News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:1TB Raspberry Pi SSD on sale now for $70 by kej on Friday September 05, 2025 @12:01PM (#45140073)
I feel like the Pi 4 and 5 have moved into a weird limbo area, where if you want it as a small computer there are better computers that include all the things you mentioned, and if you want it for integrating with electronics there are probably less powerful but cheaper options that would work just as well.
Re:1TB Raspberry Pi SSD on sale now for $70 by ploxiln on Friday September 05, 2025 @12:23PM (#45140348)
The Pi 3 B+ is still available for $35, it's what I still use on occasion - as an ad-hoc networked sensor, or an LED or switch controller, or an weird eeprom programmer ...

Sure I could use an arduino in many cases, but the Pi running linux can be very convenient, with bash or regular python or even small unix C utilities (which I can tweak and re-compile right on the Pi!)

Re:1TB Raspberry Pi SSD on sale now for $70 by ThatPlayer on Friday September 05, 2025 @12:52PM (#45140727)
Yeah, the Raspberry Pi 4 is available at $35 too, and I like the less common Pi 3A+. The competitors at that price are only the rk3566 boards

The Pi 5 and the RK3588 boards is when I'd get an Intel N100 miniPC instead.

Re:1TB Raspberry Pi SSD on sale now for $70 by tzs on Friday September 05, 2025 @12:30PM (#45140445)
What I'd really like is an RPi4 or RPi5 that has an ATmega328P on board that can be programmed and controlled from the software running on the ARM processor. Basically a built-in Arduino UNO.
Re:1TB Raspberry Pi SSD on sale now for $70 by arcane23 on Friday September 05, 2025 @02:34PM (#45142011)
Just get a hat? They breakout into Arduino UNO style connectors and you can use hats designed for that on top of it.
Re:1TB Raspberry Pi SSD on sale now for $70 by teamonkey on Friday September 05, 2025 @12:50PM (#45140712)
Have you looked at programming the RP1 chip on board the Pi5? It’s not exactly a RP2040 but it has PIO and other similarities.
Re:1TB Raspberry Pi SSD on sale now for $70 by ThatPlayer on Friday September 05, 2025 @12:54PM (#45140750)
Not an ATmega328P (and not ARM), but the Radxa X4 has an Intel N100 with a RP2040 microcontroller built-in.
Re:1TB Raspberry Pi SSD on sale now for $70 by teamonkey on Friday September 05, 2025 @01:07PM (#45140899)
I remember someone testing that board (Jeff Geerling, maybe?) and there was significant lag on the GPIO because the MCU is essentially an external device with communication over serial (IIRC), it just happens to be mounted on the motherboard.
Re:1TB Raspberry Pi SSD on sale now for $70 by ThatPlayer on Friday September 05, 2025 @02:37PM (#45142048)
The Raspberry Pi 5 has also done something similar: the CPU no longer controls the GPIO directly, but through a RP1 southbridge. Maybe that's what you're thinking of? Don't see any mention of latency on Jeff's review on it, and I doubt the Radxa X4 is popular enough for any big in-depth review like that.

It looks like the RP2040 on the X4 is connected via USB. The RP2040's bootloader mode that enables flashing emulates a mass storage device over USB to transfer firmware, so it would be confusing to not connect it via USB.

Re:1TB Raspberry Pi SSD on sale now for $70 by teamonkey on Friday September 05, 2025 @04:46PM (#45143402)
To clarify, the issue with the X4 is that it essentially is no different than having a Pi Pico attached via USB.

This means that your x86 program doesn’t directly control the GPIOs, it must communicate with the RP2040 over USB serial. The RP2040 must be flashed with a firmware that knows how to handle these serial commands.

It works, but it’s an extra step and timing may be an issue.

On the other hand, a Raspberry Pi Linux program can toggle GPIO pins natively simply by using the official libraries.

I mentioned the RP1 in another comment.

Re:1TB Raspberry Pi SSD on sale now for $70 by slug on Friday September 05, 2025 @12:55PM (#45140768)
Beaglebone Black with PRU
Re:1TB Raspberry Pi SSD on sale now for $70 by ShakataGaNai on Friday September 05, 2025 @12:32PM (#45140471)
Not even limbo. If you need an ultra low power SBC, Pi is there. But if you want the cheapest option, it ain't.

