Why would GDP be the proxy for a country's profit? If I pay someone to build a house and another person to tear that house down, both activities contribute to GDP while producing nothing of tangible value.
If it were the same company, that company would have made profit twice. Or did your house change country before being torn down?
But they spent the money you paid them and it stimulated the economy! We assume value was created elsewhere. /s
Econ is a crock.
Re:996
by adgjlsfhk1 on Saturday September 06, 2025 @02:48PM
(#45151859)
gdp is a revenue like number, not a profit like number.
It is closest to value added something most companies do not disclose but is closely related to profit but is NOTHING like revenue.
Re:996
by adgjlsfhk1 on Saturday September 06, 2025 @04:42PM
(#45152677)
no, if you trade a dollar back and forth 1000 times with a friend, you are adding $1000 to the GDP.
If you pay someone a dollar, that is because they supplied you with something worth a dollar - i.e. a dollar's worth of value added to the economy.
Re:996
by adgjlsfhk1 on Sunday September 07, 2025 @05:52PM
(#45162517)
right, but if an item goes through 10 different factories to be assembled the price each pays from the previous gets added to GDP.
IS that true? What do you define as the revenue of a country? Tax revenues? That is just the government. GDP/GNP/GNI? That comparison for that should be profit, and only a handful of really big companies (Saudi Aramco, Apple, that sort of size) have a profit as large as the GDP of mid-size middle income countries (e.g. Sri Lanka) or small rich countries (e.g. Luxembourg). There is a long tail of small or poor countries so most countries by number, but most people live in a country with a GDP that is an order of magnitude or two greater than any company's profit.