News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Depression lies by huggah on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @11:58PM (#4509061)
We have an incredible capacity for denial and self-deception. For years, I would periodically drop into severe depression; I would stop sleeping, stop eating, stop answering my phone or email. I wouldn't leave my room for weeks on end; on a few occasions I was so successfully reclusive that people worried that I disappeared or died called the police to investigate. A few times I almost did die; I think the biggest reason I never committed suicide was that I didn't have the willpower for even that.

Years. Call it 6, with bouts every 8 months. One semester of 'A's, one semester of 'F's.

Of course this caused me to fail classes and lost me friends, opportunities and respect. But every time I recovered I thought to myself "Wow, that was awful. Glad I'll never do that again!" I had to lose my fiancée and my funding in grad school before I finally accepted to the fact that this might be a problem. That there might be a cause other than being lazy. Because, you know, laziness makes people curl up in an empty bathtub and cry for 24 hours. That's normal, right?

Thanks to Wil for posting this. It's important to reach out to sufferers as well as their friends and family. It takes a lot to recognize when you or someone you know has a problem, even when in retrospect it's blindingly obvious.

Re:Depression lies by btilly on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @12:12AM (#4509101)
I think the biggest reason I never committed suicide was that I didn't have the willpower for even that.

One of the most dangerous periods for depressed people is shortly after they start treatment. They are still depressed, but suddenly have the energy to commit suicide, and a certain fraction of them do.

My wife lost a cousin that way. :-(

Re:Depression lies by navs on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @01:02AM (#4509231)
Also consider that many SSRIs actually list suicidal urges as a side effect. In my transition from Celexa to Prozac to Effexor, I've found that transitioning period to be particularly bad. Not to go into too much detail but I've done things of late I never did before and my doctor has said it's likely my change in medication. They say things need to be at their worst before they can get better. That's my mantra.
Re:Depression lies by mnicole on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @11:33AM (#4511114)
Effexor literally made me think and act in ways I never had before. There's the disassociative feeling you get from depression, and then there's what Effexor did; effectively making me a ticking time-bomb with an insanely vivid, active (and morbid) imagination. Really dark times, and coincidentally a few months after I'd quit it, Time magazine had a cover article about the rise of [teen] suicides because of it.
Re:Depression lies by navs on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @04:13PM (#4512906)
Can I ask what you switched to after dropping Effexor? My email is listed in my profile if you wish to answer privately.
Re:Depression lies by mnicole on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @06:19PM (#4513568)
Quite honestly it scared the shit out of me to the point where I no longer felt safe seeking aid from people who claimed to have answers. At the end of the day, none of the other anti-d's I'd tried (all of the major ones) did anything but take any emotions - negative or positive - away, and that's not how I wanted to live. For years I wasn't on anything, but more recently I tried Wellbutrin to similar results. As such I've made it more of a mission to find out what it really is that's causing this, rather than apply a band-aid to what is really just a side-effect of a bigger issue.
Re:Depression lies by moistgorilla on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @10:30PM (#4514485)
I'm sorry anti-depressants didn't work out for you. Luckily I've only had to try out two different types before finding the one for me. Wellbutrin was my first ad but it made me feel like an emotionless robot. I then got on prozac and rather than make me a robot it made me feel normal. Not exactly happy but definitely not sad. Which is what I was going for anyway. Good luck, also, if you didn't try therapy, i suggest you do.
Re:Depression lies by grueful on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @12:23AM (#4509133)
They're often on the tail of years of anxiety and depression, plus environmental stressors which aren't going to disappear through talking or medication.

Sometimes you take a pill and the problem is solved. But often, it's a matter of a struggle for better, not fixed. Or a decision between the illness and the side effects of continuous medication.

But ignoring it is a terrible option.

Re:Depression lies by diffeomorph on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @12:42AM (#4509185)
I had the same problem. My depression had been latent since early HS but it really manifested when I began college, and my grades were horrible as a result despite having been a model student until then(well, until the last year of HS; college only hastened its development). I'm 29 and I've since gotten treatment but the effect on my professional development has been incredibly damaging. It's less a stumble out of the gate than a foot shot.

