It is a good idea though, peer-to-peer anything is the new hotness.
As a card carrying member of the "160k miles, last 20k with the check-engine light on" club, this is the best thing ever and I can't wait for them to get it to Chicago.
Your car's maintenance can easily become a life or death issue if you lose engine power on the highway, or far worse, lose brakes or a wheel. You wouldn't go to Dr. Nick Riviera would you?
YourMechanic hasn't reduced the time it takes to perform basic repairs. The only practical difference is where the repair takes place and that you can schedule it over the web instead of over the phone. Existing mechanics already offer at-home repairs (albeit, at significantly higher rates than in-shop repairs) so YourMechanic's "innovation" is really just offering existing concierge mechanic services for a lower price.
Here's the thing: any mechanic worth his oil doesn't have the free time to drive to customers to perform repairs. He may have employees drive out to customers to pick up cars on his behalf, but he will remain back at the shop. Thus, YourMechanic will ultimately attract the types of mechanics who don't have the skills to set up their own fixed locations, i.e., mechanics who are mostly definitely not the cream of the crop.
Incidentally, I'd never use an at-home service, even though it's very inconvenient for me to drop off my car at the garage, because the quality of car repair can be a life-or-death issue, so I'd rather that my mechanics have all the tools and equipment (car lift, adequate lighting, etc.) they need right at their disposal instead of being tempted to cut corners.
Wow really?
If that is the case how can they not have received favorable treatment? Even with the best of intentions those judges must be intimate with every aspect of the business and would be unable to separate that knowledge from what the other judges are basing their decisions on.
I know the TC bias bashing is a bit of a meme here on HN but is hard to get away from when things like this crop up.
The exception was last year's BitCasa, who ironically lost to Shaker. Strange world we live in sometimes.