Regardless, the unpredictability of black swans and their potential impact on a fund's returns show the ridiculousness of Dave trying to frame this discussion as "Barry bonds vs ichiro".
Taleb and his theory make for a good story in the wake of the financial meltdown, but the tangible application is sometimes exaggerated [1].
[1]http://www.businessinsider.com/wait-before-you-invest-in-nas...
I got Universa from the Google search blurb from Wikipedia. I got the over 100% figure from http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-10-06/black-swan-money-ma... which quoted "a person familiar with the matter" as saying that the fund brought in 115% during 2008.
However if I read either closely it was obvious that Taleb does not run Universa.
As far as the returns, the 100% figure wouldn't surprise me, really; more than a few bearish funds crushed it during 2008. It just seems like that number is the financial media echo chamber in action. It's repeated over and over in article after article (just look at the citations for it on the Universa wikipedia page). And yet, it always comes from an unnamed source or someone "familiar" with the fund. If there's anything I've learned from the financial crisis, it's that hedge fund managers aren't particularly trustworthy; even less so when they're talking their own book!
They do a lot of their investing in out of the money options. Those are investments that cost very little to make, which will make a lot of money if something very unlikely happens. (You can make these investments on both sides - both up and down.) Lots of people are willing to take the opposing side of the bet based on standard models. If those standard models are significantly underestimating the risk of unusual things happening, then in the long run the black swan strategy will make money.
Since by definition you don't know where a black swan will happen, you also need to spread your investments out across many places. But you don't just diversify, you diversify across very specific classes of investments that are very cheap to make and have a very low probability of paying off.
In the startup analogy you'd want to diversify across as many startups as possible, and invest in them as early as you can.
The only thing I gathered from this is that in his mind 500 startups can't attract or afford the most sought after yc companies and founders and.. That's ok, We're global!
The math on this just doesn't make sense. By definition, the moment a fund has an investment which is a "black swan" that investment will make all the singles and "on base hits" (or whatever) insignificant to the total returns.
I get that he is successful and has a lot of hutzpah but if I was an LP I wouldnt be thrilled by this.