I know intellectually that I've achieved as much - or possibly more - than my typical peer because I've worked through my problems and traumas and come out the other end alive and healthy, but they're still the ones with the comparatively advanced careers, living in nicer cities, and taking care of their young families while I'm still working saw jobs in the midwest and living, alone, in a studio apartment.

But I'm alive, and I'm able to finally live a normal life, which is priceless.

Re:Depression lies by eggdude on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @02:16PM (#4512099)
Comparing yourself to others is an easy way to think negatively and possibly even descend into depression. It's important to accept who you are and what got you there and not think that your life would be so much better "if only things had been different". Things weren't different. You were given the genes you were given from parents who you didn't choose and countless other variables influenced you to become depressed and then recover at the time you did. No need to feel bad about it.

I don't mean for this to sound like a personal attack. I'm in a similar position to you and I've found it incredibly rewarding to realize that it is useless to worry about the past and what could have happened.

Re:Depression lies by msfd on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @05:58AM (#4509935)
I would say "Maybe".

Maybe they have better lives, or maybe they are (or will be) depressed like you were.

The point is, you don't know, so enjoy you live, I think you deserve it.

Re:Depression lies by msfd on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @02:17PM (#4512106)
Cannot edit anymore, so what I wanted to say (I was not very clear) is : The lives they have is not necessarily as nice as you picture it, nor yours as bleak as you think. In the end, I would not really think too much (even if I know it's hard) about them. After all, they might had enormous advantage, or actually a shitty live, because everything is too perfect or maybe they struggled so much to be where they are and so, are exhausted intellectually and depressed.

You achieved an incredible feat by controlling your depression, I'd be proud of it.

Re:Depression lies by luriel on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @12:01AM (#4509074)
Knowing you "have a problem" doesn't mean you or anyone understands the problem or what to do about it. And even if you know what to do, doesn't mean you can do it either, the psychological, social or just practical barriers can be impossible to climb.

Medication has a statistical significant effect, but is often marginal at best, and most of the effect is placebo.

And this assumes an accurate diagnosis, and don't count on that, I have had the head of psychiatric care of a major European capital say to me that the science of psychiatric diagnosis is basically worthless, I wouldn't go that far (the split between research and academia and practice is also a huge problem), but is nowhere as simple as some like to make it seem.

People and lives are often much more complex than that and much more significant factors.

Doctors can also do much more harm than good, locking people up in horribly depressing kafkian institutions because they are suicidal is one of the most insane things I have seen in my life.

Imagine what it feels like being locked up against your will, treated almost like an animal, when you have done nothing to harm anyone, and being told it is "for your own good".

Re:Depression lies by dkarl on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @01:13AM (#4509255)
Knowing the problem is depression and learning to recognize how depression affects me has led to big improvements for me. It doesn't stop me from getting depressed and believing all the same old lies, but when the depression lifts, I get to enjoy not being depressed right away. Before I understood depression, the lies depression taught me tended to stick around. They were part of how I thought even when I wasn't depressed, and I wasted a lot of energy debating them with myself and fretting about problems that were insoluble but weren't really problems. By the time I started feeling hopeful about life again, the next depression was already right around the corner. Now it's much easier to shrug off those false beliefs when the depression lifts and just enjoy being relatively normal for a while. That doesn't mean I won't get depressed again, but depression casts less of a shadow over the non-depressed times of my life.

As a really crude analogy, imagine somebody slips a hallucinogen into your drink and you end up having a terrifying conversation with God where he addresses you as Satan, and for weeks afterwards you obsess painfully about whether you're evil or maybe you are actually Satan somehow, living in fear of what will happen next, versus knowingly taking a drug and afterwards saying, "Wow, that was shitty. I thought I was Satan, LOL." In both cases the experience is horrifying and real, but in the first one, the experience continues to be horrifying and real for a long time afterwards. In the second one, only the memory remains real.

