Re:I Should Have Loved Electrical Engineering
by zhemao on Thursday September 04, 2025 @03:11PM
(#45131071)
In computer architecture / digital ASIC design there's zero control theory. There's not much mathematics in general.
Re:I Should Have Loved Electrical Engineering
by dreamcompiler on Thursday September 04, 2025 @07:04PM
(#45133238)
There's Boolean algebra but no control theory is needed for logic design.
One minor caveat is that most CPUs nowadays contain phase-locked loop (PLL) clock multipliers. Those fall into the domain of control theory but strictly speaking they're not part of the logic.
Re:I Should Have Loved Electrical Engineering
by uxp100 on Friday September 05, 2025 @08:55AM
(#45137975)
And in my inexpert experience, they are IP developed by the fab. So if you are doing CPU design work, you may need to understand PLLs well enough to read a datasheet, but you will not need to design a PLL.
I maybe had the most trouble just figuring out which instantiated PLL in the chip belonged to which PLL design, and where someone stuck the documentation in the giant repo. Especially since a hardware designer may think, oh we don’t need to update the docs, “nothing changed,” but the PLLs did change names because of a process change and their parameters may have changed slightly, even if they’re essentially the same. And chasing down small changes and documenting them ends up being a lot of the job in software.
I wonder, how much control theory is there in CPU?