News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I'm a High Schooler. AI Is Demolishing My Education by igor47 on Wednesday September 03, 2025 @11:38PM (#45123272)
Struggling to understand what you're saying but it sounds like you're making two points:

* We should dismiss the concerns in TFA because the author is... A good and conscientious student? Who is both unpopular and also the class president?

* The students who are outsourcing their thinking, or at least their work, to LLMs, have good reasons for this and the reasons are not addressed in the piece

The first point is at best a pure ad hominem and at worst a full blown assault on conscientiousness and actually doing the work. I think the class president and good student is a better authority than the cheater. I'm very disturbed by the recent trend on HN and the wider world to justify any shortcut taken for personal advancement. We need people to value substance, not just image...

The second point is irrelevant -- we don't have do both-sideism in every piece. But also even if they do have good reasons to cheat, this creates an instant race to the bottom where now everyone must cheat. This is why they do doping checks in professional sports, except this is much higher stakes

Re:I'm a High Schooler. AI Is Demolishing My Education by textadventure on Wednesday September 03, 2025 @11:45PM (#45123325)
I'm wondering why is this being published in the first place. It's not an interesting or illuminating perspective, it's a pretentious student telling us nothing new.

I gave no opinions on AI, yet I do think it's very much a problem. This article presents neither good ideas to tackle it, nor an insightful perspective on the problem.

Re:I'm a High Schooler. AI Is Demolishing My Education by hdhdhsjsbdh on Thursday September 04, 2025 @12:05AM (#45123442)
Her parents know someone at the Atlantic, and she needs publications to pad out her Harvard application :)
Re:I'm a High Schooler. AI Is Demolishing My Education by igor47 on Thursday September 04, 2025 @12:00AM (#45123409)
The point of publishing it seems to me to be "kids in classrooms also think this is a problem". The subject matter is often talked about in the upper echelons and among adults, it's good to see a kid's prospective. It's equivalent to an essay by a kid saying they also struggle with the effects of social media -- it creates a broader consensus environment, helping to build buy in for a shared paradigm
Re:I'm a High Schooler. AI Is Demolishing My Education by textadventure on Thursday September 04, 2025 @12:12AM (#45123499)
Right, except what I'm saying is that the perspective of a this A+ kind of student is off-putting and not contributing to the discussion in any meaningful way.

What I'm saying is precisely that the take of a more genuine, less pretentious kid, would be far more insightful.

It's a weak editorial choice.

Re:I'm a High Schooler. AI Is Demolishing My Education by intended on Thursday September 04, 2025 @12:49AM (#45123687)
This does feel like a personal preference has been inflamed here, and is overshadowing your interpretation of the message.

There will be interviews done with non A+ students.

Re:I'm a High Schooler. AI Is Demolishing My Education by polotics on Thursday September 04, 2025 @12:43AM (#45123657)
can you highlight the pretentious bits i totally missed them
Re:I'm a High Schooler. AI Is Demolishing My Education by flappyeagle on Thursday September 04, 2025 @03:15PM (#45131130)
It’s a good student writing the piece, which is somehow fundamentally pretentious
Re:I'm a High Schooler. AI Is Demolishing My Education by polotics on Friday September 05, 2025 @06:20AM (#45136960)
ok, essentialism much?
Re:I'm a High Schooler. AI Is Demolishing My Education by flappyeagle on Thursday September 04, 2025 @03:14PM (#45131109)
You seem to be projecting some issues onto this student from your own childhood experience. Maybe look into that