Re:Depression lies by lusr on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @01:28AM (#4509281)
Absolutely. I haven't seen anybody mention David Burns' book "Feeling Good" but it probably saved my life from a descent into insanity. It's my "bible" now. I knew something was completely and absolutely wrong with my self-destructive thought patterns but didn't understand what until I learned about Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT).

A sad observation: everytime I encounter a struggling friend with dysfunctional thought patterns, I work through their thoughts using CBT techniques (without mentioning that's what I'm doing). This almost always results in a calmer friend who starts feeling better about the situation, or at least more confident in their ability to deal with it.

I then tell them what I'd done to improve their emotional state and how they can learn to do it for themselves by pointing them to CBT and Burns... and a few months later I find they still suffer from dysfunctional thoughts and haven't bothered following my advice.

Funny thing is I was the same; it took a bout of severe depression and reading "Feeling Good" exactly at the time when I could introspect my severely dysfunctional thought patterns for me to accept my situation (having purchased the book a year previously but being dubious about its claims of my "mild" depression at the time). I don't know if this is social conditioning (only "weak" people get depression) or general ignorance of the fact that the mind needs "maintenance work".

Re:Depression lies by kahawe on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @04:46AM (#4509747)
I do think it is great you take the time to help them like that; I also think this isn't something you should be doing, basically taking them through a "mini therapy".

Now, granted, the line between "I just wanted to cheer them up" and "I showed them CBT" can be blurry but as soon as you take it onto yourself to actively make them better, I'd say you are strolling down a path you shouldn't. The main reason being I doubt you are an expert. The other reason being that it can affect you because you are close to them. And lastly I do not think just one such hint in the right direction is going to help the person suffering. Practically all therapists and people who have ever taken therapy will tell you just how much it feels like 1 small step forward 2 steps back, how much of a constant struggle it is. Changing a behavior is never easy, much less so if it is something that was "programmed" into you since you were a child, something that is your very view of the world. Understanding the mechanisms and a few techniques of CBT can be empowering, absolutely, but it takes so much more to actually make them work and work in the long run, to actually make you feel better and get out of that hole or to change... and not all people have that much energy or ability to introspect and watch themselves what they are doing AND then come up with ways of making it stop. Maybe in the long run it would be more helpful for them to just seek therapy?

Re:Depression lies by lusr on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @07:28AM (#4510127)
Whilst I agree it's dangerous to attempt offering people therapy when you don't have the qualifications to back it up, I think you're conflating therapy with helping depressed individuals to recognize their condition so that they may seek therapy.

Believe me I have no desire to rescue people. Been there, tried that. However, part of the problem with people who are depressed is that they don't realise they are depressed. So when you see somebody struggling with dysfunctional thinking you have 3 options:

1. Pretend you have no additional information that can help them and hope they find the appropriate resources themselves.

2. Decide that (1) is unethical and suggest appropriate resources that may help them.

3. If (2) didn't work the last time, acknowledge that sometimes depressed individuals can be either unaware or in denial of the seriousness of their condition. Since you can't force them to seek help, you have the option of asking them the very same questions CBT taught you to ask yourself in the situation. At this point the person hopefully sees the value in what you're doing and is more convinced in the value of your suggestions in (2). At no point do you take it upon yourself to perform therapy.

CBT is based on the idea that we're ultimately rational creatures but sometimes we're not aware of all the factors influencing our cognition. While you ought to have training if you are attempting to perform therapy, you don't need a professional training to point out dysfunctional thinking in someone and point them in the direction of professionals who can perform therapy.

