Re:Stock buybacks are stock swindles
by cm2187 on Saturday September 06, 2025 @12:55PM
(#45150899)
Completely moronic take. Stock buybacks are just a more tax efficient form of dividend. If the author's argument is that companies should never return any money to investors, either as dividend or stock buybacks, then what is the point of owning a share in the first place.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Well, there are voting rights. This way you should have influence on the development of the company and therefore influence on the stock price. Which gives a shareholder money back if he/she sells.
Re:Stock buybacks are stock swindles
by quantified on Saturday September 06, 2025 @03:03PM
(#45151983)
The only driver of the price at that point is the price that the company would buy shares back for, because that's the only vehicle to return cash.
If the company gave preferences to shareholders (like discounts on the trucks it makes, flights it makes, rides it shares, etc.) or only sells to them, there could be other sources of value.