News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I'm done with Scrum by g123g on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @12:16PM (#4511359)
The #1 point mentioned in the article was my experience as well. For a tight deadline project if we decided to do everything based on the complexity points and team velocity it would take 6 sprints and a total of 3 months. But we just decided to ditch it and sit around a table and finished the whole thing in 2 weeks straight. So my experience is that if you are working with a dedicated team it is better to finish the work based on the best of your ability rather than time boxing into some artificial time limits.
Re:Why I'm done with Scrum by kevingadd on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @12:29PM (#4511445)
How would Scrum turn a 2 week project into 3 months? Are you just saying you were terrible at estimation, or what? I don't understand what you ditched, specifically, and how that produced an improvement.
Re:Why I'm done with Scrum by SoftwareMaven on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @01:52PM (#4511915)
In timeboxed iterations, you have to be very careful that work doesn't expand to fill all available time. If you are a little conservative with your estimates, its easy to double the time the necessary aspects of development would take. Little, unnecessary tweaks becomes more important than putting four hours into the stretch goal that is going to spill into the next sprint.

Six times is a bit much, though. That sounds like they haven't worked out their estimations yet.

Re:Why I'm done with Scrum by knighthacker on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @01:01PM (#4511642)
Having a dedicated team is definitely important. I had a similar experience to yours and I am not entirely sure why.

I think a big part of it is that once you dig into complexity points and time estimates and all that other stuff, people tend to be on the safe side and add a lot of buffer. But when the whole team is in the hacking mentality and just wants to get sh*t done, you don't need to have everything in sprints. You just need a highly motivated and a dedicated team.

Re:Why I'm done with Scrum by skMed on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @01:11PM (#4511703)
Are you trying to say the overhead of SCRUM would increase the time to 3 months? SCRUM is a lightweight framework, so I am struggling to see how this could happen. Alternatively, do you think the estimation with points was the main problem and you couldn't get a correct feel for doing it without resulting in a conservative estimate?