Re:Depression lies by dkarl on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @03:07PM (#4512451)
Analyzing, talking through, and attempting to change thought patterns isn't just a clinical technique for serious problems. In my experience, the smaller the problem and the healthier the person, the more quickly and dramatically it seems to work. Other than people who have been in therapy or who have grappled with mental health issues on their own, I rarely see people using it, with one exception: I see the parents I know using it with their children all the time to help them deal with everyday emotional difficulties such as anger management. A decade from now, there might be a generation of adults who consider it common sense and have no idea it originated in the treatment of mental illness.
Re:Depression lies by lusr on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @05:35PM (#4513362)
An excellent point and indeed I see my experiences with depression as a strength I can pass onto my children by teaching them to recognize and handle dysfunctional thought patterns in themselves and others.
Re:Depression lies by lsiebert on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @02:20AM (#4509393)
You want to talk about statistics, but include anecdotal statements from anonymous sources, and end with an appeal to emotion.

You want to state that psychiatric medicine is mostly placebo, but don't have any good criticisms to levy against double blind studies of antidepressants with placebos.

Given the point of the article was encouraging/helping individuals who have depression to seek medical help, I'm not sure what the purpose of your comments are. It sounds like you had a bad experience with the mental health community.

Just like people who have a bad experience with any public service, I feel for you. I might even look at whether there are systemic issues in the provision of the service, in this case mental health.

But if your intention is to make people question the efficacy and usefulness of mental health treatment for depressed people, then I feel that you are attacking something that many people have fought hard to get, get attention for and get funded, mental health treatment.

Mental health treatment still has a stigma attached to it, that of some inherent deficiency that contributes to mental issues. Adding the unrealistic idea that depressed individuals are going to be locked up and treated like animals isn't helpful in my opinion.

I'm not saying that your experience, or the experiences you are familiar with, was/were invalid. However, hundreds of thousands of individuals who find psychological or pharmacological treatment for mental illness of benefit, and many more could benefit but go undiagnosed/untreated.

Re:Depression lies by Alex3917 on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @12:23PM (#4511417)
"You want to state that psychiatric medicine is mostly placebo, but don't have any good criticisms to levy against double blind studies of antidepressants with placebos."

Because maybe he assumes you aren't too stupid to do a simple Google search. Both Emperor's New Drugs and Anatomy of an Epidemic are extraordinarily well written, it's well worth reading both, and there are all sorts of other good books on mental illness as well.

This is exactly why HN has become like idiocracy, where anyone who takes the time to become well educated about something before speaking is basically called a faggot for reading books.

Re:Depression lies by locopati on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @01:02PM (#4511649)
I don't understand where your last paragraph of bile is coming from. There's been no name calling here that I can see.
Re:Depression lies by Alex3917 on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @01:12PM (#4511711)
Read the section of text that I quoted. Someone who said something that's fundamentally correct is being criticized by a variety of other people who are too lazy to actually do the research themselves. That's the very premise of the movie Idiocracy.
Re:Depression lies by jtheory on Thursday September 13, 2012 @10:10AM (#4516191)
Your language is noticeably nastier than anything you're responding to, here and in another comment below.

Of course you can disagree with, or be upset by other comments, but dialing up the language significantly doesn't do anything useful.

Re:Depression lies by Alex3917 on Thursday September 13, 2012 @10:58AM (#4516439)
"Of course you can disagree with, or be upset by other comments, but dialing up the language significantly doesn't do anything useful."

While I respect your opinion, personally I think it's much better to have a community where people are occasionally assholes than to have a community where people are giving false and dangerous health advice.

Re:Depression lies by lotharbot on Thursday September 13, 2012 @06:30PM (#4518987)
> "it's much better to have a community where people are occasionally assholes"

The guidelines [0] disagree with you. "Be civil" is followed by a period, not by a list of exceptions for when it's OK to be an asshole. Likewise, "please respond to the argument instead of calling names" is followed by an example, not by exceptions.

When people give wrong advice, counter it, but do so without the name-calling.

[0] http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Depression lies by Alex3917 on Thursday September 13, 2012 @10:14PM (#4519675)
"When people give wrong advice, counter it, but do so without the name-calling."

I have been. For several years. You're right of course. From my perspective though it's just extremely frustrating because I try my best to help people stay safe, but day after day people keep thoughtlessly posting the same crap based on what they see on TV commercials or whatever.