A raspberry pi 5 8gb CanaKit. So pi, fan, microsd, cords, power. Comes in at $160 on Amazon https://www.amazon.com/CanaKit-Raspberry-Starter-Kit-PRO/dp/...

You can get any number of Intel N150 MiniPC's with RAM, SSD and power cord for $140? https://www.amazon.com/GMKtec-mini-pc-computer-n150/dp/B0CH8... Maybe less on sale. And an Intel N150 is going to score 2-3x on standard benchmarks what the RPi does. You can find older N100 based mini PC's for even less.

The pi still has its place, again, for those ultra low power use cases. But for "I just want a small computer", it's not the option. Mostly because of economies of scale. Everything in the MiniPC's is made at thousands of times more scale than the RPi. Also.... in Chinese factories for significantly less cost to start with.

Re:1TB Raspberry Pi SSD on sale now for $70 by dogleash on Friday September 05, 2025 @03:43PM (#45142787)
For a "project" mini, I've found used minipcs on ebay sold by the lot can have very reasonable per-unit prices. The hardware can be 5+ years old, but if you're looking for a pi/SBC alternative that can still be more than you need.
Re:1TB Raspberry Pi SSD on sale now for $70 by arcane23 on Friday September 05, 2025 @02:23PM (#45141857)
The way I used my Raspberry Pi boards fits into two categories, either always on providing some network service (with a shield), which usually benefits from very low power draw, either needing SPI/I2C/serial to connect to random hardware. For both of these use cases x86 miniPCs are not adequate. They either lack the GPIO header either they draw way more power than ~3-5W (onboard chipset, RAM etc draw extra power)
Re:1TB Raspberry Pi SSD on sale now for $70 by Mister_Snuggles on Friday September 05, 2025 @12:37PM (#45140533)
Honestly, the big thing that the Pi has is the support and mindshare. Compared to many equivalents (e.g., the Banana Pi) you'll find much better documentation and have a much more polished experience with a Raspberry Pi.

The only question, for me anyway, is how much value I put on that experience and whether the increased cost is worth it.

Re:1TB Raspberry Pi SSD on sale now for $70 by joshuanapoli on Friday September 05, 2025 @01:45PM (#45141376)
Yes, this is it. When I'm experimenting, I'm happy to pay an extra $40 for the name-brand device that has 1000s of blog posts supporting it, since it's probably this community is going to help me be more successful and learn faster.

I would reconsider the choice when I have a commercial product that I have some scale of production, where a few bucks off the BOM is important.

Re:1TB Raspberry Pi SSD on sale now for $70 by JohnBooty on Friday September 05, 2025 @01:33PM (#45141210)
Respectfully, not from my angle!

From a purely hardware perspective, I think it's always been in that "limbo" for almost every use case anyway.

For a hobbyist even in Ye Olden Days (before there were other single board computers) you were always able to pull up Craiglist or walk to the thrift store and buy a $50 PC that vastly outperformed a Pi anyway. Underclock that PC and it could be a fanless power miser too, albeit not quite down to Pi levels. (Pretty sure I remember people clocking 900mhz P3's down to 500mhz fanless, that kind of thing. Still faster than a O.G. RPi...)

So the Pi's hardware was really only a revelation if you needed that semi-embeddable form factor, or if you wanted to do something like manage a classroom of cheap low-performance PCs without the nightmare of managing a fleet of heterogeneous junk PCs.

It was always all about the objectively awesome ecosystem of support and peripherals, and deciding whether that ecosystem mattered for you and your use case. Sometimes that ecosystem is a massive boon and sometimes it doesn't matter at all.

Re:1TB Raspberry Pi SSD on sale now for $70 by JohnBooty on Friday September 05, 2025 @02:57PM (#45142275)
Tangentially, it's always been annoying (and maybe slightly morbidly humorous) how the RPi has always remained a sort of barely-tolerable web browsing machine, even as the hardware's performance has massively increased, because the weight and complexity of web pages has also correspondingly increased.