davemthrowaway
What I should have said is: try to think of vcs as investors with a mandate to invest in a specific asset class.
Talking about venture capitalists within the context of what they actually are, rather than stretching athletic metaphors adds a lot of clarity to the discussion. It actually fits quite well with the art dealers and a&r guys you mentioned. Both of them are (basically) investors in a very specific asset class. Each of those asset classes has unique qualities and each of those investors can add value in unique ways.
Lastly, I think you are genuinely trying to contribute and I concede that I may just be ignorant; however, your approach to commenting doesn't make it very clear what you are trying to say. I would suggest that you dial down the complexity of your writing and reduce your use of equations/ variables when words and sentences would do.
Regardless, the unpredictability of black swans and their potential impact on a fund's returns show the ridiculousness of Dave trying to frame this discussion as "Barry bonds vs ichiro".
Do you actually think the patriots and nfl draft picks have more to offer a discussion of venture strategies than the concepts of equity investing and portfolio management which are common to many institutional investors?
As another commenter pointed out, 1000x variations in returns actually happen in venture investments, they don't happen in sports.
The only thing I gathered from this is that in his mind 500 startups can't attract or afford the most sought after yc companies and founders and.. That's ok, We're global!
The math on this just doesn't make sense. By definition, the moment a fund has an investment which is a "black swan" that investment will make all the singles and "on base hits" (or whatever) insignificant to the total returns.
I get that he is successful and has a lot of hutzpah but if I was an LP I wouldnt be thrilled by this.