Re:Depression lies by jtheory on Tuesday September 18, 2012 @01:29AM (#4536508)
Don't think of "people" as a static entity; that's the problem. HN does have something of an "eternal September" effect that everyone has to deal with, permanently.

There's a constant influx of new people, many of whom will learn to contribute more valuable commentary, but haven't learned yet.

It's discouraging, but easier to deal with if you recognize it for what it is.

Re:Depression lies by DenisM on Thursday September 13, 2012 @09:26PM (#4519568)
Pleas leave and don't come back until you are ready to be civil.
Re:Depression lies by EricDeb on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @12:56AM (#4509214)
I'm not sure that the abbreviated sentiment that medication has little more effect than a placebo is useful in the realm of mental disorders. Depression/anxiety/ocd are very complex because they deal with the brain/mind, which is poorly understood. To suggest that antidepressants only have a placebo effect despite working in animal models of depression, severe depression, certain depressive subtypes, and less severe conditions in rats and monkeys is not helpful for many sufferers (like the author) who might otherwise benefit.
Re:Depression lies by ryanmolden on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @01:16AM (#4509259)
Who cares if something works through the placebo effect, as long as it works. I can't be bothered to look it up at the moment (on my mobile) but I do believe he is correct in that published studies in well regarded medical journals have purported to show just that (effect == placebo), but as I said, from the perspective of the person being treated, does it matter? I agree if it prevents people from seeking help that is bout desirable, but it need not.
Re:Depression lies by niels_olson on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @01:27AM (#4509277)
Yes, actually, it does matter. Side effects of antidepressants include the period of getting just enough energy to kill yourself, and the risk of serotonin syndrome, especially when seeing multiple doctors for multiple issues, who might start SSRIs in near succession. The list goes on for a ways.
Re:Depression lies by drumdance on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @11:27AM (#4511082)
Fine, weigh the risks. But don't dismiss it out of hand. I've used SSRIs off an on for years and can honestly say my life is much, much better for having done so.
Re:Depression lies by d0mine on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @06:46PM (#4513679)
The stronger side-effects the more effective placebos. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yfRVCaA5o18
Re:Depression lies by ceol on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @01:34AM (#4509297)
The consensus was that it works in severe cases of depression, but milder ones show little benefit.
Re:Depression lies by jpeg_hero on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @12:34AM (#4509162)
> Medication has a statistical significant effect, but is often marginal at best, and most of the effect is placebo.

The point of the author's post is that medication made a huge difference for him

Hey's saying: if you have a problem, there might be help for you too.

Your comment was just negative side talk.

Re:Depression lies by SoftwareMaven on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @08:22AM (#4510258)
I can't read the full article (paywalls...grumble...), but this[1] would indicate better-than-placebo performance for those with major depression.

Please don't spread unsubstantiated rumors on this topic. As many of us know from personal experience, the results of giving people an excuse to say "that medicine doesn't work anyway" can be devastating.

1. http://psycnet.apa.org/psycinfo/1991-19312-001

Re:Depression lies by philwelch on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @11:29AM (#4511092)
I've gathered that selective publication of results is the main problem, actually.
Re:Depression lies by SoftwareMaven on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @06:06PM (#4513505)
Indeed[1]. It seems to be endemic of the entire medical field[2][3] and even further removed[4]. Combined with how difficult (if not impossible) it is to reproduce many findings[5], I would call these the most important problems in science today. Science cannot move forward without all of the data (positive and negative) in a reproducible fashion.

1. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18199864 2. http://journals.lww.com/greenjournal/Citation/2003/09000/Evi... 3. http://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=198809 4. http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjourna... 5. http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405297020376480457705...

Re:Depression lies by Alex3917 on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @12:25PM (#4511425)
"Please don't spread unsubstantiated rumors on this topic."

You're the one spreading misinformation. How about you actually read some books on the topic before attacking others.

