207616)
Vs it’s a natural inevitable process when the conditions support it?
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by d1sxeyes on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:04PM (#45203690)
If that is true, then why does it seem that there has been only a single origin event on Earth?
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by AngryData on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:07PM (#45204664)
Well we aren't sure that it did have a single origin. But also, anything primitive enough to generate randomly is going to be viable food itself for other already existing and more evolved lifeforms, and the conditions for life to start by itself might just be a smorgasbord of energy for existing life forms that could out compete more primitive forms or alter the environmental conditions enough to prevent more life from forming. It might just not be possible for new life forms to arise in a non-sterile environment.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by rrmm on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:22PM (#45203956)
Does it seem that way? It happened at least once (but could have happened many times without "taking over"), and certainly one sort of life seemed to successfully out-compete all others. But none of that says single-origin to me.

Early on I would expect a whole lot of "horizontal gene transfer" sort of things to have taken place. So for example in addition to actual horizontal gene transfer, there are mechanisms like one organism enveloping another to eventually become organelles, co-opting products from each other, etc. All of which would act to homogenize life and make certain process ubiquitous.

Finally, there's an outside chance that "there's only one way to do it".

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by roncesvalles on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @07:01PM (#45205285)
I think single origin event is highly likely because, for example, it's wholly conceivable that a slightly different variant of AUCG (or just one of the molecules) could've emerged and it would have similar characteristics, but not differentiated enough that one would have a very strong selective advantage over the other.

Diversity could exist in harmony and the lack of any diversity is a pretty strong signal that the only extant version is either very rare or the only to ever emerge.

Everything in nature is diverse except RNA/DNA and this fact alone is a sort of evidence.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by vlovich123 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @07:55PM (#45205807)
Or the basic life that forms is going to look the same regardless of where it starts on Earth, meaning that you’d never have evidence of two origins.

Or RNA was just a winning virus that infected all other life or killed all competition to make it seem like there was only one origin.

Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by roncesvalles on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @09:45PM (#45206688)
I'm pretty sure we've checked every lifeform to see if they follow the universal genetic code, and they do. RNA is too fundamental to be a virus infection.

When you should see evidence but don't, "absence of evidence is not evidence of absence" doesn't apply. Otherwise absence becomes unprovable à la Russell's teapot.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by vlovich123 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @11:58PM (#45207628)
Except for that you’d have to have a reasonable belief you know what to look for and where to look.

By comparison, we’ve looked nowhere (Earth is big and mostly inaccessible to humans) and don’t know what we should be looking for, since we don’t have any testable models for the origin of life yet.

And re RNA I was just giving one example of why all life might have it (ie RNA gave an evolutionary advantage so anything without RNA died). There’s all sorts of reasons why we don’t have evidence of multiple origins, not least of which is that we just haven’t looked in the right place and there could easily be life being created from scratch on this planet without even knowing about it. That’s what the entire field of synthetic biology is even about; just doing it in a lab instead of out in nature so that we can understand the conditions better.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by d1sxeyes on Thursday September 11, 2025 @07:16AM (#45210212)
Absence of evidence is of course not evidence of absence, but all life on earth today seems to be descended from a single organism, 3-4 billion years ago: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Last_universal_common_ancest...

This is about a quarter of the lifetime of the universe ago, and we don’t have any evidence at all that life has ever occurred in any other way. We’ve only really been looking for a hundred years or so, but we’ve not found any “fountain of life” where life is being created, we’ve not found evidence of any type of life that isn’t broadly related.

I absolutely agree that it’s not evidence, but I believe that on balance, it makes more sense to take our working hypothesis to be something that fits the evidence we do have, rather than believing the evidence must exist we just don’t have it.

To be clear, I’m not advocating that we don’t investigate both possibilities, and I wouldn’t put much weight behind my own guess here.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by dgroshev on Monday September 15, 2025 @07:26AM (#45248414)
An important nuance here is that LUCA doesn't really imply there was only that one organism. There could be more organisms, it's just the one that we can trace, similar to mitochondrial Eve (see the "popular reception" section): https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitochondrial_Eve
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by estimator7292 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:58PM (#45204533)
There is absolutely zero evidence for this either way. We assume this is the case, but there's actually no way to ever know for sure. It's completely possible that life emerged and went extinct on this planet many times. Problem is it was so long ago that any fossil evidence has been either buried so far that we can never reach it, or subducted into the mantle and melted down. Absolutely no way to tell.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by vlovich123 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @07:57PM (#45205829)
It was so long ago that it would be buried deep under the ocean and we haven’t even explored well the ocean floor. And fossils wouldn’t really tell you whether there was one origin or another.

And you’re right, assuming those fossils even managed to survive in the first place and not get destroyed. And that’s ignoring that early life would have been microscopic and we wouldn’t really see fossils of that.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by d1sxeyes on Thursday September 11, 2025 @07:17AM (#45210219)
Why did it stop?
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by vlovich123 on Thursday September 11, 2025 @10:47AM (#45212324)
Do we have evidence that it stopped? Or just that we don’t know where to look and what to look for?

But even if it did, one clear argument could be that the conditions on Earth when it happened would have been very very different than the earth today. Lots more volcanic activity, lightning storms, and UV radiation. We don’t know the exact conditions needed to create life from inorganic precursors so we don’t have a solid hypothesis of was there multiple origins or a single or is it still happening today.

But given we have the beginnings of evidence of life on Mars, Titan, and Triton, and that it would make sense since we know life must arise naturally out of non-life origins (since there was no life at the Big Bang), I would venture to guess that life is both rare and common. Intelligent life also seems common although less common than life overall (other primates, dolphins, Elephants, ravens/crows, and cephalopods are all quite intelligent). Intelligence + tool use is also not uncommon but rarer (we’ve caught animals on tape using tools). Advanced industrial civilization is the only thing so far that we only have a single existence evidence for - is that unique, can there ever only be one on a planet at a time, or can there only be one ever when conditions are right? Eg we wouldn’t have gotten very far if we were on the planet earlier and didn’t have dinosaur bones to power our industry with - the jump from whale oil to nuclear/photovoltaics/wind turbines seems unlikely but maybe it would happen anyway, just longer.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by aurareturn on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:10PM (#45203770)
"You start with a random clump of atoms, and if you shine light on it for long enough, it should not be so surprising that you get a plant." -Jeremy England

Life increases entropy and doesn't break 2nd law of thermodynamics.

Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by mr_mitm on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:19PM (#45203899)
Actually it's enough to have a sufficiently large amount of hydrogen. No extra light necessary.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by lawlessone on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @04:58PM (#45203602)
neptune?
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by vlovich123 on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @06:06PM (#45204642)
Sorry, I meant a moon of Neptune (Triton). There's also a recent research study suggesting Titan also has life.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by soiltype on Wednesday September 10, 2025 @05:19PM (#45203906)
I don't think there's any reasonable way to call that a likely scenario though. If life did emerge on Mars, why wouldn't it also emerge on Earth? For both planets to have life, the most likely explanation is that it's just common.
Re:'Clearest sign' yet of ancient life on Mars by Bender on Friday September 12, 2025 @03:39PM (#45225848)
Anything is possible but unlikely we would find it unless there are buried megaliths signed by humans with graphic pictures. Even on Earth it would be hard to prove we were ever here after half a billion years after we destroy ourselves. It might not even take that long. Most things will rust, decompose, shatter into something resembling dust and many coastal regions will get recycled by plate techtonic movements. Mars has been a dead planet for a long time no magnetosphere, probably how this one will end up at some point.