News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bear is now source-available by yjftsjthsd-h on Monday September 01, 2025 @03:59PM (#45096078)
I'm really not a lawyer, but I'm skeptical that such a thing is even possible; is it legally possible to say that you as the copyright owner will never relicense something?

(What I'm given to understand does work is using a copyleft license and taking code from multiple parties without a CLA, because then relicensing requires all the copyright owners to agree, which for a large enough project is impractical.)

Re:Bear is now source-available by _puk on Monday September 01, 2025 @04:02PM (#45096113)
How about a standard entity "OSI perhaps?!", that commits a file to an early stage of the repository (could this be automated), who then cannot / will not give approval for a relicense?
Re:Bear is now source-available by j1elo on Monday September 01, 2025 @05:55PM (#45096968)
Relicensing still can be done, just keeping that file out. (and reimplementing it the same but with new code, if it was really needed for something important)
Re:Bear is now source-available by miggol on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @02:08PM (#45106860)
Love the idea but the thing is, if it's just one file then it's probably easy enough to work that contribution out of the repository.

It is quite fun to try and think of ways that this could work though. Perhaps a bot that code-paraphrases (paracodes?) every accepted PR. Or maybe there's some crypto magic you could do to make the only option a clean room rewrite.

Re:Bear is now source-available by dragonwriter on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @11:35AM (#45104466)
> I'm really not a lawyer, but I'm skeptical that such a thing is even possible; is it legally possible to say that you as the copyright owner will never relicense something?

It’s possible to say anything. Without something like a contract with reciprocal commitments to make it binding, the legal effect of saying it is limited (though not necessarily zero, because legal concepts like promissory estoppel exist.)