Re:Depression lies by huggah on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @04:36AM (#4509719)
luriel, you added considerably to your post since I first replied, and I feel like it now merits a different response. I agree with almost everything you've said, but feel like your criticism is misdirected and may do more harm than good.

Knowing you have a psychological issue is like knowing your application is crashing for some customers. You might have only vague guesses as to what the triggers are, and no understanding of what's actually going on or how to fix it. But now you are in a position to assess the cost and allocate resources to fix the problem. Maybe it will take years of man-hours (in either case) to handle the problem, but now you have a place to start.

I don't think Wil was telling people to take medicine; I certainly wasn't. The only thing I'd like to emphasize is that Depression is a problem that can be addressed. Don't ignore it. If you have a problem with Depression, do your research; find out what helps, and what doesn't. Stop treating your mental state like it's an immutable part of your environment: change your environment and your behaviors as you discover what you need to be healthier.

"Changes to your environment" might include drugs, and even they don't work over the long term, they might temporarily be enough of a lifeline to help you get to a point where you can start hacking at the problem in other ways. Doctors can be helpful guides on this path; sometimes they're not helpful, but in aggregate, I believe they help more than they hurt. Scaring people away from seeing a doctor by telling them that they'll be locked up in a kafkian institution against their will is liable to prevent people from getting help. Of course this has happened, and continues to happen, but it's rare. I think a much more common (and in aggregate, more serious) mode of failure is people's belief that the doctor is in charge of curing them---that the drugs are all it takes---and that they can't or don't need to work on themselves.

Re:Depression lies by lilsunnybee on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @11:12AM (#4511023)
Yeah this post is really harmful. Antidepressants definitely have significant and varied effects, and those with depression should not be afraid to explore their chemical options, especially if it means lifting out of a life-threatening suicidal phase. Antidepressants affect various neurotransmitters in the brain, either blocking reuptake, or providing artificial analogues, etc. To say they provide mainly a placebo affect is just ludicrous, and suggests a lack of understanding of the science, or any significant practical experience with antidepressants or mental illness.

And at least here in the US, there was a little thing that happened in the 60's called deinstitutionalisation (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deinstitutionalisation). No one is locked up against their will for more than 48 - 72 hours at a time, and even then only if they are deemed to pose a significant threat to themselves or others. Not sure what the situation is like in Sweden, but i can't imagine it would be much different.

Luriel your personal beliefs are ignorant and harmful. Please stop spreading disinformation that could result it people dying or suffering due to not seeking medical assistance for a medical condition.

Re:Depression lies by pharrington on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @01:07PM (#4511678)
Yes, psychoactive chemicals have a very real effect on neurotransmitters; this does not say the physical effect must bear out its stated psychiatric intent. Also while I have no real idea what was going on in the 60s, public mental hospitals in the USA are often terrible to the point of being inhumane. Alot of people I've talked to who've had long and or recurring stays in public institutions compare them, often negatively, to prisons. The private sector is infinitely better in that regard, though.

The real issue is just that psychology and psychiatry are both extremely frontier sciences. I agree that encouraging people to avoid them is harmful, but it's not apparent to me that most of what's happening in those fields isn't still largely guesswork.

Either way, I'd also like to see the studies Luriel's talking about regarding the efficacy of specific meds.

Re:Depression lies by dwj on Friday September 14, 2012 @08:23PM (#4524664)
Actually, the evidence does show that many (most?) antidepressants have little effect over and above placebo. Look at the meta-analyses and you'll see that. I'm not sure why it's ludicrous - that's precisely what the science says.

Now certainly antidepressants can help many people (my wife for one), but again it is likely to be mostly the placebo effect, which is actually very powerful, especially in depression. For some people a placebo can be the 'kick' they need to get help them get out of their depression. In my wife's case she also used CBT with an excellent therapist, and I think that was likely more useful in the long-term (she is now free of depression).

Re:Depression lies by huggah on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @12:09AM (#4509090)
True. It took a few years between accepting that I had a problem and finding a solution to it. For many people, it takes a lot longer; some never "solve" their problem at all. But knowing is a necessary first step, and for me, it was the hardest and the one that would have benefited most from posts like this.
Re:Depression lies by donniezazen on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @12:47AM (#4509193)
What was your solution, if you don't mind sharing?
Re:Depression lies by huggah on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @04:53AM (#4509775)
My only hesitation about sharing is that I don't want people to extrapolate from what worked for me to expect it to work on themselves. So don't.

With that disclaimer, I'll say that I went on several regimens of drugs for a few years. They had serious side effects, didn't work or worked only for a few months. They did keep me afloat long enough to get the rest of my life together.

Stephen Ilardi's "The Depression Cure" is 80% insipid self-help; I'm surprised I didn't throw it away in disgust. The remaining 20% (which is mostly the table of contents) had a profoundly positive effect. It did more good than all the drugs I'd taken combined; but I had to take it seriously and have the willpower to make changes.

In the end, CBT techniques got me to the point where I instinctively revise my thought patterns. Combined with a lifestyle that includes a lot more exercise, time outside, and physical contact with people I care about, I have been un-medicated for almost three years and haven't had a single major depressive episode.

Re:Depression lies by donniezazen on Thursday September 13, 2012 @12:45AM (#4514833)
Do you think pushing yourself to do what you think is right is a right course of action or part of solution to your depression?
Re:Depression lies by huggah on Saturday September 15, 2012 @01:34AM (#4525424)
I don't understand your question. Are you asking whether I think choosing to behave ethically is part of my solution to depression? What do you mean by "do what you think is right"?
Re:Depression lies by borplk on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @02:25AM (#4509403)
I'm noticing some alarming similarities between your description and my current situation. Shit.
Re:Depression lies by huggah on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @05:13AM (#4509826)
Do something! Talk to someone; start with someone you trust (not necessarily a doctor). Catalog your history, list the duration and severity of every time you were depressed enough to impact your school, job, or social life. You're doing this with someone because this is serious trigger territory. If you're on the edge, then do this with a therapist.

Don't try to diagnose yourself from this: the point is to let it sink in that you have an issue, and it's not going to get better unless you do something. Don't skip this step. Now that you're convinced, start hacking at the problem.

I recommend http://www.amazon.com/The-Depression-Cure-Program-without/dp...; but do your own research, talk to people, get better. Get better every day. You'll fail several times along the way; have people you can count on for help. Get better every year.

Maybe it will be an easy, short road for you. Maybe it will be a life-long struggle. That's okay, just make sure you live long enough to find out; it will be worth it. There's only one thing you need to know: problems you ignore won't go away.

Re:Depression lies by chmike on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @01:20AM (#4509267)
You could be bipolar with a hypo maniac phase. You should check this with experts.
Re:Depression lies by huggah on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @05:19AM (#4509843)
I was initially diagnosed with a Major Depressive Disorder; my first round of SSRIs sent me into a manic episode. That was enough to get me diagnosed with Bipolar II. I question whether that was an accurate diagnosis; my experience with bipolar medication was pretty awful, and with behavioral treatments (CBT and environmental changes) I seem to do okay without them, which is much more rare for people who suffer from Bipolar than for people who suffer from MDD.
Re:Depression lies by chmike on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @08:53AM (#4510367)
I'm afraid the bipolar diagnostic is probably right. I would say the recurrence of the depression is a sign of that. Correlation with season variations is the most common, but not the rule.

Medication efficiency and side effect are known to vary individually.

In the end, the only thing that matters is that you find a treatment that helps you to feel and live better. I have heard lithium could help smooth the mood changes. Did you heard of that ? Unfortunately, some people have too bad side effects with it.

Re:Depression lies by Buzaga on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @01:55PM (#4511944)
not even psychiatrists know about their diagnosis, since there's no scientific method at all there, just bullet point stories to try to match with the pacient... so I'd suggest not trying to diagnose people over the internet too
Re:Depression lies by marklabedz on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @03:35PM (#4512652)
Not to mention the politics behind the DSM.